Thanks Dims, Since I called for the meeting, I'll take responsibility for getting the info for the meeting posted and for getting summaries documented and posted.
-Nick Nicholas Gallardo WebSphere - REST & WebServices Development [email protected] Phone: 512-286-6258 Building: 903 / 5G-016 Davanum Srinivas <[email protected] m> To [email protected] 06/18/2009 02:47 cc PM Subject Re: Architecture Q&A Call Please respond to wink-...@incubato r.apache.org Eli, The goal is to be as open as possible and post as many things as possible ahead of time, anything/everything to facilitate an off-line discussion and ensure broadest participation. * Any documents, please post URL's to wink-dev@ before the meeting (google docs or wiki or JIRA or anywhere else public is ok) * Come up with some sort of agenda items that needs to be discussed (this can be done on the wiki) * Set up a specific start/stop time for the meeting so everyone can plan to be there at least for that duration. * Please post the date/time of the IRC meeting, agenda and pointers to any documents. * Someone should volunteer to keep the meeting on track * Come up with proposals and possible solutions or action items for agenda items * Post all above in logical chunks to wink-dev@ and ask for closure on the mailing list. This helps people who cannot attend the IRC chat and still want to participate * When the chat winds down, please post the log to wink-dev. thanks, dims On 06/18/2009 01:53 PM, Baram, Eliezer wrote: > Dim, > I'm new to IRC meeting and I try to figure out the right format that will make this meeting work. > I would call the meeting successful if valid questions will be raised during the conference and a discussion will be made. > > How do you recommend to run the IRC meeting ? > > If we were running the meeting In a conference call with an ability to share documents (by Google document for instance, or sent earlier by mail) I would format this meeting in a way where the contributors of the submissions would present their submission. These presentations would hopefully raise questions, and a discussion will be created. What can be an IRC alternative to this in order to trigger such discussion? > > Thanks, > Eli > > -----Original Message----- > From: Davanum Srinivas [mailto:[email protected]] > Sent: Thursday, June 18, 2009 5:57 PM > To: [email protected] > Subject: Re: Architecture Q&A Call > > Nick, > > Yes, please use IRC and post the transcript to the mailing list. > > No, you cannot make decisions on the IRC chat, you need to post what ever you are proposing on the mailing list and VOTE > on it (72 hours etc as usual) > > thanks, > dims > > On 06/18/2009 10:45 AM, Nicholas L Gallardo wrote: >> Jason, you (and anyone else for that matter) are absolutely invited, should >> have made that point clear. I mentioned it on the list for exactly that >> reason though. >> >> I agree that calls are not typical for the Apache projects I've seen >> either. But, it was proposed as a means to try to work through the issues >> quickly and to get everyone acquainted. Most discussion will obviously >> happen on the mailing lists. But, we need to come to a decision quickly on >> the base code as that's holding up any other work. If the community would >> rather handle it via IRC then we can do that. If done on IRC, do you just >> copy/paste the transcript somewhere for people to comment on later? >> >> Mentors, any suggestions here for how to have synchronous work sessions to >> get through discussions quickly? >> >> -Nick >> >> >> >> Nicholas Gallardo >> WebSphere - REST& WebServices Development >> [email protected] >> Phone: 512-286-6258 >> Building: 903 / 5G-016 >> >> >> >> Jason Dillon >> <[email protected] >> om> To >> Sent by: Jason [email protected] >> Dillon cc >> <jason.dil...@gma >> il.com> Subject >> Re: Architecture Q&A Call >> >> 06/18/2009 09:11 >> AM >> >> >> Please respond to >> wink-...@incubato >> r.apache.org >> >> >> >> >> >> >> I think I can make that, if I'm invited of course. >> >> Though along those lines, typically "calls" aren't really used that >> much by the Apache community... IRC at times has even been a stretch, >> though I think many communities use it for regular group >> communications. It may be construed as a bad sign if the first major >> discussion is effectively offline. Perhaps if a transcript of the >> call was recorded somewhere, on this list, it might fly. Otherwise >> it may be better from a community perspective to hold this meeting >> over IRC on freenode.net. But I'm unsure, we'll let the mentors chime >> in more on this. >> >> I do think there needs to be more discussion on the merits of both >> codebases before a descison is made. >> >> Hope this helps... >> >> --jason >> >> >> On Jun 18, 2009, at 8:57 PM, Nicholas L Gallardo wrote: >> >>> All, >>> >>> I think it would be useful to have a call next week for some Q&A >>> regarding >>> the two runtimes and architectures. We can have the relevant people >>> give >>> summaries of the work that's been contributed and then answer >>> questions. >>> >>> Given the geographic dispersion, getting a time nailed down will be >>> tough. >>> How does 8:00AM CST on Tuesday the 23rd work for everyone? >>> >>> -Nick >>> >>> >>> >>> Nicholas Gallardo >>> WebSphere - REST& WebServices Development >>> [email protected] >>> Phone: 512-286-6258 >>> Building: 903 / 5G-016 >>
