[shell-discuss] Re: [request-sponsor] Requesting sponsor for CR# 6488593(/etc/profile should set TMPDIR to /tmp/$LOGNAME/) ...

2006-11-06 Thread Darren J Moffat
Casper.Dik at Sun.COM wrote: Casper.Dik at Sun.COM wrote: Yeah, you'll notice that if you try to su to root and run installers that run pkgadd internally. I use this method, and the StarOffice 8 installer failed quite mysteriously until I realized it was just an instance of that problem and

[shell-discuss] Re: [request-sponsor] Requesting sponsor for CR# 6488593(/etc/profile should set TMPDIR to /tmp/$LOGNAME/) ...

2006-11-06 Thread Darren J Moffat
Joerg Schilling wrote: Peter Tribble peter.tribble at gmail.com wrote: I regard this as unsafe and undesirable *as a default*. It clutters up /tmp with unnecessary directories, wastes memory and involves extra code at login. I have no problem with administrators or users doing it if they

[shell-discuss] Re: [request-sponsor] Requesting sponsor for CR# 6488593(/etc/profile should set TMPDIR to /tmp/$LOGNAME/) ...

2006-11-06 Thread Mike Gerdts
On 11/6/06, Darren J Moffat Darren.Moffat at sun.com wrote: While it isn't particularly necessary on machines with small numbers of users if you have every logged into a big Sun Ray machine you would have an idea of just how cluttered /tmp can get with hundreds of users all using the same

[shell-discuss] Re: [request-sponsor] Requesting sponsor for CR# 6488593(/etc/profile should set TMPDIR to /tmp/$LOGNAME/) ...

2006-11-06 Thread Darren J Moffat
Mike Gerdts wrote: On 11/6/06, Darren J Moffat Darren.Moffat at sun.com wrote: While it isn't particularly necessary on machines with small numbers of users if you have every logged into a big Sun Ray machine you would have an idea of just how cluttered /tmp can get with hundreds of users all

[request-sponsor] Requesting sponsor for CR# 6488593(/etc/profile should set TMPDIR to /tmp/$LOGNAME/) ...

2006-11-04 Thread Roland Mainz
Casper.Dik at sun.com wrote: Darren J Moffat wrote: Roland Mainz wrote: Requesting sponsor for CR# 6488593 (/etc/profile should set TMPDIR to /tmp/$LOGNAME/) - patch is included in the RFE... This will I believe need an ARC case since it is a change in default behaviour. It also

[request-sponsor] Requesting sponsor for CR# 6488593(/etc/profile should set TMPDIR to /tmp/$LOGNAME/) ...

2006-11-04 Thread Roland Mainz
Darren J Moffat wrote: Casper.Dik at Sun.COM wrote: Since I do this myself in my own .profile I feel duty bound to stand up to the plate and by your sponsor for this. So sign me up for putback sponsor and I'll be ARC case submitter too. Good idea (I use this myself :-)). Should the

pkgadd failure / was: Re: [request-sponsor] Requesting sponsor for CR# 6488593(/etc/profile should set TMPDIR to /tmp/$LOGNAME/) ...

2006-11-04 Thread Roland Mainz
Dave Miner wrote: Casper.Dik at Sun.COM wrote: Darren J Moffat wrote: Roland Mainz wrote: [snip] Good idea (I use this myself :-)). Should the directory be created 700 by default? There's a risk in setting $TMPDIR and making it mode 700; the risk is that programs started under a

[request-sponsor] Requesting sponsor for CR# 6488593(/etc/profile should set TMPDIR to /tmp/$LOGNAME/) ...

2006-11-04 Thread Roland Mainz
Casper.Dik at Sun.COM wrote: Yeah, you'll notice that if you try to su to root and run installers that run pkgadd internally. I use this method, and the StarOffice 8 installer failed quite mysteriously until I realized it was just an instance of that problem and reset TMPDIR to something

[shell-discuss] Re: [request-sponsor] Requesting sponsor for CR# 6488593(/etc/profile should set TMPDIR to /tmp/$LOGNAME/) ...

2006-11-04 Thread casper....@sun.com
Casper.Dik at Sun.COM wrote: Yeah, you'll notice that if you try to su to root and run installers that run pkgadd internally. I use this method, and the StarOffice 8 installer failed quite mysteriously until I realized it was just an instance of that problem and reset TMPDIR to something

[shell-discuss] Re: [request-sponsor] Requesting sponsor for CR#6488593(/etc/profile should set TMPDIR to /tmp/$LOGNAME/) ...

2006-11-04 Thread Roland Mainz
Peter Tribble wrote: I regard this as unsafe and undesirable *as a default*. It clutters up /tmp with unnecessary directories, wastes memory and involves extra code at login. I have no problem with administrators or users doing it if they want, but I see no advantage to having it as the

[shell-discuss] Re: [request-sponsor] Requesting sponsor for CR#6488593(/etc/profile should set TMPDIR to /tmp/$LOGNAME/) ...

2006-11-04 Thread casper....@sun.com
I disagree. The flat layout in /tmp for all temporary files of all users is very very annoying for both admins and users. I doubt mode 1777 is insecure (yes, you can always craft a case where it goes wrong...). Why? I hard ever look in /tmp. OTOH, GNOME already dumps 3 or four temporary

[shell-discuss] Re: [request-sponsor] Requesting sponsor for CR# 6488593(/etc/profile should set TMPDIR to /tmp/$LOGNAME/) ...

2006-11-04 Thread Joerg Schilling
Peter Tribble peter.tribble at gmail.com wrote: I regard this as unsafe and undesirable *as a default*. It clutters up /tmp with unnecessary directories, wastes memory and involves extra code at login. I have no problem with administrators or users doing it if they want, but I see no

[request-sponsor] Requesting sponsor for CR# 6488593 (/etc/profile should set TMPDIR to /tmp/$LOGNAME/) ...

2006-11-02 Thread Darren J Moffat
Roland Mainz wrote: Hi! Requesting sponsor for CR# 6488593 (/etc/profile should set TMPDIR to /tmp/$LOGNAME/) - patch is included in the RFE... This will I believe need an ARC case since it is a change in default behaviour. It also should be done for all shells not just ones that

[request-sponsor] Requesting sponsor for CR# 6488593 (/etc/profile should set TMPDIR to /tmp/$LOGNAME/) ...

2006-11-02 Thread Bart Smaalders
Darren J Moffat wrote: Roland Mainz wrote: Hi! Requesting sponsor for CR# 6488593 (/etc/profile should set TMPDIR to /tmp/$LOGNAME/) - patch is included in the RFE... This will I believe need an ARC case since it is a change in default behaviour. It also should be done for all

[request-sponsor] Requesting sponsor for CR# 6488593 (/etc/profile should set TMPDIR to /tmp/$LOGNAME/) ...

2006-11-02 Thread casper....@sun.com
Darren J Moffat wrote: Roland Mainz wrote: Hi! Requesting sponsor for CR# 6488593 (/etc/profile should set TMPDIR to /tmp/$LOGNAME/) - patch is included in the RFE... This will I believe need an ARC case since it is a change in default behaviour. It also should be done for all

[request-sponsor] Requesting sponsor for CR# 6488593 (/etc/profile should set TMPDIR to /tmp/$LOGNAME/) ...

2006-11-02 Thread Darren J Moffat
Casper.Dik at Sun.COM wrote: Since I do this myself in my own .profile I feel duty bound to stand up to the plate and by your sponsor for this. So sign me up for putback sponsor and I'll be ARC case submitter too. Good idea (I use this myself :-)). Should the directory be created 700 by

[request-sponsor] Requesting sponsor for CR# 6488593 (/etc/profile should set TMPDIR to /tmp/$LOGNAME/) ...

2006-11-02 Thread Dave Miner
Casper.Dik at Sun.COM wrote: Darren J Moffat wrote: Roland Mainz wrote: Hi! Requesting sponsor for CR# 6488593 (/etc/profile should set TMPDIR to /tmp/$LOGNAME/) - patch is included in the RFE... This will I believe need an ARC case since it is a change in default behaviour. It

[request-sponsor] Requesting sponsor for CR# 6488593 (/etc/profile should set TMPDIR to /tmp/$LOGNAME/) ...

2006-11-02 Thread casper....@sun.com
Yeah, you'll notice that if you try to su to root and run installers that run pkgadd internally. I use this method, and the StarOffice 8 installer failed quite mysteriously until I realized it was just an instance of that problem and reset TMPDIR to something else. This, unfortunately, kills

[request-sponsor] Requesting sponsor for CR# 6488593 (/etc/profile should set TMPDIR to /tmp/$LOGNAME/) ...

2006-11-02 Thread Dave Miner
Casper.Dik at Sun.COM wrote: Yeah, you'll notice that if you try to su to root and run installers that run pkgadd internally. I use this method, and the StarOffice 8 installer failed quite mysteriously until I realized it was just an instance of that problem and reset TMPDIR to something