Axil Axil <[email protected]> wrote:
> *The results of transmutation from the proton 21 experiments have been > replicated by Sandia National Laboratories* > Yes, but they determined the results have a prosaic cause: contamination. Not transmutation. > *I would think that Sandia labs would have tried with all their power to > eliminate all contamination that concerned them . . .* > I expect they did try. And I expect they are better at doing that than the people at Proton-21. But it is not possible to eliminate all contamination. Detection technology is far more advanced the purification techniques. > *as expert experimentalists but they were not able to so: “although the > surface contamination cannot be validated”. But they still were unable to > accept the results of the experiments.* > The point is, they were not able to eliminate contamination and it is not likely the people at Proton-21 were able to eliminate it either. Their results can be explained as contamination, and it is likely that so can the Proton-21 results. Until several people independently replicate, you cannot be sure of a one-off, unique result such as this one. It is suggestive at best. - Jed
