Re: Thermal grease?

2009-06-03 Thread John Callahan
I realize this is old news but I recently saw a 1947 Cadillac with the exhaust manifolds exiting from the vee block over the intake manifolds and down over the rear of the engine. Thought I knew engines but I guess I have much more to learn!! On Mar 16, 2009, at 6:05 PM, Wallace Adrian

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-16 Thread pdimage
On 15/3/09 21:13, Amanda Ward amanda.w...@comcast.net wrote: I have the aforementioned heat sink and CPU apart. What would be a good thermal compound to reassemble the beast? I do have a dab of Arctic Silver from a former project. Think this would be okee dokee? The chip doesn't seem to

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-16 Thread Bruce Johnson
On Mar 15, 2009, at 9:17 AM, John Callahan wrote: At last, a voice of reason and acuity in this exercise in tedium. Also I take issue with this statement the exhaust manifold comes off the sides of the engine, not down the middle... Never saw an engine (V8) with the exhaust down the

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-16 Thread Wallace Adrian D'Alessio
On Mon, Mar 16, 2009 at 11:59 AM, Bruce Johnson john...@pharmacy.arizona.edu wrote: On Mar 15, 2009, at 9:17 AM, John Callahan wrote: At last, a voice of reason and acuity in this exercise in tedium. Also I take issue with this statement the exhaust manifold comes off the sides of

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-16 Thread glen
At last, a voice of reason and acuity in this exercise in tedium. Also I take issue with this statement the exhaust manifold comes off the sides of the engine, not down the middle... Never saw an engine (V8) with the exhaust down the middle. Mis-statement on my part: The intake manifold

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-15 Thread Amanda Ward
Hi Peter... On Mar 14, 2009, at 2:42 PM, PeterH wrote: With over-application of Arctic Silver, for example, to a G4, there are power decoupling lines on the surface of the chip which can be shorted-out by such oozing. The washer which Apple generally applies to its processors can limit

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-15 Thread pdimage
On 15/3/09 09:21, Amanda Ward amanda.w...@comcast.net wrote: I have a CPU (Intel type) with a large heat sink that is firmly stuck to the processor. Any thought on getting the two separated. They should come apart somehow... the CPU is a ZIF and you can't get it back into the socket because

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-15 Thread John Callahan
On Mar 14, 2009, at 10:44 PM, Bruce Johnson wrote: CPUs and heat sinks never move, they simply need a thermally conductive join. And yeah, that '34 would be worth a whole boatload of money today...:-) -- Bruce Johnson U of Az College of Pharmacy Information Technology Group

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-15 Thread Amanda Ward
Hey John... On Mar 15, 2009, at 9:17 AM, John Callahan wrote: At last, a voice of reason and acuity in this exercise in tedium. Also I take issue with this statement the exhaust manifold comes off the sides of the engine, not down the middle... Never saw an engine (V8) with the exhaust down

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-15 Thread Amanda Ward
PETE!!! On Mar 15, 2009, at 3:08 AM, pdimage wrote: On 15/3/09 09:21, Amanda Ward amanda.w...@comcast.net wrote: I have a CPU (Intel type) with a large heat sink that is firmly stuck to the processor. Any thought on getting the two separated. They should come apart somehow... the CPU is

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-15 Thread Amanda Ward
Back on topic... I promise!!! On Mar 15, 2009, at 3:08 AM, pdimage wrote: On 15/3/09 09:21, Amanda Ward amanda.w...@comcast.net wrote: I have a CPU (Intel type) with a large heat sink that is firmly stuck to the processor. Any thought on getting the two separated. They should come apart

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-14 Thread Ernest L. Gunerius
On 14/3/09 02:32, Wallace Adrian D'Alessio fluxstrin...@gmail.com wrote: Overclockers who are set on defeating heat to preserve costly CPUs yet squeeze extreme clock counts out of them have been known to polish the CPU and heatsink with ever finer grades of wet or dry paper starting with

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-14 Thread PeterH
On Mar 14, 2009, at 2:38 AM, Ernest L. Gunerius wrote: It could be argued and possibly answered by experiment that there could be a surface condition in the range between a very rough finish and a finish that imposes a Casimir force that would give the minimum thermal resistance at a

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-14 Thread insightinmind
On Mar 14, 2009, at 8:25 AM, PeterH wrote: For the LGA 775 products from Intel, which present a very large surface area to the cooler, the most popular method of extreme cooling is lapping the processor and the cooler to flatness, followed by application of the best available heat

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-14 Thread Wallace Adrian D'Alessio
On Sat, Mar 14, 2009 at 4:43 AM, pdimage pdim...@btinternet.com wrote: On 14/3/09 02:32, Wallace Adrian D'Alessio fluxstrin...@gmail.com wrote: Overclockers who are set on defeating heat to preserve costly CPUs yet squeeze extreme clock counts out of them have been known to polish the

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-14 Thread James E. Therrault
Ernest L. Gunerius wrote: On 14/3/09 02:32, Wallace Adrian D'Alessio fluxstrin...@gmail.com wrote: Overclockers who are set on defeating heat to preserve costly CPUs yet squeeze extreme clock counts out of them have been known to polish the CPU and heatsink with ever finer grades of

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-14 Thread insightinmind
On Mar 14, 2009, at 12:28 PM, Kris Tilford wrote: On Mar 12, 2009, at 6:46 PM, PeterH wrote: Silicone thermal grease needs no special preparation. Arctic Silver must be applied according to instructions, as this stuff is conductive, and it can short-out a processor, if improperly

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-14 Thread pdimage
On 14/3/09 16:28, Kris Tilford ktilfo...@cox.net wrote: Is this true? I'd think there's a chance the the word conductive is being misinterpreted? It seems to me that thermal paste is likely to be thermodynamically conductive and not likely to be electrically conductive? Yes this is

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-14 Thread pdimage
On 14/3/09 14:50, PAR prieme...@msn.com wrote: still don't have a good feel for an answer. For example, arctic silver (and comparable products) say they are thermal conductors and not electrical conductors, yet the fine print says it may end up shorting out circuits -- in plain English,

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-14 Thread Clark Martin
PAR wrote: still don't have a good feel for an answer. For example, arctic silver (and comparable products) say they are thermal conductors and not electrical conductors, yet the fine print says it may end up shorting out circuits -- in plain English, that means it is an electrical

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-14 Thread Stephen E. Bodnar
insightinmind wrote: On Mar 14, 2009, at 12:28 PM, Kris Tilford wrote: On Mar 12, 2009, at 6:46 PM, PeterH wrote: Silicone thermal grease needs no special preparation. Arctic Silver must be applied according to instructions, as this stuff is conductive, and it can short-out a

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-14 Thread Bruce Johnson
On Mar 14, 2009, at 1:43 AM, pdimage wrote: On 14/3/09 02:32, Wallace Adrian D'Alessio fluxstrin...@gmail.com wrote: Overclockers who are set on defeating heat to preserve costly CPUs yet squeeze extreme clock counts out of them have been known to polish the CPU and heatsink with

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-14 Thread insightinmind
Ya, I can tell you from experience that it IS electrically conductive. Got a blob where I shouldn't have on a motherboard once upon a time, luckily I got it cleaned off after it wouldn't run. ... Arctic Silver has metal particles in the gel - I'm not sure if it is aluminum or real silver.

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-14 Thread Charles Davis
On Mar 14, 2009, at 3:16 PM, Clark Martin wrote: PAR wrote: still don't have a good feel for an answer. For example, arctic silver (and comparable products) say they are thermal conductors and not electrical conductors, yet the fine print says it may end up shorting out circuits -- in

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-14 Thread PeterH
On Mar 14, 2009, at 2:01 PM, Charles Davis wrote: The 'Electrically conductive' being a problem is NOT between the processor heat sink, it's the problem caused by 'excess conductive paste' oozing onto circuit traces adjacent to the processor, and shorting various signals and/or power

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-14 Thread Clark Martin
PeterH wrote: On Mar 14, 2009, at 2:01 PM, Charles Davis wrote: The 'Electrically conductive' being a problem is NOT between the processor heat sink, it's the problem caused by 'excess conductive paste' oozing onto circuit traces adjacent to the processor, and shorting various signals

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-14 Thread Wallace Adrian D'Alessio
On Sat, Mar 14, 2009 at 4:22 PM, Bruce Johnson john...@pharmacy.arizona.edu wrote: On Mar 14, 2009, at 1:43 AM, pdimage wrote: On 14/3/09 02:32, Wallace Adrian D'Alessio fluxstrin...@gmail.com wrote: Overclockers who are set on defeating heat to preserve costly CPUs yet squeeze

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-14 Thread glen
The Over Clockers are the modern equivalent of the old Shade Tree Mechanics squeezing the last possible Horsepower/Torque out of a Flat Head Ford engine; as they work within their version of the Triple Constraint. If it works for them, Hurrah, ErnieG Heh... You

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-14 Thread Wallace Adrian D'Alessio
On Sat, Mar 14, 2009 at 9:25 PM, glen glenst...@yahoo.com wrote: For conductive heat transfer as in this case you ideally want perfectly flat surfaces. They wouldn't need any heat transfer compound between them as there would be no gap. But ideal and perfect are on back order so you

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-13 Thread mythmaker18
So, let me get this straight (forgive my ignorance. I'm used to the plug-n-play of the beige processor upgrades that had their own built- in heatsinks). If I decide to upgrade the processor in my Quicksilver to a later quicksilver processor (for example, putting a used gual 1GHz in a QS933

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-13 Thread nestamicky
mythmaker18 wrote: So, let me get this straight (forgive my ignorance. I'm used to the plug-n-play of the beige processor upgrades that had their own built- in heatsinks). If I decide to upgrade the processor in my Quicksilver to a later quicksilver processor (for example, putting a used

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-13 Thread dc
I'm not a big fan of the sticky black goop Apple uses for thermal compound. When I swap processors, which is pretty frequent, I always replace it with a better compound. First I remove the black stuff with a plastic (not metal- don't scratch the heatsink or CPU) scraper, scrub it off with acetone

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-13 Thread insightinmind
On Mar 13, 2009, at 9:40 AM, nestamicky wrote: mythmaker18 wrote: So, let me get this straight (forgive my ignorance. I'm used to the plug-n-play of the beige processor upgrades that had their own built- in heatsinks). If I decide to upgrade the processor in my Quicksilver to a later

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-13 Thread PeterH
On Mar 13, 2009, at 6:54 AM, insightinmind wrote: I have a Dual 1GHz QS 2002 ... seems to be working fine ... just concerned about age. Would it be advisable to go on and remove the heatsink(s), clean the surfaces, and re-apply thermal grease? Sort of preventive maintenance? In

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-13 Thread John Callahan
Isn't heat transfer the issue here??? On Mar 13, 2009, at 2:11 AM, Clark Martin wrote: PeterH wrote: On Mar 12, 2009, at 7:14 PM, technophobic_...@comcast.net wrote: Don't put ANY grease near your processor! A grease is simply solids within an oily carrier. Electronics grade silicone

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-13 Thread Clark Martin
technophobic_...@comcast.net wrote: On 3/12/09, Clark Martin wrote: If the Heatsink / Processor combo is supposed to use grease then conductivity isn't an issue, you assume the CPU and heatsink will connect electrically. If you don't want them to connect electrically you use an

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-13 Thread pdimage
On 13/3/09 13:54, insightinmind billycarm...@verizon.net wrote: In a similar vein ... I have a Dual 1GHz QS 2002 ... seems to be working fine ... just concerned about age. Would it be advisable to go on and remove the heatsink(s), clean the surfaces, and re-apply thermal grease? Sort of

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-13 Thread Wallace Adrian D'Alessio
On Fri, Mar 13, 2009 at 9:49 AM, dc dbc...@verizon.net wrote: I'm not a big fan of the sticky black goop Apple uses for thermal compound. When I swap processors, which is pretty frequent, I always replace it with a better compound. First I remove the black stuff with a plastic (not metal-

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-12 Thread Bruce Johnson
On Mar 12, 2009, at 3:48 PM, PAR wrote: I just received a 450 Mhz dual processor to replace the single 400 Mhz processor in my G4 gigabit machine. I assume I must get a tube of thermal grease to put a drop on top of each processor before i put the new processor unit and heatsink in my G4?

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-12 Thread Wallace Adrian D'Alessio
On Thu, Mar 12, 2009 at 6:48 PM, PAR prieme...@msn.com wrote: I just received a 450 Mhz dual processor to replace the single 400 Mhz processor in my G4 gigabit machine. I assume I must get a tube of thermal grease to put a drop on top of each processor before i put the new processor unit and

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-12 Thread Stephen Weber
You might want to read some documentation on the CPU, there might be something in there about thermal grease. I know the processor upgrade that I got for my BW said not to use any thermal grease because it already had something on it. If you do decide to put on some thermal grease remember to

Re: Thermal grease?

2009-03-12 Thread PeterH
On Mar 12, 2009, at 4:18 PM, Stephen Weber wrote: You might want to read some documentation on the CPU, there might be something in there about thermal grease. I know the processor upgrade that I got for my BW said not to use any thermal grease because it already had something on it.