Not sure if it helps for CTR/RTC, ASF does host a review board instance ( https://reviews.apache.org ).
Personally, I agree with Justin's sentiments about process. I do see a number of projects that use RTC. They're generally projects dominated by a single vendor. John On Tue, Jan 3, 2017 at 6:22 AM Von Gosling <[email protected]> wrote: > Hi, > > 1. Refer to RTC or CTR problem > > For commit, may be, we could use CTR. For PR, we would prefer to RTC. We > are high valuing the quality in RocketMQ. So, it is a better way to use the > conservative strategy from my opinion :-) > > 2. Refer to PPMC and committer relationship > Thanks Justin refers. We are not familiar with Apache recommended way for > this problem. But i have learn about something about PMC additional > responsibilities. IMO, we really want to keep the community diversity. > Committer may be a good candidate for entering into PMC. For the same > reason, contributor may be a good candidate for becoming Committer. > > AFAIK, Apache Tomcat have separate the PMC member and committer role. And, > Apache Storm may regard as the committer as PMC member when someone make a > great achievement for the project[1]. > > 1. http://storm.apache.org/contribute/People.html < > http://storm.apache.org/contribute/People.html> > > > > > 在 2017年1月3日，16:33，Justin Mclean <[email protected]> 写道： > > > > Hi, > > > >> IMO, not only the number of PR, more concerned about the quality of PR. > > > > Just try not to have the bar too high / wait too long to vote potential > candidates in. This may discourage people being invoved and hinder > community growth. But it’s totally up to this PPMC to decide this. > > > >> PPMC number of members should be less than the number of committer, > IMHO, > >> the committers are not all PPMC. > > > > Which is fine being a PPMC/PMC member had additional responsibilities [1] > > > >> RTC +1 The reference quality is the first priority. > > > > JFYI This is uncommon in Apache projects and all projects I have been > involved in have been CTR. In CTR any commit is just a revert away. I’ve > not seen many cases where it’s been an issue, especially where you have > good test coverage and code quality metrics. But again it’s totally up to > the PPMC to decide. > > > > Thanks, > > Justin > > > > 1. https://www.apache.org/dev/pmc.html#policy > >
