On 06/03/11 21:10, John Mikes wrote:
A problem (in my mind) about "compute": does 'computing' include an
evaluation of the result automatically, *_by the device itself_*, or
does it need a /*_"thinking" mind_*/ to valuate the computation? Does
'comp' */_act_/* upon the result of its own computation? ( H O W ? )
Also the word _"automatically"_ raises the question whether it
requires some homunculus(?) - (call it a factor or any presently
unknown dynamics?) instigating it for us rather than - or even BUILT
IN as - a not-yet discovered intrinsic part of the functionality to be
With my agnosticism (ignorance about the not-yet disclosed parts of
the wholeness) it is hard to agree with any proof, truth, or evidence.
The most I can do is a "potentially possible".
This is exactly the point I am pursuing with Bruno in recent posts. If
there is to be change, time evolution, how does this come about?
Intuitively, I find myself drawn towards the simple existence of all
possible numbers in a Platonic realm. Equally, by extrapolation, all
possible information structures, and even all computations - meaning
computational operations on numbers or structures of information, would
exist. But nothing happens.
This parallels the same, or similar, paradox in the physical world. If
we accept that the block universe of relativity is static, then we have
Weyl's statement as a perfect expression of the situation.
The world simply is, it does not happen. Only to the gaze of my
consciousness, crawling up the life-line of my body, does the world
fleetingly come to life. (1949, p. 116)
I reckon that consciousness is a rather neat explanation. Neat, but of
course hardly simple, since it begs an explanation of consciousness.
That is the subject of Transtemporal Phenomenal Consciousness and
Logical Types in Quantum Mechanics if anyone is interested.
Sorry about the plug, but this really is directly apropos.
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"Everything List" group.
To post to this group, send email to email@example.com.
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
For more options, visit this group at