I am a bit confused by all this we proposed making small changes so we
have room to add external applications that give us
room to test/try different solutions for adding functions. if people
react to this vote it seems 'we want to see all effects of what this
means within the taglibs, how its implemented and could be
implemented'. This makes this whole hack vote useless since its forced
into a project (with effects in taglibs, core, editors, xml's,
reflections and a whole range of other places).

again, I like the idea of the hack, and i also see the need for functions in the core of MMBase.
The problem with this proposal is that, for me, it is not clear what the hack actually incorporates...


I don't think it is necessary to make a project of it. But if you want to donate your code to the community it has to be clear what you donate, why you donate it, what the purpose of the hack is, i would like to see the actual source code (not source code that still needs modifications), some kind of design... I really think up till now the problem is not the idea of the hack itself, but the lack of good communication.

Rob





Reply via email to