I'm in the throes of editing a lengthy piece by Samuel Capricornus 
from 1660. It's one of those typical pieces with two mensuration 
signs, C and 3/2, where the C is really 4/2 and the 3/2 is really 6/2 
(2 beats of dotted whole each, but occasionally alternating with 
3/1). And, of course, there are, as is usual in this repertory, lots 
of silent changes to lengthier measures at cadential points, e.g., in 
4/2, a 3/1 measure may close a section (really 6/2, but 6/2 with 3 
beats of a whole note each), and there are 9/2 measures in the 6/2 
sections.

It's customary in the original sources not to mark any of these. 
Indeed, in the original sources, there are no barlines in any of the 
parts but the basso continuo/organ part. I've replicated the barlines 
in that slavishly (with a couple of exceptions that aren't yet 
indicated in the sketchy notes, where I judge the original source to 
have been faulty in leaving out bar lines, since 8/2 is not really 
what I consider a valid construct in this repertory).

Anyway, my question is whether or not this looks manageable or not:

http://tearesofthemuses.com/Editions/Scores/Capricornus-Laemmlein/

Now, please, no criticism on the many layout issues that I haven't 
dealt with. I don't want to deal with word extensions and running 
Patterson Beams until I've decided on the final metrical layout. 
Related to all of that, I haven't spaced the lyrics and figured bass 
for the final versions, and a number of other things that I don't 
want to even begin mucking with until I've finalized the time 
signatures.

I just want to know if the meters make sense.

And while I find the opinions of those who are unfamiliar with early 
music interesting, I'm much more interested in the reactions of those 
who regularly edit and perform early music, since I'm creating the 
edition for my own group, which is quite accustomed to reading white-
note notation and non-explicit meters (as well as seeing C and ยข for 
4/2 and 3/2 for 3/1).

Do you think it would be better to just use the original mensuration 
signs and let the chips fall where they may? The parts for the 
instrumentalists are going to be prepared to be nearly identical to 
the original parts, with the sonatas printed once, then TACET and 
then SONATA REPETATUR (with cues to indicate when to come in). So, 
I'm not really concerned being overly fussy about using multimeasure 
rests that break for the time signature changes.

Comments?

Advice?

Complaints?

-- 
David W. Fenton                    http://dfenton.com
David Fenton Associates       http://dfenton.com/DFA/


_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to