How I read George's comment is that picking one piece of criteria alone does not necessarily qualify as being that much more conservative. Having worked at a nuke plant for a good while, there is an extensive overall program that combined makes a very high level of fire protection such as the referenced on-site FD as well as trained plant personnel as well as extensive rated construction, tightly controlled contents of rooms, enforcement of criteria, and extensive testing and maintenance etc etc. My plant wasn't even a reactor site but a enrichment facility where it gets really tight.

Craig: BTW, we had Lockwood Greene do some work for us. Where you with them in the early 90's. Respond off-Forum.

Roland

On Nov 19, 2008, at 6:47 AM, <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> <[EMAIL PROTECTED] > wrote:

You lost me there George. So through all that would you say to not protect or to protect at a lesser degree would be adequate? Based on......?

If you look at a mechanical room the activity going on within would be similar to no less than OH1 (light mfg, electrical, rotating machinery, light lubricants, minimal combustibles). I could hardly say that it would be similar to a church or library (LH).

Electrical rooms especially if cable trays are present can pose a greater hazard than an air handling room. Again no way to justify LH, OH1 at minimum. Now mind you I'm not talking about residential stuff here.

Now as far as the "when in doubt make it stout" approach, is there any wording anywhere that states you can not increase design criteria for an area without adopting the higher standard for the entire facility? I haven't found that anywhere, so if I chose to apply a criteria for a pump room that may be referenced in a Nuke section of NFPA 13, where is it stated or implied that I have to provide Nuke level criteria to everything else in the entire facility?



Craig L. Prahl, CET
Fire Protection Specialist
Mechanical Department
CH2MHILL
Lockwood Greene
1500 International Drive
PO Box 491, Spartanburg, SC  29304-0491
Direct - 864.599.4102
Fax - 864.599.8439
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://www.ch2m.com


-----Original Message-----
From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] ] On Behalf Of George Church
Sent: Wednesday, November 19, 2008 9:32 AM
To: [email protected]
Subject: RE: Mech/Electrical room classification(waExistingPipeScheduledSystem Water Supply)

Craig-
I'd disagree that a specialty risk, especially when we don the nuke mentality hat, is as readily transportable to other plain jane risks as you state. Nuke plants revert to a higher standard of care than the reasonable protection levels in other standards. Redundancy is a precaution that MUST be taken- whether its derived as a requirement in an NFPA Standard, NRC, or insurance carrier. The downside is too great- I remember being 20 miles away from TMI and missing reading week since our college shut down for a week. If you've seen China Syndrome, stick Gov Thornburgh up there and you see what we lived thru- the parallel is too scary to be coincidental.

I would agree that if you were to transport the protection requirements for a portion of a nuke plant to a lesser risk (which is 99.99% of anything we see) you'd have it covered EXCEPT the caveat that it should be understood that these requirements assume other nuke protection levels are in place in what could be related criteria, which might not be the case in the lesser risk the criteria are transferred to.

Let's say all nuke plants are required to have an on-site FD. Due to this, water durations for areas "outside the fence" might be decreased since almost instantaneous trained response is anticipated. You shouldn't take this lessened duration and apply it in Joey's backyard where the nearest FD could be 100 miles away.

glc

-----Original Message-----
From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
[mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Wednesday, November 19, 2008 9:09 AM
To: [email protected]
Subject: RE: Mech/Electrical room classification (waExistingPipeScheduledSystem Water Supply)

Every time there is either an electrical or fire pump room, this is the criteria acceptable to or required by the AHJ's & Underwriters. Regardless of whether the criteria is under the light water reactor heading or not, if the criteria is acceptable for this type of occupancy it is defendable for any lesser occupancy.

These rooms are the same no matter what environment they protect. In industrial applications the fire pumps are not out on the production floor with the hazardous material they are in a separate building, or room same as they would be for any other occupancy so what goes on elsewhere in the occupancy has no bearing on the protection scheme for a pump or electrical room. If the building requires sprinklers then the above criteria is applied.

Gas fired boilers are looked the same as a gas fired water heater, oil fired equipment is looked at differently. Sorry but I can't extrapolate the thoughts of those writing the codes and standards.

Height of room when you're speaking of storage IS relevant but it's not relevant when you're talking about a space designed for equipment. Two different things. Typically I don't see a lot of rack storage going on in mechanical spaces. We're talking about mechanical spaces. Fire codes prohibit storage of combustibles in mechanical and electrical rooms.


Craig L. Prahl, CET
Fire Protection Specialist
Mechanical Department
CH2MHILL
Lockwood Greene
1500 International Drive
PO Box 491, Spartanburg, SC  29304-0491
Direct - 864.599.4102
Fax - 864.599.8439
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://www.ch2m.com


-----Original Message-----
From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
[mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Thom McMahon
Sent: Tuesday, November 18, 2008 6:16 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: RE: Mech/Electrical room classification (waExistingPipe ScheduledSystem Water Supply)

Remember that 21.32 addresses only "Advanced light Water Reactor Electric Generating plants" This would not be the across the board design criteria for all M/E spaces. These plants have fuel oil and lube pumps flowing hundreds of gallons per minute. Not quite the same as a furnace room in a nursing home. Or a gas fired direct vent boiler system in a school, to say nothing of the Electrical room in either.

It would appear that it is the fuel and lube oil that drives the density requirements. Interesting that Gas fired boilers are not included. I wonder would that mean that Gas fueled Emergency generators are not included also?
Probably goes back to look at the lube oil requirements.

Height of room always has code support, or why reduce the area for QR in LH and OH occupancies? That alone says "Height Matters." OH I has 8' storage height limitations, so Height matters. OH II has 12' storage limitations again "Height Matters." Many storage application sprinklers are listed for specific height building or storage arrangements, again "Height Matters."


Thom McMahon, SET
Firetech, Inc.
2560 Copper Ridge Dr
P.O. Box 882136
Steamboat Springs, CO 80488
Tel:  970-879-7952
Fax: 970-879-7926



Generator rooms are at .25 gpm/sf NFPA 13, 21.32.1.7

Fire Pump rooms the same. (next paragraph)

That would put them into the OH II category.

Most electrical rooms don't require sprinklers if they follow the NFPA 13 and bldg. code requirements for rated construction and the other items listed including no liquid filled transformers.

Elevator pits, well that's kind of obvious.

Mechanical rooms aren't given any options so height of room or other "logic"
has no Code support.



Craig L. Prahl, CET
Fire Protection Specialist

_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum
For Technical Assistance, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

To Unsubscribe, send an email to:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
(Put the word unsubscribe in the subject field) _______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum
For Technical Assistance, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

To Unsubscribe, send an email to:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
(Put the word unsubscribe in the subject field)

_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum
For Technical Assistance, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

To Unsubscribe, send an email to:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
(Put the word unsubscribe in the subject field)
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum
For Technical Assistance, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

To Unsubscribe, send an email to:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
(Put the word unsubscribe in the subject field)


_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum
For Technical Assistance, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

To Unsubscribe, send an email to:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
(Put the word unsubscribe in the subject field)

Reply via email to