Re: Turkey

2002-12-03 Thread Sabri Oncu
Article Ian sent: US hawk wants Turkey in EU Writing in the Turkish Daily Cumhuriyet today Mustafa Balbay claims that, according to his sources, US hawks want Turkey in Iraq too. He reports that the US asked Turkey to be the logistic base of the attack on Iraq and plans to station 250,000

Key Aide Seeks Military Pledge From Turkey

2002-12-03 Thread Sabri Oncu
Key Aide Seeks Military Pledge From Turkey By Vernon Loeb Washington Post Staff Writer Tuesday, December 3, 2002; Page A01 LONDON, Dec. 2 -- Deputy Defense Secretary Paul D. Wolfowitz today launched a mission to press Turkey to allow the United States to use its military bases and to provide

Re: exploiting the intelligentsia

2002-12-03 Thread Chris Burford
Gene wrote about the sophisticated financing that allows Harvard to maintain its position as a preeminent business while apparently offering charity. and At 02/12/02 08:02 -0800, Johan wrote: When will the vast armies of the working intelligentsia see the bigger picture on a world scale?

Re: Re: Maquiladoras not beneficial

2002-12-03 Thread Doug Henwood
Sabri Oncu wrote: I don't know what troll means but I happen to have some ideas about right wingers. I hold that a necessary, but not sufficient, condition for being a leftist is the recognition that the US is an imperialist state screwing most of the rest of the world. Don't forget the U.S.'s

Re: Maquiladoras not beneficial

2002-12-03 Thread Michael Hoover
[EMAIL PROTECTED] 12/02/02 05:50PM Also, many of the maq's are shutting down as contractors flee to China and other low cost labor. Michael Perelman just released international labour organization report indicates 200,000 such jobs have shifted to china... michael hoover

RE: Re: Maquiladoras not beneficial

2002-12-03 Thread Devine, James
Title: RE: [PEN-L:32701] Re: Maquiladoras not beneficial to me, it doesn't matter that much whether deLong is a right-winger or not. I can filter out his right-wing opinions, just as I do with the New York TIMES or U.S. National Public Radio. Just as I filter out a lot of the crap that some

the state and eternal war.

2002-12-03 Thread Devine, James
Title: the state and eternal war. was: [RE: [PEN-L:32699] Re: Re: eternal war for eternal peace update] of course, eternal war will produce eternal peace for many... Ian quotes: If protection rackets represent organized crime at its smoothest, then war making and state making -

Re: Re: Maquiladoras not beneficial

2002-12-03 Thread Louis Proyect
A little while ago I discovered that Brad Delong has an article defending neoliberalism in Mexico on his website that originally appeared in Foreign Affairs: http://www.j-bradford-delong.net/Econ_Articles/themexicanpesocrisis.html It is very useful, even if totally wrong--especially when read

Re: Re: Re: Maquiladoras not beneficial

2002-12-03 Thread Michael Perelman
Lou is correct on several points. Brad typically supports neo-liberal policies abroad and, at least to my mind, he is more often than not wrong. Also, the 3 people he mentioned did leave in disgust about Brad's behavior. I thought that it would have been healthier to have dialogued with Brad,

Re: Re: exploiting the intelligentsia

2002-12-03 Thread johan soderberg
Chris wrote: enough insight and flexible irony, (thank you)...and... could only have conviction in the importance of increasing the market share of enterprise A versus enterprise B and feign some team spirit Right so. The two just wont mix, will they! Poor capital, how can it muster

Dow Chemical

2002-12-03 Thread Dan Scanlan
I received the following PR Release today. The dow-chemical.com site is quite a sophisticated satire of the real thing (at dow.com). In today's surreal news world, the line between spoof and official is blurred far beyond Jonathan Swift, so that the corporate blathering of the Dan Rathers in

Social Security and the 2002 Election.htm

2002-12-03 Thread Alejandro Valle Baeza
Title: Social Security and the 2002 Election November 7, 2002 Social Security and the 2002 Election by Michael Tanner Michael Tanner is director of the Cato Institute's Project on Social Security Choice. "This election is a referendum on

Re: Re: Re: Re: Maquiladoras not beneficial

2002-12-03 Thread Doug Henwood
Michael Perelman wrote: Lou is correct on several points. Brad typically supports neo-liberal policies abroad and, at least to my mind, he is more often than not wrong. Also, the 3 people he mentioned did leave in disgust about Brad's behavior. I thought that it would have been healthier to

Re: Re: Re: Maquiladoras not beneficial

2002-12-03 Thread Ian Murray
- Original Message - From: Doug Henwood [EMAIL PROTECTED] Don't forget the U.S.'s junior partners, like Canada, the EU, and Japan, who sometimes act as if they're above the imperial screwing even as they benefit from it. Doug Not long after 9-11 there was a

Re: Maquiladoras not beneficial

2002-12-03 Thread Ian Murray
- Original Message - From: Devine, James [EMAIL PROTECTED] this is the standard way that the US imperialists see it: the US provides international public goods from which the other countries -- including the totally dominated ones -- benefit. The countries that don't go along (e.g.,

test

2002-12-03 Thread andie nachgeborenen
test __ Do you Yahoo!? Yahoo! Mail Plus - Powerful. Affordable. Sign up now. http://mailplus.yahoo.com

RE: Re: Maquiladoras not beneficial

2002-12-03 Thread Devine, James
Title: RE: [PEN-L:32721] Re: Maquiladoras not beneficial I described: the standard way that the US imperialists see it: the US provides international public goods from which the other countries -- including the totally dominated ones -- benefit. The countries that don't go along (e.g.,

Re: RE: Re: Maquiladoras not beneficial

2002-12-03 Thread Ian Murray
- Original Message - From: Devine, James [EMAIL PROTECTED] Ian, Ian, Ian! you're getting too close to reality! the efforts by individual parts of the military-industrial complex (or the whole shebang) to gain advantage for themselves is part of the reality of imperialism. It's not

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Maquiladoras not beneficial

2002-12-03 Thread Michael Perelman
Dialogue requires a certain degree of courtesy that was often absent from his posts. On Tue, Dec 03, 2002 at 02:22:32PM -0500, Doug Henwood wrote: Michael Perelman wrote: Lou is correct on several points. Brad typically supports neo-liberal policies abroad and, at least to my mind, he is

RE: Re: RE: Re: Maquiladoras not beneficial

2002-12-03 Thread Devine, James
Title: RE: [PEN-L:32724] Re: RE: Re: Maquiladoras not beneficial I said: It's not the same as the self-perception and self-justification of imperialists that I described. Ian writes: Right, except that I think they're no longer worried about the fables of international public goods

RE: crime stats

2002-12-03 Thread Max B. Sawicky
http://www.fbi.gov/ucr/ucr.htm http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov/bjs/abstract/cvusst.htm -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]On Behalf Of [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Monday, December 02, 2002 3:37 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [PEN-L:32685] crime stats Hi,

Chomsky: A man of great integrity?

2002-12-03 Thread Steve Diamond
The critique of Chomsky on Cambodia is hardly a canard. Thus, I cannot understand your claim, Michael, that he is a man of, what did you say, great integrity? Consider the following selections from an article by Chomsky and Herman in 1977 (http://www.zmag.org/chomsky/index.cfm Distortions at

RE: Chomsky: A man of great integrity?

2002-12-03 Thread Max B. Sawicky
I checked one item in this post against the text (which is here: http://www.zmag.org/chomsky/articles/7706-distortions.html The slaughter by the Khmer Rouge is a Moss-New York Times creation. The context for the statement is not, as is implied by the extract above, a general denial of mass

RE: RE: Chomsky: A man of great integrity?

2002-12-03 Thread Devine, James
Title: RE: [PEN-L:32730] RE: Chomsky: A man of great integrity? MS concludes: One should not judge the morality of NC's statements at the time by how well they accord with what is known retrospectively, in light of the reality that the sources on genocide were not trustworthy. Untrustworthy

Late Job Posting: Macroeconomics, Lewis and Clark College (fwd)

2002-12-03 Thread Martin Hart-Landsberg
I hope that Pen-l can help generate some good candidates for this position at the college where I teach. Marty Hart-Landsberg PLEASE FORWARD TO INTERESTED PARTIES-- Macroeconomics The Department of Economics at Lewis Clark College invites applications for a one-year position for the

Re: RE: Chomsky: A man of great integrity?

2002-12-03 Thread Steve Diamond
Max, As you note, Chomsky and Herman admit there were sharply conflicting assessments at the time. The question is why they chose to disparage those assessments that suggested a genocide was underway. I would suggest it is because doing so was consistent with their politics - which still today

Re: Re: RE: Chomsky: A man of great integrity?

2002-12-03 Thread topp8564
On 4/12/2002 11:53 AM, Steve Diamond [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The remarkable thing is how exactly this mirrors the approach of the U.S. Government when it chooses facts to fits its politics - as it so shamefully did in the case of Rwanda. (By the way I can find nothing that suggests that

Re: Re: RE: Chomsky: A man of great integrity?

2002-12-03 Thread Louis Proyect
Stephen Diamond: that Chomsky ever stated that he was wrong in 1977.) The failure of the left to establish a credible independent foreign policy opposed to the politics of both the U.S. government and those of regimes like Hussein's, Castro's, Lee Kuan Yew's, and Kim il Jung's is a tragedy

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Maquiladoras not beneficial

2002-12-03 Thread Carrol Cox
Doug Henwood wrote: Michael Perelman wrote: True enough, but it's an odd model of dialogue that will admit only people in fundamental agreement with each other. I guess it's the left version of Richard Feinberg's wonderful comment that democracy only works when there's fundamental

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Maquiladoras not beneficial

2002-12-03 Thread Louis Proyect
Carrol Cox: Brad is an enemy, but one can talk to him just as Chou tried to talk to Dulles one morning during the Geneva Conference. (They both arrived early one morning; Chou offered to shake hands, Dulles snubbed him.) In the present case Lou is playing a marxist version of Dulles's style,

reply to Jim Devine and Thiago on Chomsky

2002-12-03 Thread Steve Diamond
Jim, it is certainly, I will agree, Chomsky's obsession to use an apparently objective critique of the western media to make his political arguments, but to ignore the politics behind this approach is to reward form over substance. In your parenthetical ending you come dangerously close to a

Re: reply to Jim Devine and Thiago on Chomsky

2002-12-03 Thread Ian Murray
- Original Message - From: Steve Diamond [EMAIL PROTECTED] Thiago suggested that noone on the left supports regimes (a term I usually apply to states controlled by groups that gained that position without a democratic election, as opposed to governments which have some claim to

Bush: let's study global warming some more

2002-12-03 Thread Louis Proyect
NY Times, Dec. 3, 2002 Can Global Warming Be Studied Too Much? By ANDREW C. REVKIN WASHINGTON, Dec. 2 — On Tuesday, the Bush administration convenes a three-day meeting here to set its new agenda for research on climate change. But many climate experts who will attend say talking about more

Re: reply to Jim Devine and Thiago on Chomsky

2002-12-03 Thread topp8564
On 4/12/2002 1:35 PM, Steve Diamond [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Thiago suggested that noone on the left supports regimes (a term I usually apply to states controlled by groups that gained that position without a democratic election, as opposed to governments which have some claim to

Chomsky

2002-12-03 Thread Michael Perelman
I thought that Jim, Thiago, and Max answered Steve quite well. Chomsky was not concerned about defending Cambodia, only trying to show the hypocracy of the US. Once in France, I saw a very interesting Yugoslavian documentary on Cambodia. It made the case that Pol Pot had to move the people out

your views are not pointless, Thiago

2002-12-03 Thread Steve Diamond
Your perspective is representative of many on the left and thus expressing it seems far from pointless. But that does not mean that it makes sense. For example, you admit to some problems with the Castro regime (rightly describing him as a thug) but then leap to the conclusion that that mean[s]

Re: Chomsky

2002-12-03 Thread Steve Diamond
The Germans had a word for such movements of entire populations out of the cities, Michael, I think they called it das endliche losung - and, just think, they were fed and clothed during the entire ride. - Original Message - From: Michael Perelman [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: Chomsky

2002-12-03 Thread Michael Hoover
[EMAIL PROTECTED] 12/03/02 22:39 PM To say that Iraq before the Gulf War had some success in developing health and education does not make someone a supporter of SH. All too often in political discourse to say a positive word about any of today's demons, makes one an agent of the devil. Michael

Die Endloesung

2002-12-03 Thread andie nachgeborenen
Steve Diamond [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The Germans had a word for such movements of entire populations out of thecities, Michael, I think they called it "das endliche losung" - and, justthink, they were fed and clothed during the entire ride. Die Endloesung, bitte. Actually, they weren't fed,

Re: reply to Jim Devine and Thiago on Chomsky

2002-12-03 Thread andie nachgeborenen
Steve Diamond [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Jim, it is certainly, I will agree, Chomsky's obsession to use an apparentlyobjective critique of the "western media" to make his political arguments, This is perverse, Steve. When C has a political point to make, he makes it directly. Why not take him at

Die Endloesung

2002-12-03 Thread andie nachgeborenen
Steve Diamond [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The Germans had a word for such movements of entire populations out of thecities, Michael, I think they called it "das endliche losung" - and, justthink, they were fed and clothed during the entire ride. Die Endloesung, bitte. Actually, they weren't fed,

Re: your views are not pointless, Thiago

2002-12-03 Thread topp8564
Erm... I am confused, though I think I must agree with what you have written now. I thought you, in your previous post, had whipped up the charge that Chomsky and unspecified leftists were soft on Pol Pot, Hussein, Castro, Lee Kuan Yew (!!! this just cracks me up every time!), North Korea and

Turkey

2002-12-03 Thread Ian Murray
[New York Times] December 4, 2002 Turkey Saying No to Accepting G.I.'s in Large Numbers By MICHAEL R. GORDON with ERIC SCHMITT ANKARA, Turkey, Dec. 3 - Turkey today said that it would not allow the United States to deploy substantial numbers of ground troops on its territory in the event of a