Re: Requesting ideas for Google Summer of Code

2010-03-22 Thread Scott Quesnelle
Reporting. The ability to see things like - how many review requests a given developer has open at the moment. - How many reviews and review requests a given developer has done in the last X days - Stats on review requests. Average length, Min/max. etc. We have also had the situation where with m

Re: Requesting ideas for Google Summer of Code

2010-03-22 Thread Christian Hammond
Hey :) Thanks! I think one of the things I'd really like to see is: 1) The DVCS work mentioned in this thread. 2) Maybe some work on the extensions branch. 3) File attachments 4) Some creative UI for better tracking review requests and reviews. I'd love to see what people would brainstorm separa

Re: Requesting ideas for Google Summer of Code

2010-03-20 Thread David McCloskey
ClearCase :) On Mar 9, 5:44 pm, Christian Hammond wrote: > Hi everyone, > > We've signed up again this year to take part in Google's Summer of Code. > We're still awaiting acceptance, but want to brainstorm some ideas that > students can work on. > > First of all, for those who aren't familiar wi

Re: Requesting ideas for Google Summer of Code

2010-03-19 Thread Eduardo Felipe
Now you have! Congrats! What would you like the most seen implemented? []s Eduardo. On Thu, Mar 11, 2010 at 7:35 PM, Christian Hammond wrote: > We haven't even been accepted yet (though we've had several student > applications already!) so no huge hurry. Ideally, though, within 1-2 weeks. > >

Re: Requesting ideas for Google Summer of Code

2010-03-11 Thread Christian Hammond
We haven't even been accepted yet (though we've had several student applications already!) so no huge hurry. Ideally, though, within 1-2 weeks. Christian -- Christian Hammond - chip...@chipx86.com Review Board - http://www.reviewboard.org VMware, Inc. - http://www.vmware.com On Thu, Mar 11, 20

Re: Requesting ideas for Google Summer of Code

2010-03-11 Thread Paul Schulz
When do the suggestions need to be in by? The company that I work for uses Reviewboard across several international sites. I'm attempting to collect suggestion from the other users. Cheers, Paul On Fri, Mar 12, 2010 at 7:41 AM, Stephen Gallagher wrote: > On 03/10/2010 04:32 PM, Dan Savilonis wr

Re: Requesting ideas for Google Summer of Code

2010-03-11 Thread Stephen Gallagher
On 03/10/2010 04:32 PM, Dan Savilonis wrote: > I would generalize Stephen's idea and just call it general support for > distributed vcs workflow since RB isn't really built around that model > and we're kind of stuffing it in after the fact. > I found some time today and decided to extend post-

Re: Requesting ideas for Google Summer of Code

2010-03-10 Thread Christian Hammond
It's not the complexity so much. LDAP, AD, and S3 are things masked by auth and storage backends in Django. We can get those cheaply and there's no user-facing UI for any of it. Furthermore, those are needed for core operations of Review Board. Features like advanced bug tracker integration or bu

Re: Requesting ideas for Google Summer of Code

2010-03-10 Thread Brad Hards
On Thursday 11 March 2010 05:39:29 pm Christian Hammond wrote: > I would love integration like this, but it's going to have to wait until we > land Extensions support in 2.0. Otherwise we end up complicating the > codebase, dependencies, UI and settings. I respect your call on this, but my (hackish

Re: Requesting ideas for Google Summer of Code

2010-03-10 Thread Christian Hammond
I would love integration like this, but it's going to have to wait until we land Extensions support in 2.0. Otherwise we end up complicating the codebase, dependencies, UI and settings. Christian -- Christian Hammond - chip...@chipx86.com Review Board - http://www.reviewboard.org VMware, Inc. -

Re: Requesting ideas for Google Summer of Code

2010-03-10 Thread Brad Hards
On Wednesday 10 March 2010 08:44:48 am Christian Hammond wrote: > Hi everyone, > > We've signed up again this year to take part in Google's Summer of Code. > We're still awaiting acceptance, but want to brainstorm some ideas that > students can work on. I'd like to see integration with buildbot (v

Re: Requesting ideas for Google Summer of Code

2010-03-10 Thread JohnHenry
Hi, Christian. I think the post-review tools can make some improvements on CVS like file-revision-independent Repository. As to the dashboard of Reviewboard, If it gives users ( super user ) the ability to Creating and Customizing New columns, that would be cool. And more strict permission system a

Re: Requesting ideas for Google Summer of Code

2010-03-10 Thread Christian Hammond
I spent some time on review.source.android.com a bit earlier and you're right, it's much snappier. I'm going to spend some time looking into what the slowdowns are. Part of it may be due to the Django templating. Part of it is likely Pygments syntax highlighting. I'll spend some time poking around

Re: Requesting ideas for Google Summer of Code

2010-03-10 Thread Dan Savilonis
I think it's just a general performance comparison, though initial diff loading is particularly slow. I haven't profiled it, but if you compare loading reviews.reviewboard.org dashboard to review.source.android.com, or one of the diffs, the latter just feels much more instantaneous. I don't know ho

Re: Requesting ideas for Google Summer of Code

2010-03-10 Thread Christian Hammond
Agreed on both parts. There's a bit more that Review Board does than Gerrit and Rietveld under the hood, but we should certainly strive to make things faster. Is there a specific area where Review Board feels slower to you? Christian -- Christian Hammond - chip...@chipx86.com Review Board - htt

Re: Requesting ideas for Google Summer of Code

2010-03-10 Thread Dan Savilonis
I would generalize Stephen's idea and just call it general support for distributed vcs workflow since RB isn't really built around that model and we're kind of stuffing it in after the fact. I'd also love to see performance improvements. I haven't done any real comparisons, but Rietveld and Gerrit

Re: Requesting ideas for Google Summer of Code

2010-03-09 Thread Stephen Gallagher
It was discussed in another thread, but I think it would be great to improve the git support by handling patch-sets in post-review. The idea would be to support the following workflow: Create a branch based on the upstream master (the repository that RB is storing). Apply several patches on that

Requesting ideas for Google Summer of Code

2010-03-09 Thread Christian Hammond
Hi everyone, We've signed up again this year to take part in Google's Summer of Code. We're still awaiting acceptance, but want to brainstorm some ideas that students can work on. First of all, for those who aren't familiar with this, Google Summer of Code is a yearly program from Google where st