Hi, [email protected] píše v pá 05. 03. 2010 v 09:09 -0800: > On Fri, Mar 05, 2010 at 05:46:38PM +0100, Milan Jurik wrote: > > For now after elimination of file system caches and download > > deliverables IPS is (at least) 3x slower than YUM/RPM. I am not IPS > > internals expert nor others involved on bug submittion so we have no > > good possibility to discover the reasons for this performance issue. > > If you don't understand how our system works, it's going to be difficult > for you to make any rational decision about whether our approach is > correct or not. This leads me to my other point about this bug, it's > obvious that the participants are not behaving rationally. The bug in > question has quickly become a thread for reasons why the submitters > don't like IPS, instead of any constructive discussion. > > The point that Shawn was trying to make, and that the other participants > in this bug seem to have missed, is that performance is still a work in > progress. The bug database is for specific problems with a cause and a > solution. It's not a forum for rants or general nonsense. > > If you're able to identify a specific performance problem, we're happy > to look into it. However, filing general complaints isn't useful. > Moreover, the comparisions that were made in the bug report are vague > and hard to interpret. Much of this is like goint to the truck > dealership to complain that your truck doesn't accelerate like your > motorcycle. >
Could you show me in my own comment added to that bug, or comment from Marcel Telka, where we were not behaving rationally, please? Even the description from Ondrej Kubecka was not evaluated in the first comment correctly, no deep evaluation done. Before accusing somebody from ranting and irrational behaving it is better to evaluate the answer. I did not want to evaluate how was that defect was managed, but the data submitted there. So, to summarize your answer - I, as somebody who must use IPS frequently now, but have no knowledge of IPS internals, have no possibility to log performance bug against IPS. I hope that IPS development team will be able to present comparisons of performance against other packaging systems before Solaris Next release. Best regards, Milan _______________________________________________ pkg-discuss mailing list [email protected] http://mail.opensolaris.org/mailman/listinfo/pkg-discuss
