2014-10-21 15:39 GMT+02:00 Jerry Clough - OSM <sk53_...@yahoo.co.uk>:

>    - Use of the shop tag is inherently problematic. These are not shops
>    but retail areas. At the moment whenever I do any kind of retail analytical
>    query I have to do AND NOT IN (shop='mall'). I would prefer to use
>    landuse=retail with retail=mall or retail=shopping centre etc. We certainly
>    don't tag a centre of a village with a few shops as shop=village_centre.

The centre of a village is much more than just shops, but that's another
discussion ;-)

I agree with you that shop=shopping_centre or mall is not a good tag,
unlike shop=department_store or supermarket, these are indeed entities
consisting of several shops. On the other hand, landuse doesn't seem a nice
tag to me neither, as it is about the use of land, an attribute. Yes,
landuse=retail and retail=mall will indicate that this land is used for a
mall, but I'd consider this an indirect way of stating: "there must be some
shopping mall over there", rather than explicitly naming the feature (e.g.
amenity=shopping_centre would be a candidate), and I could also imagine
situations where several landuse objects together form one shopping mall or
centre (because they are interrupted in the middle by something else).

Tagging mailing list

Reply via email to