Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: 535 members of Congress and ...

2003-03-21 Thread Robert Scott Gassler
At the beginning of boht the Korean and Vietnam conflicts, there was a draft, and members of Congress may have had draft-age sons. At the beginning of WWII and the two Gulf wars, there was no draft and members of Congress therefore did not need to worry about their own sons. It seems to have

Re: Pre-emptive attack against General Assembly meeting

2003-03-21 Thread soula avramidis
Dear Ambassador, Please consider invoking UN Res. 377 "Uniting For Peace" to stop this unnecessary, unjust disastrous war that U.S. President Bush is trying to foist upon innocent Iraqis and the world. The war will cause hundreds of thousands of deaths of innocents, trillions better spent on

Illegality of war

2003-03-21 Thread k hanly
Published on Monday, March 10, 2003 by the Guardian/UK A Supreme International Crime Any Member of a Government Backing an Aggressive War Will Be Open to Prosecution by Mark Littman The threatened war against Iraq will be a breach of the United Nations Charter and hence of international law

Wallerstein on Iraq

2003-03-21 Thread k hanly
Bush Bets All He Has Mar. 15, 2003 The United States is in deep trouble. The President of the United States has taken an enormous gamble, and done it from a fundamentally weak position. He decided a year ago or so that the U.S. would make war on Iraq. He did this in order to demonstrate the

Re: Re: Article on Illegality of Iraq war

2003-03-21 Thread k hanly
I havent heard that it was explicity written. However Negroponte gave assurances in the media that there was no automaticity and said there was no hidden trigger of force. It was on these assurances that everyone signed on. Technically I expect you are correct and the CESR is wrong. I am not sure

To Ian Murray

2003-03-21 Thread Louis Proyect
Ian, you cite this as an example of my attacking people rather than ideas? To the contrary, a pacifist (in the sense of being opposed to the right of the imperialists to make war) position is the only one that principled Marxists, radicals and progressives can put forward. Perhaps you should

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: 535 members of Congress and ...

2003-03-21 Thread Carrol Cox
Robert Scott Gassler wrote: At the beginning of boht the Korean and Vietnam conflicts, there was a draft, and members of Congress may have had draft-age sons. At the beginning of WWII This is wrong. The draft began in 1940. Then the upper age limit was reduced, and some who had been

RE: G. William Domhoff replies...The whole thing?

2003-03-21 Thread Devine, James
Title: RE: [PEN-L:35855] G. William Domhoff replies...The whole thing? Instead of being pelted with petty personal attacks, Domhoff should be given credit for doing excellent research to produce his books. His theory's not very deep (in my humble opinion), but most of the people on pen-l are

PK on deficit fears

2003-03-21 Thread Devine, James
Title: PK on deficit fears March 21, 2003/New York TIMES Who Lost the U.S. Budget? By PAUL KRUGMAN The Onion describes itself as America's finest news source, and it's not an idle boast. On Jan. 18, 2001, the satirical weekly bore the headline Bush: Our long national nightmare of peace and

Re: To Ian Murray

2003-03-21 Thread Ian Murray
- Original Message - From: Louis Proyect [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Friday, March 21, 2003 6:02 AM Subject: [PEN-L:35853] To Ian Murray Ian, you cite this as an example of my attacking people rather than ideas? To the contrary, a pacifist (in the sense of being

Re: RE: G. William Domhoff replies...The whole thing?

2003-03-21 Thread Michael Perelman
I think with the killing of people in Iraq, Palestine, we don't need to center on personalities. On Fri, Mar 21, 2003 at 07:56:11AM -0800, Devine, James wrote: Instead of being pelted with petty personal attacks, Domhoff should be given credit for doing excellent research to produce his

RE: Re: RE: G. William Domhoff replies...The whole thing?

2003-03-21 Thread Devine, James
Title: RE: [PEN-L:35859] Re: RE: G. William Domhoff replies...The whole thing? I think with the killing of people in Iraq, Palestine, we don't need to center on personalities. That's what I was saying: petty attacks on Domhoff and the like are distractions (at best).

Re: G. William Domhoff replies...The whole thing?

2003-03-21 Thread Louis Proyect
I did forward the whole thing. It was just interspersed by my own comments. I did get another message from him that is not worth commenting on. -- The Marxism list: www.marxmail.org

Re: RE: G. William Domhoff replies...The whole thing?

2003-03-21 Thread Louis Proyect
Devine, James wrote: Instead of being pelted with petty personal attacks, Domhoff should be given credit for doing excellent research to produce his books. What for? Professors are paid to do excellent research. Last night I told my wife that 90 percent of the people on lists like PEN-L and PSN

Re: Re: To Ian Murray

2003-03-21 Thread Louis Proyect
Ian Murray wrote: There are no celebrities here. Your sarcasm looks a lot like adolescent name calling and facile attempts at character assassination to me and a lot of other people, especially those on the receiving end of your communication. What is it, objectively? Well, other people like it

Re: Re: RE: G. William Domhoff replies...The wholething?

2003-03-21 Thread Doug Henwood
Michael Perelman wrote: I think with the killing of people in Iraq, Palestine, we don't need to center on personalities. And who is centering on personalities? Now it's Domhoff, added to a long list of ad hominems, including Jim O'Connor and David Harvey - three radical scholars who've

Re: Re: Re: RE: G. William Domhoff replies...The wholething?

2003-03-21 Thread Louis Proyect
Doug Henwood wrote: And who is centering on personalities? Now it's Domhoff, added to a long list of ad hominems, including Jim O'Connor and David Harvey - three radical scholars who've done really fine work. This kind of spurious even-handedness is deeply unfair Michael. The only thing I ever

flaming

2003-03-21 Thread Michael Perelman
I am going to have to be off line for the rest of the day. Please, everybody involved, cool it. -- Michael Perelman Economics Department California State University Chico, CA 95929 Tel. 530-898-5321 E-Mail [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: Re: Re: Re: RE: G. William Domhoff replies...The whole thing?

2003-03-21 Thread Michael Perelman
Please, let's cool it. There are more important things going on now. Do we really need circular firing squads? On Fri, Mar 21, 2003 at 12:09:10PM -0500, Louis Proyect wrote: Doug Henwood wrote: And who is centering on personalities? Now it's Domhoff, added to a long list of ad hominems,

Re: Re: Re: Re: RE: G. William Domhoff replies...The whole thing?

2003-03-21 Thread andie nachgeborenen
Let's everybody chill out. Louis' participation in this latest round has been constructive. We needn't have matters degenerate as they have at times. right now there's a war on. Can everyone here be nice to each other over things that don't matter? Louis has actually beeing trying to do that. As

two people killed in anti-war protest

2003-03-21 Thread e. ahmet tonak
The BBC reported this two deaths. I am interested in knowing anything else like this, i.e. any other deaths, large scale assault, etc.? http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/2872873.stm E. Ahmet Tonak Professor of Economics Simon's Rock College of Bard 84 Alford Road Great Barrington, MA

Re: The politics underlying the war

2003-03-21 Thread Kendall Grant Clark
chris == Chris Burford [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: chris obviously futile. But as the stories mount of unnecessary chris civilian deaths and maimings, and of deaths through friendly chris fire and accidents, this propels the relevance of continued chris protests, against an unjust and

Politics of 'Oil for Food': The big catch

2003-03-21 Thread Paul_A
http://www.moscowtimes.ru/stories/2003/03/20/042.html Thursday, Mar. 20, 2003. Page 7 Report: U.S. Plans to Tap $40Bln Iraq Account In itself, the current proposal of Kofi Anon is technical and almost required: the residual unspent amounts left over from the sale of Iraqi oil under the

spat upon veterans

2003-03-21 Thread marty
For those intested in the history of the spat upon veteran and attempts to create a new myth about the contemporary military, read the newspaper story at: http://www.mountainx.com/news/2003/0319troops.php Marty Hart-Landsberg

butcher

2003-03-21 Thread Dan Scanlan
Title: butcher -- -- Drop Bush, Not Bombs! -- During times of universal deceit, telling the truth becomes a revolutionary act. George Orwell - END OF THE TRAIL

RE: Politics of 'Oil for Food': The big catch

2003-03-21 Thread Devine, James
Title: RE: [PEN-L:35871] Politics of 'Oil for Food': The big catch also, despite all the possible aid to the Iraqi people, the overhead and clean-up will be likely supplied by Bush cronies, who will profit mightily. JD (hi, Paul!) -Original Message- From: Paul_A To: [EMAIL

NO TO WAR in Cochabamba, Bolivia

2003-03-21 Thread Tom Kruse
Title: PK on deficit fears Just got back from our rally and march. A great group of about 400 people, highschoolers, retired workers, nuns and anarchists gathered at noon in the central plaza, did a couple of rounds, and then marched to the US Consulates office in a fancy office building

homeland security signs

2003-03-21 Thread Ann Li
http://titaniumcounter.com/temp/emergency/

Report on Anti-War Actions from Columbus, OH

2003-03-21 Thread Yoshie Furuhashi
Protests in Columbus, OH have never been able to match those of Chicago, San Francisco, and other big cities, but we're making progress in number, breadth, and militancy. Tuesday, March 18: * Die-ins at 15th Ave. and High St., Noon-1 PM (about 30 people) and 5-6 PM (124 people). Thursday,

Re: Re: The politics underlying the war

2003-03-21 Thread Waistline2
In a message dated 3/20/03 11:21:37 PM Pacific Standard Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: At 2003-03-20 08:10 -0500, Louis Proyect wrote: Chris Burford wrote: We will see how the peace movement responds and evolves, and we can each make our personally minuscule contribution to the debate. Peace

Re: Re: RE: G. William Domhoff replies...Thewhole thing?

2003-03-21 Thread Michael Hoover
[EMAIL PROTECTED] 03/21/03 11:52 AM Devine, James wrote: Instead of being pelted with petty personal attacks, Domhoff should be given credit for doing excellent research to produce his books. What for? Professors are paid to do excellent research. whatever gave you above idea? re.

Re: Re: Jazz corruption.

2003-03-21 Thread andie nachgeborenen
Gil Skillman [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: For what it's worth, I think the original connection went corruption--brothels and speakeasies and underground clubs--jazz and sometimes blues. Right, like I said, New Orleans jazz was whorehouse music to entertain the girls or the customers while waiting.

protection rents redux

2003-03-21 Thread Ian Murray
U.S. Set to Award 7 Contracts for Rebuilding of Iraq Initial Work Will Go to American Firms By Paul Blustein and Renae Merle Washington Post Staff Writers Friday, March 21, 2003; Page A30 The U.S. Agency for International Development said yesterday that it will shortly award seven contracts to

RE: G. William Domhoff replies...The whole thing?

2003-03-21 Thread Sabri Oncu
Now that I have been away from this list for the past two days, spending some time with the Peace Initiave friends over at Turkey, look what happened. Justin, Apparently your spell did not work. Could you please give it a second try? Sabri PS: By the way, there are many fights going on on

Re: Re: Re: RE: G. William Domhoff replies...The whole thing?

2003-03-21 Thread Louis Proyect
Michael Hoover: What for? Professors are paid to do excellent research. whatever gave you above idea? I have no idea. It just popped into my head like any other outrageous thought. In any case, here's what a friend of mine, who teaches at a funky NYC community college and who attended

Re: Re: Re: RE: G. William Domhoff replies...The whole thing?

2003-03-21 Thread Joel Blau
Domhoff names names in the structure without conceptualizing it adequately. It's a much more "American" way of going at the issue. At the other extreme, people conceptualize the structure elaborately but do not name any names. Though each has its advantages and disadvantages, a blend of both is

Re: protection rents redux

2003-03-21 Thread k hanly
Are there any articles or data on the distribution of contracts for reconstruction in Afghanistan that Penners would commend? Cheers, Ken Hanly - Original Message - From: Ian Murray [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: pen-l [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Friday, March 21, 2003 4:30 PM Subject: [PEN-L:35881]

Pearls from Perle

2003-03-21 Thread k hanly
This is a prime example of the sort of absolute nuttiness and radical imperialism that drives the Bush policy. Won't even international capital recoil at this stuff. It promises instability and constant intervention and a world race to develop WMD's. What other option is there to stop a power

Michael Albert: Support our Troops

2003-03-21 Thread k hanly
http://www.zmag.org/content/print_article.cfm?itemID=3255sectionID=15 Support Our Troops by Michael Albert; March 17, 2003 If war comes even despite the historic, tenacious, and comprehensive opposition now raging across the planet, the U.S. government will proclaim triumphantly that everyone

Napalm used

2003-03-21 Thread k hanly
From Sydney Morning Herald http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2003/03/21/1047749944836.html The destruction of Safwan Hill was a priority for the attacking forces because it had sophisticated surveillance equipment near the main highway that runs from Kuwait up to Basra and then Baghdad. The

Sacramento peace protest, 3/21

2003-03-21 Thread Seth Sandronsky
37 arrested Friday at Sacramento peace protest By Dorothy Korber -- Bee Staff Writer Published 2:33 p.m. PST Friday, March 21, 2003 At downtown Sacramento's federal building Friday morning, 37 anti-war demonstrators were arrested for staging a die in and blocking the courthouse doors. The event

will it pay?

2003-03-21 Thread Ian Murray
Does Conquest Pay? : The Exploitation of Occupied Industrial Societies Peter Liberman, Richard H. Ullman (Editor), Jack L. Snyder (Editor) Princeton University Press ISBN: 0691002428 September 1998 From the Publisher: Does Conquest Pay? demonstrates that expansion can, in fact, provide

Japan

2003-03-21 Thread Ian Murray
The Japan Times: March 22, 2003 Tokyo peace protest draws thousands The Associated Press Thousands of demonstrators marched Friday through downtown Tokyo to protest the war in Iraq and Japan's plans to support the U.S.-led campaign with nonmilitary aid. The protests came hours after Prime

The spoils of war to the victors aka Iraq Freedom project

2003-03-21 Thread k hanly
US delays announcement of contracts to run Iraqi air, sea ports This all copyright by Agency Freedom Press...aka Agence France Press. Cheers, Ken Hanly WASHINGTON (AFP) Mar 22, 2003 US President George W Bush's administration delayed the award Friday of a contract to a US firm to run

Perle has Global connections.

2003-03-21 Thread k hanly
March 21, 2003 Pentagon Adviser Is Also Advising Global Crossing By STEPHEN LABATON ASHINGTON, March 20 - Even as he advises the Pentagon on war matters, Richard N. Perle, chairman of the influential Defense

law and economics of war rents

2003-03-21 Thread Ian Murray
Conflict Jostles Contracting Sector D.C. Law Firms, Clients Hurry To Alter Services, Insurance By Carrie Johnson Washington Post Staff Writer Saturday, March 22, 2003; Page E01 William A. Roberts III, a longtime government contracts lawyer in Washington, said his phone started ringing Wednesday

Re: Re: Re: RE: G. William Domhoff replies...Thewhole thing?

2003-03-21 Thread Patrick Bond
- Original Message - From: Michael Hoover [EMAIL PROTECTED] Devine, James wrote: Instead of being pelted with petty personal attacks, Domhoff should be given credit for doing excellent research to produce his books. re. domhoff, his study of social backgrounds of powerful white men

Re: Pearls from Perle and Hammurabi

2003-03-21 Thread soula avramidis
"History suggests not. The UN arose from the ashes of a war that theLeague of Nations was unable to avert. It was simply not up to confrontingItaly in Abyssinia, much less - had it survived that debacle - to taking onNazi Germany." If history is repeating itself, then is this the tragedy or the

G. William Domhoff replies...The whole thing?

2003-03-21 Thread e. ahmet tonak
Lou, If it is not too personal, it would be a good idea to forward Domhoff's entire response. Did you do it already? Louis Proyect wrote: Bill Domhoff wrote: for a Marxist, you don't seem to have much appreciation for structure, except of course in the economyat least so I gather