I don't think that is an option as AD isn't going to give up source code which 
holds many patents. If they did, I would tend to think the asking price would 
be too steep.

But let's pretend AD offers the source code and the price is affordable - is 
Softimage really worth the price of acquiring as a business venture?  Based on 
all the pieces of information I've gathered about the product over the years, 
it sounds like it would take a few years just to get familiar with the code and 
be comfortable enough to do any significant work.

While one could inherit a nice system like ICE, animation mixer, render pass 
system, and so on.  To put new features into it would likely require a lot of 
study of existing code for ripple effect of adding new features or implementing 
significant changes.  The application as a whole is still tremendously useful 
and a great general purpose 3D environment, but it's design is from the 1990's 
and showing its age in some areas.  The user interface is still single 
threaded, the playback engine isn't the speediest and doesn't loop nicely, and 
the real time shaders aren't real time.  Some of the things we would want to 
implement in Softimage if we had the source code would be things that I don't 
think the architecture supports - ability to put modeling operators outside the 
modeling marker or pin them into specific slots of the construction history to 
enforce order of evaluation, for example.

On a personal level, having been around the product for so long I would be 
extremely interested in looking and tinkering with the source code, and perhaps 
fix/modify stuff that always drove me nuts.  It would at least explain why 
certain things are the way they are.  I always thought it be a nice gesture if 
at Siggraph you'd get swag in the form of a capsule on a keychain that 
contained all the source code to discontinued product(s).  Granted, this will 
not likely ever happen due to patents, trade secrets, and other business 
interests, but would be good for customer morale and developing interest in 3D 
animation.  I wonder if anybody would gain anything (business-wise) from 
obtaining the Softimage|3D code today considering its successor is also on its 
way out to pasture?  It would be more useful swag than T-shirts or CD cases.



As for my employer, I cannot speak on their behalf.




Matt







>Hey Matt --
>
>Out of genuine curiosity -- can your employers not get a source code license 
>out of AD?  IIR, deals like that were
>not unknown among the larger studios -- or was that all pre-acquisition?
>
>Ed

Reply via email to