a.ashfield <[email protected]> wrote:
> Jed says he thinks it it impossible to measure the performance of a black > box by measuring the input and output, without knowing how the heat is > dissipated from the output. That is clearly not true. > I did not say it is impossible. Please do not put words in my mouth. I said that when you do not have access to a 1 MW plant you cannot be sure it is real. I said that Rossi's data is a god-awful mess and it needs to be confirmed. I said that no one would pay $89 million without confirming there is 1 MW factory equipment in operation. The fact that Rossi did not allow anyone in to see the factory equipment is extremely suspicious, to say the least. It makes me think there was no factory. There are several other reasons to think there was no factory; i.e., apparently no one was in there, there was no noise, there is no chimney, etc. > Also, I have seen sufficient number of reports of others finding > anomalous heat to be persuaded LENR is real. Others think so too. See > www.lenrproof.com LENR is real. Rossi's 1 MW reactor is not. Some of his previous devices may have been producing excess heat. It is difficult to judge because his methods are so sloppy. - Jed
