Re: [WISPA] To Break the Law or Not to Break the Law...That is theQuestion

2006-02-06 Thread Mark Koskenmaki
- Original Message - From: "David E. Smith" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "WISPA General List" Sent: Sunday, February 05, 2006 7:23 PM Subject: Re: [WISPA] To Break the Law or Not to Break the Law...That is theQuestion > Scott Reed wrote: > > > I must b

Re: [WISPA] To Break the Law or Not to Break the Law...That is theQuestion

2006-02-05 Thread Bob Moldashel
PersonallyI think the biggest fear is filing a report, showing up on the radar screen, and having "big brother" come out to your place "for a look". And considering the amount of non-compliant type accepted systems out there.I can see their point. And don't think there aren't people ou

Re: [WISPA] To Break the Law or Not to Break the Law...That is theQuestion

2006-02-05 Thread Bob Moldashel
David E. Smith wrote: Bob Moldashel wrote: BTW: What happens when the Commission provides my information to someone who asks for it??? Then what??? I would love to hear the official response to how this is handled. Um, did you see that part of the form where you can request the

Re: [WISPA] To Break the Law or Not to Break the Law...That is theQuestion

2006-02-05 Thread David E. Smith
Scott Reed wrote: > I must be missing something in this discussion. I tell the > FCC I have x customers in y zip codes and what percentage is wireless, > what percentage is wired. > > Many have posted more company confidential information that on this > and other forums. Anyone who's working th

Re: [WISPA] To Break the Law or Not to Break the Law...That is theQuestion

2006-02-05 Thread Mark Koskenmaki
- Original Message - From: "David E. Smith" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "WISPA General List" Sent: Sunday, February 05, 2006 7:15 PM Subject: Re: [WISPA] To Break the Law or Not to Break the Law...That is theQuestion > Bob Moldashel wrote: > > >

Re: [WISPA] To Break the Law or Not to Break the Law...That is theQuestion

2006-02-05 Thread David E. Smith
Bob Moldashel wrote: > BTW: What happens when the Commission provides my information to someone > who asks for it??? Then what??? > > I would love to hear the official response to how this is handled. Um, did you see that part of the form where you can request the FCC treat your submission a

Re: [WISPA] To Break the Law or Not to Break the Law...That is theQuestion

2006-02-05 Thread Scott Reed
Networking Network Design, Installation and Administration www.nwwnet.net -- Original Message --- From: Bob Moldashel <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: WISPA General List , WISPA General List Sent: Sun, 05 Feb 2006 21:41:05 -0500 Subject: Re: [WISPA] To Break the Law or

Re: [WISPA] To Break the Law or Not to Break the Law...That is theQuestion

2006-02-05 Thread Bob Moldashel
I know it would sure help alot if we didn't have to submit the form to the "Wireline Competition Bureau" at the FCC. Kinda like mailing the information to your competition. BTW: What happens when the Commission provides my information to someone who asks for it??? Then what??? I would love

Re: [WISPA] To Break the Law or Not to Break the Law...That is theQuestion

2006-02-05 Thread Peter R.
Why not set up a website on wispa.org that would collect the data - anonymously? Collect all the data they want through the organization and send them the database or the raw data. This would give those that did not want to follow the guidelines an alternative that the FCC may accept. Regard

Re: [WISPA] To Break the Law or Not to Break the Law...That is theQuestion

2006-02-05 Thread George
Scott Reed wrote: I plan to file again, just I did last fall. I want them to know I am here and I need additional spectrum. If the rest of you don't file, I will suffer because there is no need for the spectrum to be given to a group that does not exist. I do not necessarily agree with all

Re: [WISPA] To Break the Law or Not to Break the Law...That is theQuestion

2006-02-05 Thread Scott Reed
nt: Sun, 05 Feb 2006 02:33:46 -0500 Subject: Re: [WISPA] To Break the Law or Not to Break the Law...That is      theQuestion > > > >Let's just get clear right up front...   It appears you believe that if we > >all appear to be good boy scouts and have feel-good

Re: [WISPA] To Break the Law or Not to Break the Law...That is theQuestion

2006-02-05 Thread Brian Rohrbacher
I'm just flat out scared of the FCC. The way they are in bed with AT&T and the likes. To be honest, I can get by on what I have. (900, 2.4, 5.8) 3.6, 700, and TV bands would be nice, but what is the cost? I'd rather hide in the corner with a tin foil hat and not exist. John Scrivner wrot

Re: [WISPA] To Break the Law or Not to Break the Law...That is theQuestion

2006-02-05 Thread John Scrivner
There is going to have to be a compromise here guys. We will not be putting together the composite subscriber data for the FCC. There are no provisions for it. We can ask but then quite frankly I am not too keen on telling them that most of our members here seem to be reluctant to tell them who

Re: [WISPA] To Break the Law or Not to Break the Law...That is theQuestion

2006-02-04 Thread Brian Rohrbacher
Let's just get clear right up front... It appears you believe that if we all appear to be good boy scouts and have feel-good politics, we're more likely to get what we want considered. I disagree. I dont' think it'll get us even 3 seconds reconsideration. But I do believe if we make forc

Re: [WISPA] To Break the Law or Not to Break the Law...That is theQuestion

2006-02-04 Thread Mark Koskenmaki
- Original Message - From: "John Scrivner" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: Sent: Saturday, February 04, 2006 11:30 AM Subject: [WISPA] To Break the Law or Not to Break the Law...That is theQuestion > I think we seem to have a little bit of twisting of thoughts and words >