dev
Thread
Date
Earlier messages
Later messages
Messages by Date
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] Fix VM scaling: use ScaleVirtualMachine instead of ChangeServiceForVirtualMachine [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [I] Kubernetes Cluster resource missing externalloadbalanceripaddress and enablecsi parameters [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [I] destcidrlist isn't supported for cloudstack_egress_firewall [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] Feature: Add dest_cidr_list support to egress firewall [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [I] data.cloudstack_instance filters not working [CS 4.21][CTP 0.6.0] [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] Fix cloudstack_instance data source ignoring project [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
[PR] Fix VM scaling: use ScaleVirtualMachine instead of ChangeServiceForVirtualMachine [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] Add externalloadbalanceripaddress field to KubernetesCluster struct [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] Add externalloadbalanceripaddress and enablecsi to kubernetes_cluster resource [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] Fix userdata details being improperly serialized [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
[PR] Add externalloadbalanceripaddress and enablecsi to kubernetes_cluster resource [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
[PR] Add externalloadbalanceripaddress field to KubernetesCluster struct [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] Add GPU support: gpu_card / vgpu_profile data sources and GPU on service offerings [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] Add GPU support: gpu_card / vgpu_profile data sources and GPU on service offerings [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] chore(deps): bump golang.org/x/crypto from 0.36.0 to 0.45.0 [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] chore(deps): bump golang.org/x/crypto from 0.36.0 to 0.45.0 [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
[PR] Bump golang.org/x/crypto from 0.36.0 to 0.52.0 [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] Add GPU support: gpu_card / vgpu_profile data sources and GPU on service offerings [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
[PR] Bump google.golang.org/grpc from 1.66.2 to 1.82.1 [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] Bugfix: Implement egress firewall cidr validation [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] Bugfix: Implement egress firewall cidr validation [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] Bugfix: Implement egress firewall cidr validation [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] Service offering resource update [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] Add bypass_vlan_overlap_check parameter to cloudstack_private_gateway [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] Add bypass_vlan_overlap_check parameter to cloudstack_private_gateway [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [I] IPv6 Support [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] Add IPv6 support to cloudstack_network resource [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [I] cloudstack_security_group_rule does not allowsetting `protocol = "all"` [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] Allow 'all' on security group rule protocol [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] Declarative storage network IP range [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [I] Support requesting a specific IP address [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] Support requesting a specific IP address in cloudstack_ipaddress [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [I] Create data get kubernetes cluster kubeconfig using terraform [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] Add cloudstack_kubernetes_cluster_config data source [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] Fix UserData not being found when added to a project [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] add support for enabling delete protection [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
[PR] Fix cloudstack_instance data source ignoring project [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [I] cloudstack_port_forward always returns error (but really succeeds) [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] Unnecessary requirement for `project` in resources [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/17
Re: [PR] add support for enabling delete protection [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/16
Re: [PR] Add bypass_vlan_overlap_check parameter to cloudstack_private_gateway [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/16
Re: [PR] deprecate cloudstack_service_offering [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/16
Re: [PR] Add cloudstack_role_permission resource [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/16
Re: [I] destcidrlist isn't supported for cloudstack_egress_firewall [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/16
Re: [PR] Add bypass_vlan_overlap_check parameter to cloudstack_private_gateway [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/16
Re: [PR] add support for vpc internal lb [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/16
Re: [PR] add bypass_vlan_check to network and private_gateway [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/16
Re: [PR] Fix infinite update loop for optional zone fields [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/16
Re: [PR] add option to configure destination cidr in egress firewall rules [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/16
Re: [PR] add option to configure destination cidr in egress firewall rules [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/16
Re: [I] destcidrlist isn't supported for cloudstack_egress_firewall [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
Re: [I] cloudstack_network_acl_rule: read returns the rule UUID in cidr_list and protocol, making imported ACLs permanently dirty [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
[I] cloudstack_network_acl_rule: read returns the rule UUID in cidr_list and protocol, making imported ACLs permanently dirty [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
Re: [PR] Add support for internal LB [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
[PR] Add support for internal LB [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
Re: [VOTE] Version naming: drop the "4." prefix starting with release 24
Kiran Chavala
2026/08/14
Re: [VOTE] Version naming: drop the "4." prefix starting with release 24
João Jandre
2026/08/14
Re: [PR] Unnecessary requirement for `project` in resources [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
Re: [PR] Unnecessary requirement for `project` in resources [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
Re: [VOTE] Version naming: drop the "4." prefix starting with release 24
Rohit Yadav via dev
2026/08/14
Re: [VOTE] Version naming: drop the "4." prefix starting with release 24
Rohit Yadav via dev
2026/08/14
Re: [PR] chore(deps): bump github.com/hashicorp/terraform-plugin-framework from 1.12.0 to 1.17.0 [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
Re: [PR] chore(deps): bump github.com/hashicorp/terraform-plugin-framework from 1.12.0 to 1.17.0 [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
Re: [PR] chore(deps): bump github.com/hashicorp/terraform-plugin-testing from 1.7.0 to 1.14.0 [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
Re: [PR] chore(deps): bump github.com/hashicorp/terraform-plugin-testing from 1.7.0 to 1.14.0 [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
Re: [PR] add support for enabling delete protection [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
[PR] Data disk attachment on VM creation [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
Re: [PR] Data disk attachment on VM creation [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
[PR] Allow multiple nics [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
Re: [PR] Allow multiple nics [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
Re: [PR] added bypass_vlan_check to network and private_gateway resources [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
Re: [PR] deprecate cloudstack_service_offering [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
Re: [PR] add support for enabling delete protection [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
Re: [PR] Add nexthop parameter to cloudstack_static_route resource [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
Re: [PR] add bypass_vlan_check to network and private_gateway [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
Re: [PR] Network ACL Rules modifications cause churn due to being a TypeList [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
Re: [I] cloudstack_network_acl_rule modifies all rules after inserted rule [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
Re: [VOTE] Version naming: drop the "4." prefix starting with release 24
Abhishek Kumar
2026/08/14
Re: [PR] Fix traffic type import due to incorrect parameter [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
Re: [PR] Unnecessary requirement for `project` in resources [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
Re: [VOTE] Version naming: drop the "4." prefix starting with release 24
Daan Hoogland
2026/08/14
Re: [PR] feat: make cidr optional for L2 networks [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
Re: [PR] Update cloudstack-go to v2.19.1 [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
Re: [PR] Update cloudstack-go to v2.19.1 [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
Re: [PR] fix: make cidr optional for L2 network creation [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/14
[VOTE] Version naming: drop the "4." prefix starting with release 24
Wido den Hollander via dev
2026/08/13
Re: [PR] fix: make cidr optional for L2 network creation [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/13
[PR] Update cloudstack-go to v2.19.1 [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/12
Re: [PR] Add Damans227 to collaborators list [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/12
Re: [PR] Enhance cloudstack_disk_offering resource and datasource [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/12
[PR] Add GPU support: gpu_card / vgpu_profile data sources and GPU on service offerings [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/12
[PR] Add tags and import support to service offerings; fix zone_ids handling [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/12
[PR] Mp/disk offering [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/12
Re: [PR] Add cloudstack_kubernetes_cluster_config data source [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/12
Re: [PR] Add cloudstack_kubernetes_cluster_config data source [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/12
[PR] Add cloudstack_kubernetes_cluster_config data source [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/11
Re: [PR] Support requesting a specific IP address in cloudstack_ipaddress [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/11
[PR] Support requesting a specific IP address in cloudstack_ipaddress [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/11
[Announce] CloudStack-Go v2.19.1
Abhisar Sinha
2026/08/11
Re: [PR] Fix list response keys derived from the API name [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/11
Re: Proposal: Small UI Enhancements for CloudStack Storage Workflows
Rajiv Jain
2026/08/11
Re: Proposal: Small UI Enhancements for CloudStack Storage Workflows
Wido den Hollander via dev
2026/08/11
Proposal: Small UI Enhancements for CloudStack Storage Workflows
Rajiv Jain
2026/08/11
[I] How customize loadbalancer config? [cloudstack-kubernetes-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/11
Re: [PR] Fix list response keys derived from the API name [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/11
[PR] Fix list response keys derived from the API name [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/11
Re: [I] Bug Report: Userdata request size limits [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/11
Re: [I] Bug Report: Userdata request size limits [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/11
Re: [I] Bug Report: Userdata request size limits [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/11
Re: [I] Bug Report: Userdata request size limits [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/11
Re: [I] Bug Report: Userdata request size limits [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/11
hackathon at Apache CoC
Daan Hoogland
2026/08/11
Re: UI blocks snapshot for iSCSI-backed VMs (stopped state) but createVMSnapshot API works
Daan Hoogland
2026/08/10
Re: [PR] Feature: Add dest_cidr_list support to egress firewall [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/10
Re: [I] destcidrlist isn't supported for cloudstack_egress_firewall [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/10
Re: [PR] Feature: Add dest_cidr_list support to egress firewall [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/10
Re: [I] Traffic Types not handled correctly [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/10
Re: [PR] Allow 'all' on security group rule protocol [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/10
Re: [PR] Fix egress firewall rules to support all-ports without explicit ports [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/10
Re: [PR] Fix the servicecapabilitylist type for create VPC & Network Offerings [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/10
Re: [I] cannot unmarshal object into Go struct field ListVirtualMachinesResponse.virtualmachine.vnfnics of type string [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/10
Re: [PR] Fix listing virtual machines with vnfnics [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/10
Re: [PR] feat: make cidr optional for L2 networks [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/10
Re: [PR] Add IPv6 support to cloudstack_network resource [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/10
Re: [PR] feat: make cidr optional for L2 networks [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/10
Re: [PR] Fix acceptance test failures [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/10
Re: [PR] Unnecessary requirement for `project` in resources [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/10
Re: [I] data.cloudstack_instance filters not working [CS 4.21][CTP 0.6.0] [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/10
Re: [PR] Fix acceptance test failures [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/10
[PR] Fix acceptance test failures [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/10
Re: [PR] Unnecessary requirement for `project` in resources [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/10
Re: [PR] Unnecessary requirement for `project` in resources [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/08
Re: [PR] Add autocomplete support for API allowedValues [cloudstack-cloudmonkey]
via GitHub
2026/08/08
Re: [PR] Use Related metadata for autocomplete API discovery [cloudstack-cloudmonkey]
via GitHub
2026/08/07
UI blocks snapshot for iSCSI-backed VMs (stopped state) but createVMSnapshot API works
Ragi, Sathvika via dev
2026/08/07
[PR] adding go cache to gitignore file [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/07
Re: [PR] adding go cache to gitignore file [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/07
Re: [PR] disk offering updates [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/07
[PR] disk offering updates [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/07
Re: In updatestoragepool API the provider's lifecycle method call is missing
Wei ZHOU
2026/08/07
In updatestoragepool API the provider's lifecycle method call is missing
Ragi, Sathvika via dev
2026/08/07
Re: [VOTE] Apache CloudStack 4.23.0.0 (RC2)
Nicolas Vazquez
2026/08/07
Re: 4.22.2 Release plan
Andrija Panic
2026/08/07
Re: [VOTE] Apache CloudStack 4.23.0.0 (RC2)
Wei ZHOU
2026/08/07
Re: 4.22.2 Release plan
Daan Hoogland
2026/08/06
Re: [PROPOSAL] Terraform Provider release
Brad House
2026/08/06
random question about mbx
Abel Micheal
2026/08/06
Re: [PR] Add support for prepare and cancel maintenance [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/06
Re: [PR] Add support for 4.22.1.0 release [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/06
Re: [VOTE] Apache CloudStack 4.23.0.0 (RC2)
Nicolas Vazquez
2026/08/06
Re: [Proposal] CloudMonkey v6.6.0 - Release
Boris Stoyanov
2026/08/06
Re: [Proposal] CloudMonkey v6.6.0 - Release
Andrija Panic
2026/08/06
Re: [PROPOSAL] Terraform Provider release
Suresh Kumar Anaparti
2026/08/06
4.22.2 Release plan
Vladimir Petrov
2026/08/06
Re: [PROPOSAL] Terraform Provider release
Suresh Kumar Anaparti
2026/08/06
Re: [VOTE] Apache CloudStack 4.23.0.0 (RC2)
Slavka Peleva
2026/08/06
Re: [PR] Updated MS maintenance APIs [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/06
Re: [Proposal] CloudMonkey v6.6.0 - Release
Andrija Panic
2026/08/06
Re: [VOTE] Apache CloudStack 4.23.0.0 (RC2)
Andrija Panic
2026/08/06
Re: [PR] Fix nil panic in UpdateCache when listapisresponse is empty (#211) [cloudstack-cloudmonkey]
via GitHub
2026/08/06
Re: [PR] Use Related metadata for autocomplete API discovery [cloudstack-cloudmonkey]
via GitHub
2026/08/06
Re: [PR] Fix nil panic in UpdateCache when listapisresponse is empty (#211) [cloudstack-cloudmonkey]
via GitHub
2026/08/06
Re: [PR] Add autocomplete support for API allowedValues [cloudstack-cloudmonkey]
via GitHub
2026/08/06
[Proposal] CloudMonkey v6.6.0 - Release
Boris Stoyanov
2026/08/05
Re: [VOTE] Apache CloudStack 4.23.0.0 (RC2)
Wido den Hollander via dev
2026/08/05
Re: [DISCUSS] Versioning of CloudStack in 2027 and beyond
Andrija Panic
2026/08/05
Re: [PR] Fix JSON tag mismatch for metrics responses [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/05
Re: [PR] Fix list-response JSON tags + guard getRawValue against empty arrays [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/05
Re: [PR] Fix datadisksdetails [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/05
Re: [PR] Fix details serialization in ImportVmParams [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/05
Re: [PR] Updated MS maintenance APIs [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/05
Re: [PR] Fix dropped generate error [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/05
Re: [PR] Updated MS maintenance APIs [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/05
Re: [PR] Updated MS maintenance APIs [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/05
Re: [PR] Fix panic when serializing UUID-typed request parameters [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/05
Re: [PR] Add support for 4.22.1.0 release [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/05
Re: [PR] Add support for managing Storage access groups [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/05
Re: [PR] Adds support to upload k8s ISO from local [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/05
Re: [PR] Fix listing virtual machines with vnfnics [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/05
Re: [PR] Feature: Add dest_cidr_list support to egress firewall [cloudstack-terraform-provider]
via GitHub
2026/08/05
[PR] Fix listing virtual machines with vnfnics [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/05
Re: [PR] Add support for 4.22.1.0 release [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/05
Re: [PR] Adds support to upload k8s ISO from local [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/05
Re: [DISCUSS] Versioning of CloudStack in 2027 and beyond
Wido den Hollander via dev
2026/08/05
Re: [PR] Adds support to upload k8s ISO from local [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/05
Re: [I] GetTemplateByName with zoneid constraint fails on template in multiple zones [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/05
Re: [PR] Scope GetTemplateByName/GetIsoByName by-ID lookup to the zone (#87) [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/04
Re: [DISCUSS] Versioning of CloudStack in 2027 and beyond
Daan Hoogland
2026/08/04
Re: [PR] Add support for 4.22.1.0 release [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/04
Re: [PR] Add support for managing guest OS category - create, delete, update [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/04
Re: [VOTE] Apache CloudStack 4.23.0.0 (RC2)
Wei ZHOU
2026/08/04
Re: [DISCUSS] Versioning of CloudStack in 2027 and beyond
Andrija Panic
2026/08/04
Re: [DISCUSS] Make egress "allow" the default for Isolated networks (configurable)
Andrija Panic
2026/08/04
Re: [DISCUSS] Versioning of CloudStack in 2027 and beyond
Paul Angus via dev
2026/08/04
Re: [PR] Updated MS maintenance APIs [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/04
Re: [PR] Fix panic when serializing UUID-typed request parameters [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/04
[PR] Fix panic when serializing UUID-typed request parameters [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/04
Re: [PR] Fix list-response JSON tags + guard getRawValue against empty arrays [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/04
Re: [PR] Adds support to upload k8s ISO from local [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
2026/08/04
Re: [PR] Add support for managing Storage access groups [cloudstack-go]
via GitHub
Earlier messages
Later messages