cliveb;346280 Wrote: 
> Clearly it's not mistracking, nor is it clipping.
> 
> You mentioned later in your post that Spin It Again always saves the
> WAV file as 16/44.1.

Not quite.  It is a two stage process.  First it records the LP (there
is a pause button so you can flip it over) into a single large WAV
file.  You can set this up how you like, so I set this to encode
24/88.2.  I then listened to this WAV file which showed up the
distortion.  I listened both through SIA and through dbPoweramp and
both sounded distorted.

The second stage with SIA is a utility that allows you to chop the
larger WAV file up into separate tracks.  This cleverly automatically
titles the tracks (Artist-Album-Track number-track name.WAV) and
suggests break points based upon meta-data drawn from an internet
database.  You can fine tune it by dragging the start and end points of
each track in a graphical display while monitoring the results.  All
very convenient, but these separate files were downsampled to 16/44.1
by default.  There was no way of setting a different output format.  I
have queried SIA about this and there is no plan to change this.

> Could it be that the sample rate conversion within SIA is introducing
> this distortion?

Not the conversion as the distortion was in the unconverted file.
Presumably the actual sampling is all done in hardware/firmware/drivers
on the M-Audio rather than SIA.

> A useful test would be to try recording at high res again with some
> other program (eg. Audacity - it's freeware) to eliminate SIA as a
> possible culprit.

I might do this, but a time-benefit analysis would probably point out
that I am unlikely to hear the difference and the extra time needed to
identify the end points of the tracks and type in the track titles will
probably make it more bother than it is worth.

I have quite a neat workflow going with SIA to produce the tracks as
separate WAV files, dbPoweramp for FLAC conversion and Tag&Rename for
taking the title and turning it into metadata.

It is a shame that SIA does not support FLAC with tagging.  That would
save me about 15 - 20 minutes a disk.


-- 
TheLastMan

Matt

SB Duet, Synology Diskstation 107+ with FW 2.0-0600
SqueezeCenter 7.2 and SSODS 3 beta 15.
Naim 42/110 amp, B&W CM2 speakers.
LPs ripped using Linn LP12, Naim 72/Hi-cap, M-Audio 2496.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
TheLastMan's Profile: http://forums.slimdevices.com/member.php?userid=16021
View this thread: http://forums.slimdevices.com/showthread.php?t=53264

_______________________________________________
ripping mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.slimdevices.com/lists/listinfo/ripping

Reply via email to