Re: [MD] How to experience Dynamic Quality

2011-05-09 Thread Tuukka Virtaperko
John: For some people, peace of mind is easy. For others its very hard. But one thing for sure, when you've got it, you've got it and nobody can gainsay. Inorganic perfection: Light Biological perfection: Procreation Social perfection: Celebrity Intellectual perfection: Enlightenment I

Re: [MD] Free Will

2011-05-09 Thread MarshaV
Nagarjuna, in the MMK, replaces cause with conditions: The argument against causation is tightly intertwined with the positive account of dependent arising and of the nature of the relation between conditions and the conditioned. Nagarjuna begins by stating the conclusion (1: 1): neither

Re: [MD] Free Will

2011-05-09 Thread Steven Peterson
On Sun, May 8, 2011 at 10:06 PM, craig...@comcast.net wrote: [Pirsig] To say that A causes B or to say that B values precondition A is to say the same thing. The difference is one of words only. Instead of saying A magnet causes iron filings to move toward it, you can say Iron filings value

Re: [MD] Free Will

2011-05-09 Thread MarshaV
Greeings, Rather than a choice, is a pattern equivalent to a conclusion? Marsha ___ Moq_Discuss mailing list Listinfo, Unsubscribing etc. http://lists.moqtalk.org/listinfo.cgi/moq_discuss-moqtalk.org Archives: http://lists.moqtalk.org/pipermail/moq_discuss-moqtalk.org/

Re: [MD] Keep on Truckin'

2011-05-09 Thread Arlo Bensinger
[Mark] Freedom is a rig full of gas, a wide open road, a stack of audio CDs, and some sweet rock and roll. Oh, yeah, and truck stops full of coffee. Just watch out for the ones full of Vampires... [Arlo] A nice metaphor for freedom, since the agency one is able to act upon above is

Re: [MD] Free Will

2011-05-09 Thread craigerb
[Pirsig] To say that A causes B or to say that B values precondition A is to say the same thing. The difference is one of words only. Instead of saying A magnet causes iron filings to move toward it, you can say Iron filings value movement toward a magnet. [Craig, previously] In Iron filings

Re: [MD] How to experience Dynamic Quality

2011-05-09 Thread John Carl
Dan, how can I refute such eloquent and well-thought argumentation? Dan: No, but I am reading you being a dick. Johnprev: Isn't this ineffable something that is heading away from mechanistic patterns just exactly what Ron and I have been saying all along? Mechanism is determinism.

Re: [MD] How to experience Dynamic Quality

2011-05-09 Thread John Carl
Tuuka, John: Inorganic perfection: Light Biological perfection: Procreation Social perfection: Celebrity Intellectual perfection: Enlightenment Tukka, I strongly disagree that being a celebrity would be any form of social perfection. What about criminal celebrities, you know, those

Re: [MD] Keep on Truckin'

2011-05-09 Thread John Carl
What a lon-n-n-g... strange trip its been, Mark. Right now I'm sitting in my brother-in-law's house in Missoula, with the rain coming down, it's about 48, and I miss california girls - namely my wife and daughters. Yesterday, I helped my bro-in-law patrol the streets of this Montana town, and

Re: [MD] Free Will

2011-05-09 Thread John Carl
Well Ham, your words thrill me and I agree with every word. You put it most excellently as well. I just can't understand how anybody would choose to not understand such plain and well-written rhetoric. Yours, John On Sun, May 1, 2011 at 12:36 PM, Ham Priday hampd...@verizon.net wrote: Hi

Re: [MD] Free Will

2011-05-09 Thread MarshaV
Marsha: Rather than a choice, is a pattern equivalent to a conclusion? Marsha: The mind is fixated from moment to moment on static patterns (conclusions) which shape reality and establish certainty so life can be lived with some reliability. ___ Moq_Discuss mailing list

Re: [MD] Free Will

2011-05-09 Thread John Carl
Marsha, I never read Hume, but I did hand in an essay to my SDA english teacher my sophmore year, on cause and effect, and he called it Humeian so I've always had a certain fondness for the guy who woke father Kant from his dogmatic slumbers. As you do for many! I'm sure. Marsha: Been a long

Re: [MD] How to experience Dynamic Quality

2011-05-09 Thread Dan Glover
Look, John, you are the one who started by insulting me. I asked if Ron was listening on account of his asking me to explain free will vs determinism in terms of the MOQ. And this discussion didn't include him. So I was merely being polite in asking if he was listening, or reading if you will.

Re: [MD] Free Will

2011-05-09 Thread Steven Peterson
[Steve] Instead of saying A magnet [A] causes iron filings to move toward it [B], you can say Iron filings [B] value movement toward a magnet [A]. But the use of A B is inconsistent between these two formulations. A causes B is exemplified by A (proximity of a magnet to iron filings)

Re: [MD] How to experience Dynamic Quality

2011-05-09 Thread John Carl
Well Dan, I'm sorry you took such offense, but geez yer a prickly bastard sometimes. I certainly didn't intend any offense, other than good-natured jibbing which flows out in discourse without me really meaning anything other than trying to emphasize certain oppositional points. But reading

Re: [MD] How to experience Dynamic Quality

2011-05-09 Thread Dan Glover
Hello everyone On Mon, May 9, 2011 at 1:26 PM, John Carl ridgecoy...@gmail.com wrote: Well Dan, I'm sorry you took such offense, but geez yer a prickly bastard sometimes. Yes, I am. As I've admitted to others here, I tend to suffer fools poorly.  I certainly didn't intend any offense, other

Re: [MD] Keep on Truckin'

2011-05-09 Thread 118
Hey Arlo, A metaphor perhaps. It depends on how one sees freedom. Let me ask you this: Do we live in a world of bondage that we are trying to instill freedom, or do we live in a world of freedom in which we succumb to bondage? Your essay below suggest the former, whereas, the latter seems

Re: [MD] Keep on Truckin'

2011-05-09 Thread 118
Hey John the Wanderer, Missoula? Where on God's Green Earth is that? Here I am imagining an old map of the US, from say 1700. There is this red line that moves from one emerging dot to another, the dot grows as you stay at one place. Hmmm. Is it out in the Indian Country, or towards Nueva

Re: [MD] Keep on Truckin'

2011-05-09 Thread ARLO J BENSINGER JR
[Mark] It depends on how one sees freedom. Let me ask you this: Do we live in a world of bondage that we are trying to instill freedom, or do we live in a world of freedom in which we succumb to bondage? Your essay below suggest the former, whereas, the latter seems much more reasonable.

Re: [MD] Free Will

2011-05-09 Thread Ham Priday
Greetings John -- Well Ham, your words thrill me and I agree with every word. You put it most excellently as well. I just can't understand how anybody would choose to not understand such plain and well-written rhetoric. Thanks for the kind words. I had ro reread that post (to Marsha) to