[RBW] Re: Exceptional Rainwear

2013-07-18 Thread Deacon Patrick
Good luck, Larry. In my experience, if it requires ventilation zips it's not breathable enough and if it requires a coating or laminate, it will wear off and you have a wind jacket at best. In terms of cost, I fully expect this jacket to last 30 years or more and still work as well then as it

Re: [RBW] Re: Exceptional Rainwear

2013-07-18 Thread Matthew J
I have not climbed or hiked in Scotland, but the people I talked with about the Grampians have told me it is a beautiful and difficult place. The high latitude (think northern Canada) combined with winds from Atlantic depressions makes for a difficult climate. That said, I want to get to the

[RBW] Re: Exceptional Rainwear

2013-07-17 Thread KTY
Deacon, I wonder how the Wiggy's Ventile Parkahttp://wiggys.com/moreinfo.cfm?Product_ID=193would compare to the Hilltrek. Wiggy's is the sleeping bag brand that Rivendell sells. On Monday, July 15, 2013 5:14:29 PM UTC-4, Deacon Patrick wrote: The post finally arrived from Scotland with my

[RBW] Re: Exceptional Rainwear

2013-07-17 Thread Deacon Patrick
I talked with Mr. Wiggy (they are also in Colorado, so I tried to go with them first). He doesn't offer the fur analogy liner that Hilltrek does, and for me that was the deciding factor. I also looked into his sleeping bags, but he's big on his manmade insulation and I greatly prefer down (or

[RBW] Re: Exceptional Rainwear

2013-07-17 Thread LF
Patrick, I had great results with a Burley Rainrider, http://www.dirtragmag.com/reviews/burley-rain-rider-jacket waterproof with a good ventilation system. They were pretty popular. The waterproofing stopped working as well as it use to, so I hung it up, in favor of a Patagonia Torrent shell.

Re: [RBW] Re: Exceptional Rainwear

2013-07-16 Thread Deacon Patrick
Indeed, Bob. What frustrates me is I've long asked local and national experts about how to not get wet from sweat but stay dry. They all talked up their systems of choice, but none of them actually work in use. The hypothermia zone is especially dangerous from 25˚F - 60˚F. Add in wet at those

Re: [RBW] Re: Exceptional Rainwear

2013-07-16 Thread Deacon Patrick
Is Scotland's weather so unique a combination of cold and wet that experienced climbers would not normally encounter similar conditions a myriad of other places? Is seems to me the Scots are unique in the ingenuity of their solution more than their weather. Of course I'm guilty of being a

Re: [RBW] Re: Exceptional Rainwear

2013-07-16 Thread Robert Barr
I think you are correct about the jacket being a bargain if it keeps you warn and dry. In the mountains it is too easy to go from cold and wet to real trouble. On Tue, Jul 16, 2013 at 6:15 AM, Deacon Patrick lamontg...@mac.com wrote: Indeed, Bob. What frustrates me is I've long asked local and

Re: [RBW] Re: Exceptional Rainwear

2013-07-16 Thread Robert Barr
I have not climbed or hiked in Scotland, but the people I talked with about the Grampians have told me it is a beautiful and difficult place. The high latitude (think northern Canada) combined with winds from Atlantic depressions makes for a difficult climate. That said, I want to get to the West

[RBW] Re: Exceptional Rainwear

2013-07-15 Thread Michael
Wait a second...you actually didn't sweat under those garments? That is amazing. First I have never heard of rainwear that actually keeps you dry from both the rain, and your own sweat! What were the temps you were riding in? I have read that breatheable materials don't breathe unless

[RBW] Re: Exceptional Rainwear

2013-07-15 Thread Deacon Patrick
Did I sweat? Yes. Did the sweat have somewhere to go (both liquid and vapor)? Yes. It breathes as well as a heavy cotton shirt. Because it's cotton (yes, the stuff everyone says will kill you. They don't know about ventile). The mechanism for how it works is completely different from the

[RBW] Re: Exceptional Rainwear

2013-07-15 Thread Will
There are limits. In my closet rests the original Sierra Designs 60/40 parka. The lining is ventile cotton. It is way cool. There is no question that the Sierra Design parka exhausts moisture better than my Arc'Teryx Gortex parka. Although they are remarkably similar design-wise. That

[RBW] Re: Exceptional Rainwear

2013-07-15 Thread Michael
It is in the 80's - 100's here in MD with high humidity in the summer. I am basically drenched in sweat when riding until fall, when it gets back into the 50's. So I think that means no breatheable stuff will matter in those conditions of summer. It was around 100 I think on Saturday when

[RBW] Re: Exceptional Rainwear

2013-07-15 Thread Deacon Patrick
Capillary action of fur. *Capillary action* (sometimes *capillarity*, *capillary motion*, or * wicking*) is the ability of a liquid http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liquid to flow in narrow spaces without the assistance of, and in opposition to, external forces like gravity

[RBW] Re: Exceptional Rainwear

2013-07-15 Thread Deacon Patrick
For 70+˚F and high humidity with rain, I would wear shorts and t-shirt. Colorado's mountains don't get that combo. Storms drop us to 50-60 or lower. So we may start out at 80, but cool down fast with the storm. Scotland has used boiled, lanolined wool for hundreds of years at least for

Re: [RBW] Re: Exceptional Rainwear

2013-07-15 Thread Robert Barr
In the 90s Americans climbing in Scotland were frustrated with their mountaineering gear made for cold dry conditions. They were getting drenched with sweat during exertion and then freezing when they slowed down, They noticed that the Scottish climbers were using a very different clothing system

Re: [RBW] Re: Exceptional Rainwear

2013-07-15 Thread Deacon Patrick
Exactly, Bob. You are clearly ahead of my slow learning curve. I wish I'd found this 15 years ago (when the Nikwax analogy first came out, though the blending with the ventile is fairly new). Paramo make a nylon version of the same concept if you prefer nylon (Hilltrek sells it, not sure if

Re: [RBW] Re: Exceptional Rainwear

2013-07-15 Thread Robert Barr
Patrick - we learn together. When you are comfortable with constant rain, back and forth, exert and sweat/rest, you are doing well. And when you can do that in the difficult temperatures of 50 - 60 degrees I think you have success. Bob On Mon, Jul 15, 2013 at 10:42 PM, Deacon Patrick