Well said James. We have three other companies claiming to have
commercial generators of power. Each of these claims is based on
dubious demonstrations. What is the Miley claim based on? Can we
expect his claim to be debated and examined in the way the Rossi claim
has experienced? Just where does the Miley claim fall in the process
of competing claims for a practical device. What reason does anyone
have to vote for his claim? I think these questions must be examined
before we all get excited.
Ed
On Feb 8, 2013, at 9:25 AM, James Bowery wrote:
OK, guys, what is #($*#$ is going on here?
If Miley has what he claims to have -- a system that consistently
produces power with no input power -- isn't it GAME OVER regarding
Norman Ramsey's statement in the preamble of the DoE's cold fusion
report that stated:
"Ordinarily, new scientific discoveries are claimed to be consistent
and reproducible; as a result, if the experiments are not
complicated, the discovery can usually be confirmed or disproved in
a few months. The claims of cold fusion, however, are unusual in
that even the strongest proponents of cold fusion assert that the
experiments, for unknown reasons, are not consistent and
reproducible at the present time. However, even a single short but
valid cold fusion period would be revolutionary."-
Dr. Norman Ramsey, Nobel laureate and professor of physics at
Harvard University was the only person on the the 1989 Department of
Energy cold fusion review panel to voice a dissenting opinion.
Ramsey insisted on the inclusion of this preamble as an alternative
to his resignation from the panel.
Moreover, isn't it also GAME OVER regarding Gibbs's demand for a
system that not only demonstrates the effect but has market potential?
On Fri, Feb 8, 2013 at 9:56 AM, Terry Blanton <hohlr...@gmail.com>
wrote:
On Fri, Feb 8, 2013 at 5:49 AM, Moab Moab <moab2...@googlemail.com>
wrote:
> It seems LENUCO might be up to get funding from ARPA-E. Maybe.
First he'll
> need enough votes.
>
> http://futureenergy.ultralightstartups.com/campaign/detail/861
Funding is not conditional upon getting enough votes. It does,
however, help. Selection is by ARPA-E committee.
