a.ashfield <[email protected]> wrote: Jed. I did not say it is impossible. Please do not put words in my mouth. > > AA. You said it was not possible to know if the 1 MW plant produced 1 MW > without knowing where the output went > This is just a variant of what I quoted you as saying. >
You misunderstood. I meant that the calorimetry is so bad you could not confirm 1 MW unless you saw the customer machine. Actually, every indication is that there is no excess heat. So perhaps I should say, the only possible remaining proof of 1 MW would be seeing the customer machine. With properly done calorimetry, yes, it is possible to confirm 1 MW. Although even with that you would still want to see the customer machine as a reality check. You sure as heck would not accept a result when the fluid goes out of the room in one pipe and comes in another, without seeing the entire circuit! That is absurd. No one would pay $89 million without doing every reasonable reality check and method of verification. - Jed
