[asom] Deportation of Bangladeshi
Friends, I fail to get the brainstorming part in this thread :-') An idea was to issue Work Permit but none come forward with a likely amount a day labour will pay per year to government as income tax. Finding what might be the worst case can be brainstorming too, lets continue on this thread. (I include Mrinal's email as well especially XLS file he posted cannot be downloaded from yahoogroups archive if you do not have yahoo ID so I am making it easy for all to download) http://deka7kl.googlepages.com/c-16.xls http://deka7kl.googlepages.com/c-16.xls This XLS file is not easy readable, if someone can put in single page like histogram plot it would be nice. rabin Dear All I am hereby attaching a large file of the the Language census data upto the Sub Division wide for your knowledge.The date came out recently. The DATA SAYS- The population of Assamese speaking people in seven districts of the Brahmaputra Valley of Assam declined while that of Bengali speakers there increased over a 10-year period from 1991 to 2001 Rpt 1991-2001. Now it is 2008. Please have a close look and realise the gravity. Are we not being hoodwinked the same set of people again and again. It is a large Excel file. Please store it properly and see it youself what is actually happening and how many of us actually speak Assamese langugage. We are fighting within us identifiying us Kalitas, Ahoms, Chutiyas, Boros etc etc. Just see the Cesus report. http://deka7kl.googlepages.com/c-16.xls http://deka7kl.googlepages.com/c-16.xls If you cannot download from above(assamonline archive) or the one attached because file is big, collect it from Census office, or in extreme need contact me. Mrinal Talukdar
[asom] Deportation of Bangladeshi
My note is strictly from brainstorming viewpoint welcome to ingnore if you dont like :-') Can you think of converting present Bodo Land autonomy to a Tribal State? (Get a tribal state and include entire greater Kamrupi land into it) For administrative reasons Sates are broken into number of States such as MP, UP, Bihar were broken. So present Assam will break one day. If the Tribal State idea does not work: can we think of a Saranya Autonomy south of national high way? (Saranya is the correct word for what modern Assamese say Saraniya) and can we think of Rabha Autonomy? Also we need to find a way to educate ruling class Ahom nationals - these are interpoleted with horrendous murderes looters etc. My definition of Ahom nationals equal to native-Assamese, i.e., one who is born and brought up in historic Ahom kingdom. I am re-posting the following note, from brainstorming viewpoints, that I wrote a year ago. http://groups.yahoo.com/group/assamonline/message/3487 http://groups.yahoo.com/group/assamonline/message/3487 Because of the aliens (the illegal immigrants) the whole landmass is in a critical-phase - not just the indigenous-ethnic-natives but also the endangered-species that inhibit the landmass - applies to entire Northeast. * Erase names from voter's lists and offer not political rights - implement as soon as possible should they the indigenous-ethnic-natives wish to survive. * Deport all aliens or send to rest of the States in India as well. * At the same time monitor Indian immigrants too to insure you the indigenous-ethnic-natives will not be minority in the Assembly, and to insure room for endangered-species. * Protect forestland from any settlers. Now who will implement these? The leadership compaction during the past three decades has been among native-Assamese only. Even the IM(DT) innovator was a native-Assamese. These leaders enjoy engaging each other; they create scenarios and continue to engage each other. Can you think of alternative means? One alternative: The greater Kamrupi landmass has been devastated due to their leadership practice so we need to send all to Sivsagar Jorhat area, the land of farsighted big-brothers :) Rabin
[asom] Deportation of Bangladeshi
Probably we need some critical questions in order to determine merits/demerits of work-permit protocol - one such question here: What shall be the annual income of an ordinary illegal immigrant in order for him/her to pay hundred rupees income tax per year? Any developed country immigration protocol is well studied and country specific. So a direct implementation of such protocol for Assam may produce parametric output. parametric output - an output that is not desired/wanted for Assam Rabin --- anjumanara begum [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Why dont we brianstorm ourselves and think what can be done now. With heavy influx, aspirations of indigenous population and politics on the other hand, aint we in a big turmoil? I dont think anything we express and discuss here is ultimately going to be implemented by our government. I think it will be wise to let our ideas flow. Nobody is right or wrong. Best anjuman - Original Message From: Masuk Mian [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: assamonline@yahoogroups.com Sent: Thursday, 7 August, 2008 4:22:50 PM Subject: [asom] Deportation of Bangladeshi It seems this is exactly a real thinking. ..Masuk At 02:52 PM 8/6/2008, siddharth chakravorty wrote: Dear All, With reference to Bangladeshi immigrants in Assam, this debate of Deportation is going on since last decade and we have no definite solution to it and I presume there won't be any in near future. In Britian we had similar problems with Polish and other East European workers in the past. The migration of people from a poor country to a richer country is common everywhere. If we managed to implement Assan Accord fully even then politicians will devise a way to prevent it from happening. I think we need to look at the ways to utilise this hard working community to our benefits and legalising their stay by issuing temperory work permit or something similar and extract income tax from them in some form. If you look at the western countries, they realise that the resource they spend on stopping them from entering the country illegally is much higher and not worth spending. They therefore devised a way to tap the resource and use it for their country's benefit by issuing work permits and allowing them to enter the country legally. I think we need to discuss something in similar lines rather than wasting our time in finding a solution to deport entire population of Bangladeshi community back to their country, which is simply impossible. Regards, Siddhartha Chakravorty Yahoo! Groups Links * To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/assamonline/ * Your email settings: Individual Email | Traditional * To change settings online go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/assamonline/join (Yahoo! ID required) * To change settings via email: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] * To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] * Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
[asom] Deportation of Bangladeshi
I am giving only the practical examples, its nothing related to emotional. We have to choose some1 better from the worse candidates. Atleast give a try. See, all bangladeshi went to say Dhubri or Nagaon to caste their votes. They feel so happy that their opponent Assamese ppl, are lazy in casting vote, so ultimately their candidates wins the election. Hope the Govt that we choose do something good for us. Secondly, if you have some other practical steps, do share with us. Every feedback is welcome and appreciable from any side, for betterment and safety of our future and society. Thirdly, I am absolutely with you and its really very sad that students have to do the hardship, which either the political or social ppls duty to do. We citizens only can give them all possible support, in a small or significant manner. On 13/08/2008, Sanjeeb Hazarika [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Dear Mr. Ankur, Your serious concerned about our nation and future generations is appreciable but practical solution in this issue is what you advocated is not feasible untill and unless there is a strong mainstream Political will...and which is not possible in Assam. You are saying about Vote Power??? But the Candidates contesting for the Elections are not at all suitable, then whom to Vote??? Therefore people are avoiding Election as there is no provision in our constitution to reject a candidate??? You are talking about Fencing??? For this Assam Agitation was initiated and the Leaders of AASU become Ruler and they did not do anything on this issue. Do you think that any political party in Assam has got that type of preparedness/ persuation capacity with Centre to build such a long International border Fence where a high level of diplomatic relationship with Bangladesh is required??? Do you know that the present detection and deportation of Bangladeshi's are done by several student unions of Assam...I am referring them as Students, not you...Not me! If they are involved in this type of activities then brillient students will suffer another setback by lossing their academic session...Which is undesirable to all. So, try to find out a practical solution to this issue not emotionalAlways taken into accout our Past experiences on this issue... Regards Sanjeeb Hazarika, New Delhi
[asom] Deportation of Bangladeshi
I feel this problem can not be solved politically at all. Politicians use these people as vote bank. As Mr. Hazarika already mentioned, we should learn from our earlier experience. These days lots of protests against illegal migrant is going on across the state. It reminds me the days of Asom Andolon. No point of losing the valuable academic year of students. One solution to this problem can be - avoid using the service of these illegal migrants with immediate effect. If we want a solution we have to stop using the service extended by these migrants. For that matter stop the following service provided by these people : Rickshaw puller, Thela puller, Carpenter, Labour, Vegetable vendors. If these migrants can pack the Biharis of the state by capturing their business, then why we Assamese people can't send the Bangladeshi people back to their own land ? For that we need to be mentally tough as well as we have to be serious about the future of our next generations. This is something every Assamese can do. For that we do not need to wait for politician, any organization to start some agitation. So, adopt this practice immediately at your home and spread the message to your neighbour. Can't we do this ? Any thought ! Regards, Samir --- On Thu, 8/14/08, ankur baruah [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: ankur baruah [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [asom] Deportation of Bangladeshi To: assamonline@yahoogroups.com Date: Thursday, August 14, 2008, 10:08 AM Dear Mr. Hazarika, I am giving only the practical examples, its nothing related to emotional. We have to choose some1 better from the worse candidates. Atleast give a try. See, all bangladeshi went to say Dhubri or Nagaon to caste their votes. They feel so happy that their opponent Assamese ppl, are lazy in casting vote, so ultimately their candidates wins the election. Hope the Govt that we choose do something good for us. Secondly, if you have some other practical steps, do share with us. Every feedback is welcome and appreciable from any side, for betterment and safety of our future and society. Thirdly, I am absolutely with you and its really very sad that students have to do the hardship, which either the political or social ppls duty to do. We citizens only can give them all possible support, in a small or significant manner. Yahoo! Groups Links * To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/assamonline/ * Your email settings: Individual Email | Traditional * To change settings online go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/assamonline/join (Yahoo! ID required) * To change settings via email: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] * To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] * Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
[asom] Deportation of Bangladeshi
Dear Samir, Your idea of boycotting Bangladeshi is something we can do without much effort. But such kind of protests will remain confined within educated mass unless we find an alternative to them. If you look at our society, there is always a category of jobs which our people feel shameful to take up. This has created an enormous opportunity for outsiders to come to our state. Earlier it was Biharis who are now been replaced by Bangladeshis. Our society is now so use to their services it has become impossible to live without them. Regards, Sidd - Original Message From: samir goswami [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: assamonline@yahoogroups.com Sent: Thursday, August 14, 2008 1:15:59 PM Subject: [asom] Deportation of Bangladeshi I feel this problem can not be solved politically at all. Politicians use these people as vote bank. As Mr. Hazarika already mentioned, we should learn from our earlier experience. These days lots of protests against illegal migrant is going on across the state. It reminds me the days of Asom Andolon. No point of losing the valuable academic year of students. One solution to this problem can be - avoid using the service of these illegal migrants with immediate effect. If we want a solution we have to stop using the service extended by these migrants. For that matter stop the following service provided by these people : Rickshaw puller, Thela puller, Carpenter, Labour, Vegetable vendors. If these migrants can pack the Biharis of the state by capturing their business, then why we Assamese people can't send the Bangladeshi people back to their own land ? For that we need to be mentally tough as well as we have to be serious about the future of our next generations. This is something every Assamese can do. For that we do not need to wait for politician, any organization to start some agitation. So, adopt this practice immediately at your home and spread the message to your neighbour. Can't we do this ? Any thought ! Regards, Samir Yahoo! Groups Links * To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/assamonline/ * Your email settings: Individual Email | Traditional * To change settings online go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/assamonline/join (Yahoo! ID required) * To change settings via email: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] * To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] * Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
[asom] Deportation of Bangladeshi
Dear Hazarika, Your question no.-03 to Mr. Ankur itself is reflecting the dangerous situation prevailing in Assam. your concern regarding academic session of Students is also very much valid. i also would not like to see the schoolgoing students being used as pawns. but, at the same time if something is not done by someone the Indegeneous people will lose the political power in the very next decade. SITUATION IN ENGLAND IS NOT SAME AS IN ASSAM! (POLISH PEOPLE ARE NOT ON THE VERGE OF OVERWHELMING THE ENGLISH POPULATION). I want to ask you and Siddhartha :- can we afford to lose our political power to the immigrant Bangladeshis and East-Pakis? With Regards. - Kuladip P.S.:- Request to all, Please think and express your view about the issue regarding the Childrens(born in Assam/India) of convicted Illegal immigrants. --- On Fri, 8/8/08, Sanjeeb Hazarika [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: Sanjeeb Hazarika [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [asom] Deportation of Bangladeshi To: ankur baruah [EMAIL PROTECTED] Cc: assamonline@yahoogroups.com Date: Friday, August 8, 2008, 3:29 PM What Ankur has said is speaking out of his emotions... This agitation of deporting Bangladeshi Nationals all over Assam will be another mockery of Assam Agitation during 80's... which will create another set of power hungry opportunist leaders for Assam who will play with the sentiment of simple minded Assamese people...and will again destroy some important accademic session of students... I would like to ask Ankur a few questions: 1. How long will you continue this detection and Deportation of Bangladeshi from Assam? 2. How will you ensure that those deported will not come back again? 3. What will you do if they come back again after 1 year (mostly will come back within a month)? 4. How long these Students will perform this Hide Seek game with these People? and at what Cost? I think the suggestion given by Siddhartha is better alternative compared to sentimental action taken by all student community Hope all should think over the issue in a constructive way to resolve this problem. People of Assam must not be cheated again what the leader of Assam Agitation did. Regards Sanjeeb Hazarika On 8/7/08, ankur baruah [EMAIL PROTECTED] com wrote: Thanks for your thought Sid. Ya its true that ppl from poorer conutry to richer country comes for work. But, there is huge differences between Bangladeshis and Polish workers. Have you found any polish worker with 5 wives and 20-30 childrens. I knew few of them in Assam (Asom). Bangladeshis are not here just for work, with due aided support from our so called Govt. they are changing the structure of our society. If, you have a visit through country side, say if you go from Guwahati to Udalguri, via magaldai, kharupetia or say, Guwahati to Jorhat via Kaziranga etc, you will see that they reside in huge number on side of the NH. Any layman who travels in Assam (Asom) can find foreigners except our respected Chief Minister Sahab who is yet to find one Bangladeshi. I am sorry to say this, please just don't write just articles for sake of it. If you really want to save Assam (Asom), do come n join the agitation which has started in Assam (Asom) statewise, help it and please do come in election time to cast your valuable vote thanks. Note: Just a question from my side, why all the so called foreigners, run away at election time to Dhubri or Nagaon district? Why our honourable chief minister never found a foreigner? Think. Have, Bangladeshis become the king maker of Assam (Asom)? On 06/08/2008, siddharth chakravorty [EMAIL PROTECTED] com wrote: Dear All, With reference to Bangladeshi immigrants in Assam, this debate of Deportation is going on since last decade and we have no definite solution to it and I presume there won't be any in near future. In Britian we had similar problems with Polish and other East European workers in the past. The migration of people from a poor country to a richer country is common everywhere. If we managed to implement Assan Accord fully even then politicians will devise a way to prevent it from happening. I think we need to look at the ways to utilise this hard working community to our benefits and legalising their stay by issuing temperory work permit or something similar and extract income tax from them in some form. If you look at the western countries, they realise that the resource they spend on stopping them from entering the country illegally is much higher and not worth spending. They therefore devised a way to tap the resource and use it for their country's benefit by issuing work permits and allowing them to enter the country legally. I think we need to discuss something in similar lines rather than wasting our time in finding a solution to deport entire population of Bangladeshi community back to their country, which is simply impossible. Regards, Siddhartha Chakravorty
[asom] Deportation of Bangladeshi
Dear all, I quote form http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jus_so Jus soli (Latin for right of the soil or, somewhat figuratively, right of the territory), or birthright citizenship, is a right by which nationality or citizenship can be recognised to any individual born in the territory of the related state. At the turn of the nineteenth century, nation-states commonly divided themselves between those granting nationality on the grounds of jus soli (France, for example) and those granting it on the grounds of jus sanguinis (right of blood) (Germany, for example). However, most European countries chose the German conception of an objective nationality, based on blood, race or language (as in Fichte's classical definition of a nation), opposing themselves to republican Ernest Renan's subjective nationality, based on an every-day plebiscite of one's appurtenance to his Fatherland. This non-essentialist conception of nationality allowed the implementation of jus soli, against the essentialist jus sanguinis. However, today's massive increase of refugees has somewhat blurred the lines between these two antagonistic sources of right. Countries that have acceded to the 1961 Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness will grant nationality to otherwise stateless persons who were born on their territory, or on a ship or plane flagged by the country. India has signed this Convention on 29 June 1995. So, In this situation I dont know if amendment is possible in the line suggested by Kuladip, but yes, a debate can be initiated. Best regards anjuman - Original Message From: kuladip baro [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Monday, 4 August, 2008 12:43:44 AM Subject: [asom] Deportation of Bangladeshi Dear Deep, you have raised the most important issue about Bangladeshi deportation. it is true that we have to be happy content by deporting only the likes of Mr. Kamaruddin!! ! Kmaruddind is expelled but he has left us a burden of 6 chidlrens (as per News reports) ..6 more votes from the Bangladeshi immigrant community after about 10-12 years!!! think of such Kamaruddins still on the large... may be few lacs if not millions!! than guess the burden ( and danger of Bangladeshi inclined votes) they have produced! it might be in millions This situation is prevailing due to the Citizenship act -1956 by dint of which the childrens of the likes of Kamaruddin become indians by Birth. although the act is similar to the same types of acts of the civilised nations of the world it actually is Gross INJUSTICE to the indegeneous people of the Bangladeshi INFESTED places like Assam. This act is clearing the path for destruction of the Indegeneous people of Assam. This type of act is only usefull for the CIVILISED nations of the Europe and other handfull nations like USA, Canada, Australia etc. and not usefull at all to deal with the VIRUS like Bangladeshi Immigrants. i dont know whether this problem is taken care of in the Assam accord or not. if not , the situation will become worse even after implementing the accord fully. I would like to know if the act can be ammended so that AT LEAST , childrens born to post 25/03/1971 illegal Bangladeshi immigrants can also be deported. after all, Law/Act is made by humans for the smooth functioning of the society. not for endengering one section of it. So, LOGICALLY, the Act can be ammended to safeguard the Indegeneous of Assam. (i think, ONLY THE LAW OF NATURE i.e.. PHYSICSCHEMISTRY REMAINS INTACT). also, if the Act can't be ammended for the whole of India it must be ammended as a special case for Assam.. (Now, someone dont ask why as a special case for Assam? if IMDT could be enacted the said Ammendment also can be done.). i think , we indegeneous people should think as above and also act promptly. -Kuladip --- On Sun, 8/3/08, Mr. Native Assamese deep_black1@ yahoo.co. in wrote: From: Mr. Native Assamese deep_black1@ yahoo.co. in Subject: [asom] Deportation of Bangladeshi To: assamonline@ yahoogroups. com Date: Sunday, August 3, 2008, 1:59 PM Dear Sirs/Madams, There was a news that, The identified Bangladeshi Mr. Kamaruddin of Jomunamukh was arrested and being sent to Bangladesh. But the Wife and Childrens of Kamaruddin are allowed to stay in India. I dont understand, if the Father is illegal Bangladeshi how the Childrens can be citizens of India. if it is so, how many Bangladeshis out of the about 50 lacs we will be able to expell? Deep Bora Jorhat
[asom] Deportation of Bangladeshi
Hi anjuman, Going thru both links in support of you logic it looks clear that we cannot deport any illegal immigrants and in the end they will have the territorial right to rule us. Can you think of a way to deport as many illegal immigrants as possible so we Khilinzias do not become minority? There were a discussion in the past but it did not continue and I felt it did not continue because of my writing. So I am sorry about that, following is the link of that discussion: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/assamonline/message/3536 http://groups.yahoo.com/group/assamonline/message/3536 Khalek --- anjumanara begum [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Dear Deep Bora, Even if the father is an illegal migrant and the son will be an indian citizen if the son was born in Indian territory/ soil, . This tactic is used even in countries like USA. I am quoting below the citizenship chapter of Indian constitution. You may have a look. Best anjuman Part II - consists of Articles 5 - 11 on CITIZENSHIP. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PART_Two_of_the_Constitution_of_India http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PART_Two_of_the_Constitution_of_India Jus soli (Latin for right of the soil or, somewhat figuratively, right of the territory), or birthright citizenship, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jus_so http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jus_so
[asom] Deportation of Bangladeshi
Dear Sirs/Madams, There was a news that, The identified Bangladeshi Mr. Kamaruddin of Jomunamukh was arrested and being sent to Bangladesh. But the Wife and Childrens of Kamaruddin are allowed to stay in India. I dont understand, if the Father is illegal Bangladeshi how the Childrens can be citizens of India. if it is so, how many Bangladeshis out of the about 50 lacs we will be able to expell? Deep Bora Jorhat
[asom] Deportation of Bangladeshi
Dear Deep Bora, Even if the father is an illegal migrant and the son will be an indian citizen if the son was born in Indian territory/ soil, . This tactic is used even in countries like USA. I am quoting below the citizenship chapter of Indian constitution. You may have a look. Best anjuman Part II - consists of Articles 5 - 11 on CITIZENSHIP. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PART_Two_of_the_Constitution_of_India - Original Message From: Mr. Native Assamese [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: assamonline@yahoogroups.com Sent: Sunday, 3 August, 2008 1:59:41 PM Subject: [asom] Deportation of Bangladeshi Dear Sirs/Madams, There was a news that, The identified Bangladeshi Mr. Kamaruddin of Jomunamukh was arrested and being sent to Bangladesh. But the Wife and Childrens of Kamaruddin are allowed to stay in India. I dont understand, if the Father is illegal Bangladeshi how the Childrens can be citizens of India. if it is so, how many Bangladeshis out of the about 50 lacs we will be able to expell? Deep Bora Jorhat
[asom] Deportation of Bangladeshi
Dear Deep, you have raised the most important issue about Bangladeshi deportation. it is true that we have to be happy content by deporting only the likes of Mr. Kamaruddin!!! Kmaruddind is expelled but he has left us a burden of 6 chidlrens (as per News reports)..6 more votes from the Bangladeshi immigrant community after about 10-12 years!!! think of such Kamaruddins still on the large...may be few lacs if not millions!! than guess the burden ( and danger of Bangladeshi inclined votes) they have produced! it might be in millions This situation is prevailing due to the Citizenship act -1956 by dint of which the childrens of the likes of Kamaruddin become indians by Birth. although the act is similar to the same types of acts of the civilised nations of the world it actually is Gross INJUSTICE to the indegeneous people of the Bangladeshi INFESTED places like Assam. This act is clearing the path for destruction of the Indegeneous people of Assam. This type of act is only usefull for the CIVILISED nations of the Europe and other handfull nations like USA, Canada, Australia etc. and not usefull at all to deal with the VIRUS like Bangladeshi Immigrants. i dont know whether this problem is taken care of in the Assam accord or not. if not , the situation will become worse even after implementing the accord fully. I would like to know if the act can be ammended so that AT LEAST , childrens born to post 25/03/1971 illegal Bangladeshi immigrants can also be deported. after all, Law/Act is made by humans for the smooth functioning of the society. not for endengering one section of it. So, LOGICALLY, the Act can be ammended to safeguard the Indegeneous of Assam. (i think, ONLY THE LAW OF NATURE i.e. PHYSICSCHEMISTRY REMAINS INTACT). also, if the Act can't be ammended for the whole of India it must be ammended as a special case for Assam. (Now, someone dont ask why as a special case for Assam? if IMDT could be enacted the said Ammendment also can be done.). i think , we indegeneous people should think as above and also act promptly. -Kuladip --- On Sun, 8/3/08, Mr. Native Assamese [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: Mr. Native Assamese [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [asom] Deportation of Bangladeshi To: assamonline@yahoogroups.com Date: Sunday, August 3, 2008, 1:59 PM Dear Sirs/Madams, There was a news that, The identified Bangladeshi Mr. Kamaruddin of Jomunamukh was arrested and being sent to Bangladesh. But the Wife and Childrens of Kamaruddin are allowed to stay in India. I dont understand, if the Father is illegal Bangladeshi how the Childrens can be citizens of India. if it is so, how many Bangladeshis out of the about 50 lacs we will be able to expell? Deep Bora Jorhat