On Thu, Aug 11, 2011 at 1:20 AM, Craig Weinberg <whatsons...@gmail.com> wrote:
> On Aug 10, 9:55 am, Stathis Papaioannou <stath...@gmail.com> wrote:
>> Yes. Suppose your right hemisphere is replaced with a machine that is
>> functionally identical at its boundaries but has a qualitatively
>> different consciousness.
> To me this is like saying 'suppose the Eastern United States is
> replaced with a machine that is functionally identical at it's
> boundaries but has a qualitatively different culture.
>>The left half of your left visual field will
>> then look different, by definition if the visual qualia are different.
>> But your left hemisphere receives the usual signals through the corpus
> The diplomatic relations with Europe will then be different, by
> definition if the diplomatic culture is different. But the Western
> U.S. receives the usual traffic across the Mississippi River,
>>so you state via the speech centres in that hemisphere that
>> everything looks exactly the same.
> so the Eastern media reports the news that the diplomatic situation
> with Europe has not changed.
>> In other words you can't notice any
>> change in your consciousness due to the functionally identical
>> replacement. I would say that if you continue to behave normally and
>> you notice no change in your consciousness then there *is* no
>> difference in your consciousness.
> In other words Americans can't notice any change in their culture due
> to the functionally identical replacement. You would say that if the
> US continues to behave normally and it notices no change in it's
> culture then there *is* no difference in it's culture.
> Can you see why that's a rather oversimplified and misleading thought
> experiment? If you replace a civilization of living organisms with a
> machine, you have changed it's culture already. The intelligence of
> the system isn't limited to the physical relations between the
> neurons, it's millions of nodes of sensitivity all corroborating
> experiences about the interior and exterior worlds.
Not a good analogy since the US is not conscious as a single entity.
Please explain what would you think would happen if you replaced part
of your brain with an unconscious component that interacted normally
with the surrounding neurons. Would you say "I feel different" or
would you say "I feel exactly the same as before"?
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"Everything List" group.
To post to this group, send email to firstname.lastname@example.org.
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
For more options, visit this group at