On 18.06.2010 04:29, David W. Fenton wrote:

That does raise the question if you think that I've handled the 
coloration correctly. I would have liked to have used tuplets, but in 
this particular meter, I just think it would have confused things, so 
I wrote out the literal note values, instead. It seems perfectly 
clear to me. 

   David,
   Actually, your interpretation of the coloration worries me. I've never seen
   anything like this, and I have a lot of experience transcribing and playing
   music  from  this era (and yes, even Capricornus). How is the original
   notated, for example, in measure 138 of the soprano 1 part? If there are
   three colored whole notes (or one regular and two colored whole notes), they
   should still be transcribed as whole notes, since coloration at this time
   does not involve altering the length of the notes, but merely indicates a
   rhythmic shift: from ONE two three | ONE two three to ONE two THREE | one
   TWO three.
   And how is the ending (m. 245-end), for example, of the Tr 1 part notated in
   the original? This looks really weird.
   Howard
-- 
Howard Weiner
[1][email protected]
[2]http://howard-weiner.de/

Help stamp out and eradicate superfluous redundancy

References

   1. mailto:[email protected]
   2. http://howard-weiner.de/
_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to