4 tons of carbon electrodes would be a production problem.  Plus the resulting 
steel would have strange specifications—welding may be impossible—
Bob cook

Sent from Mail for Windows 10

From: Jones Beene
Sent: Saturday, March 11, 2017 11:44 PM
To: vortex-l@eskimo.com
Subject: Re: [Vo]:Sleeper from ICCF20

Eric,
Converting anything into iron would be endothermic, and there is an electric 
arc to supply power, but hardly enough for transmutation ... of even a few 
ounces.
What they may overlooked is a monoclinic iron carbide which is 40% carbon ... 
and which is a good and even an expected candidate for the so-called 
"excess"... since they do not specify how much of the carbon electrode has been 
lost.

Eric Walker wrote:
Jones Beene wrote:
"The daily input of Si and Fe was 20.479 tons at his smelting plant, and the 
output was 24.75 tons. There was a daily excess of 4.27 tons of iron and 
silica."

A process that would produce 4 tons of iron from another element in one day 
would probably imply the release (or consumption) of an astounding amount of 
energy.  When a nuclear bomb explodes, only a relatively small amount of the 
fissile material is converted to other elements.

Eric



Reply via email to