> That was the point of weakening the copyleft a bit by using MPL or
> LGPL. The MPL does not require that code linked to it is licensed
> under a compatible license. It just doesn't care.

Which is great for adoption. If we could patch a BSD clause on top, it
provides added benefits, but not necessary.

> > (I don't think they are bad, I think they are evil)
> 
> Yes, software patents are evil.

Evil evil evil.

> The MPL would stop commercial entities from taking the SharpOS code,
> making some changes/improvements, and closing it off (a so-called
> "closed fork" in the BSD/permissive model). I'm interested in this
> because I want to see the improvements to my code, and they shouldn't
> be able to stop me from doing that. Especially if they build their
> business around my hard work.

I'm ok with that and understand your sentiments. 

> Yes they should in my mind. I once worked at a restaurant where I had
> to sign an NDA for their recipes and I was appalled. I needed a job at
> the time but I cringed when my signature hit the line. It's a sin I'm

I don't want to get into politics - but Id say you have a choice not to work
there. :)

> still atoning for. Is it coincidence that your other example is one of
> the most corrupt industries in America today?

They arent just in America. I have my own views on many things including
America, but they arent suited for here and I'll refrain from injecting
them. I try to pick generic examples. I don't belive prescription drugs are
unique to America. We have Pfizer, Bayer, etc here in Europe.

> Mono would still be used, I know. Why? Because I would use it. Would

It would be used - but much much less, and because of that it would be much
much less than it is, which would further reduce it use because its
usefulness would be les...

> you use it? No, but not everyone agrees. But I'm not recommending a
> blanket GPL license here, I've already said MPL, LGPL or another weak
> copyleft license would do just fine as a compromise.

I think were in agreement now, just need to see others opinions. I wasnt
targeting my GPL input to you, but for others who might not know GPL etc..

I also think it simplifies things a lot both for us and users if we use one
license, instead of mixing some parts on one, some parts on another.




-------------------------------------------------------------------------
This SF.net email is sponsored by: Splunk Inc.
Still grepping through log files to find problems?  Stop.
Now Search log events and configuration files using AJAX and a browser.
Download your FREE copy of Splunk now >>  http://get.splunk.com/
_______________________________________________
SharpOS-Developers mailing list
SharpOS-Developers@lists.sourceforge.net
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/sharpos-developers

Reply via email to