Re: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread David Roberson
It is strange that anyone would want an unproved and expensive device. I suspect that Rossi thinks that he can work with NI and stabilize the thing, and this may be true. My personal opinion is that some serious engineering work will be required to make the system safe and repeatable. If I

Re: [Vo]:Right Sizing Nickel Particles

2012-01-22 Thread Chemical Engineer
Frank, The Ni metal is not dissolved is it? I also understand the smaller the Ni particle, the lower the melting temperature due to melting point depression. * * *Melting-point depression* is a term referring to the phenomenon of reduction of the melting point

Re: [Vo]:Mark Gibbs - Forbes- on LENR January 20th blog

2012-01-22 Thread Jed Rothwell
Ron Kita chiralex.k...@gmail.com wrote: Here is the latest from Mark Gibbs. http://www.forbes.com/sites/markgibbs/2012/01/20/cold-fusion-theory-or-fact/ This is the worst column he has written. He is a professional science writer yet he makes a hash of basic terminology! He does not

Re: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

2012-01-22 Thread Harry Veeder
On Sat, Jan 21, 2012 at 11:05 PM, Jed Rothwell jedrothw...@gmail.com wrote: Rossi has made tremendous contributions to humanity, so stop kvetching about his foibles. They make no difference. With respect to Rossi's own measure that commercial success matters above all else, he has yet to make

RE: [Vo]:Mark Gibbs - Forbes- on LENR January 20th blog

2012-01-22 Thread *** Craig Brown ***
Gibbs seems utterly desperate to explain LENR away as just an unrepeatable anomaly and as usual Mary is one of the first to get the word scam in there somewhere. I find it curious how the noisy negativists get so over the top obsessed with ramming their opinions down everyone's throat. I can

RE: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread *** Craig Brown ***
Jed, what you have described here is EXACTLY what happened to the Steorn Forum. MaryYugo and all the moletrap clowns took over the forum and it became so abusive that the forum was closed. They are a cancer and a barrier to progress because of their own egos. These people include Mary Yugo,

Re: [Vo]:Ni-64 enrichment

2012-01-22 Thread Harry Veeder
There was never any hard evidence it had been moved. Terry ( I think) remarked on voretx a day or so after the test that a tractor trailer drove off with it as if someone witnessed the departure, but he was really just extrapolating. Harry On Sun, Jan 22, 2012 at 1:36 AM, Shaun Taylor

Re: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread John Milstone
You mean the Steorn that hand-picked a jury of scientists to test their technology, which then unanimously determined that Steorn failed to show any signs of excess energy? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steorn#Jury_process From: *** Craig Brown ***

Re: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

2012-01-22 Thread Jed Rothwell
John Milstone john_sw_orla...@yahoo.com wrote: It would also explain the long, forceful jet of water/steam coming out of the E-Cat then the high-pressure side was opened at the end of the video. Rossi would have to hide the fact that the system is actually holding a temperature much higher

Re: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

2012-01-22 Thread Jed Rothwell
I wrote: Rossi and others measured the temperature and mass of the water dumped out of the reactor at the end, and reported it. . . . Of course it cools down to 100 deg C immediately. - Jed

Re: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread Alain Sepeda
Right, critical mode is not easy. for fission reactors, the resonance bells allow to have some working point where power/temperature curve create negative feedback (and also the hopeful unexpected delayed neutron that save the first reactors from fast divergence). Tchernobyl is the example of what

Re: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

2012-01-22 Thread John Milstone
There are serious questions about the setup of the temperature measurements on the various E-Cat tests.  Just because Rossi's thermocouple said the water was at 100 C (or whatever it read) doesn't mean that was the actual temperature. According to Mats Lewan, Rossi provided and set up all the

Re: [Vo]:Mark Gibbs - Forbes- on LENR January 20th blog

2012-01-22 Thread Eric Walker
On Sun, Jan 22, 2012 at 12:43 PM, *** Craig Brown *** cr...@overunity.cowrote: Gibbs seems utterly desperate to explain LENR away as just an unrepeatable anomaly I'm not so sure. I would have guessed the opposite to be the case. In this instance he might be responding to pressure as a

Re: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread Tom Barnett
yes - the rules: Pathological Skepticism is banned if your mind is open and you wish to test crazy claims rather than ridiculing them or explaining them away, hop on board! For what my opinion is worth, it is quite clear from what I have been reading here that those of you who are sincere

[Vo]:Here is the truth..

2012-01-22 Thread Dusty Bradshaw
Cold Fusion turned me gay... srsly.

Re: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread mixent
In reply to Alain Sepeda's message of Sun, 22 Jan 2012 22:03:57 +0100: Hi, [snip] for Ni+H LENR there does not seem to exist a reversible negative feedback, so like any engineer will know you have to stabilize the system with an outside control loop. You can keep it starved of fuel and let it

Re: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread Robert Lynn
I am pretty sure Rossi's stability and control problem stems from relying on heat transfer through a large temperature differential (low Watts per degree) to cool a reaction that has a positive temperature coefficient (ie gets more powerful with increasing temperature). The simple fix is to use

Re: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

2012-01-22 Thread Jed Rothwell
John Milstone john_sw_orla...@yahoo.com wrote: There are serious questions about the setup of the temperature measurements on the various E-Cat tests. There are indeed. We discussed that at length here. Fortunately, as I pointed out several times, we can ignore all of the temperature readings.

Re: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread Stephen A. Lawrence
On 12-01-22 02:18 PM, Jed Rothwell wrote: A message from Mary Yugo caught my attention before falling into the trash. Howzat work? My filters dump the folks I'm filtering before I ever see them. The important point is, my messages do not violate any of the rules set forth by Beaty:

Re: [Vo]:Ni-64 enrichment

2012-01-22 Thread Terry Blanton
On Sun, Jan 22, 2012 at 3:54 PM, Harry Veeder hveeder...@gmail.com wrote: There was never any hard evidence it had been moved. Terry ( I think) remarked on voretx a day or so after the test that a tractor trailer drove off with it as if someone witnessed the departure, but he was really just

Re: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread Jed Rothwell
Stephen A. Lawrence sa...@pobox.com wrote: A message from Mary Yugo caught my attention before falling into the trash. Howzat work? My filters dump the folks I'm filtering before I ever see them. I don't know. I was typing and it appeared, and then vanished. Probably this is how Gmail

[Vo]:If you like Ecats you'll LOVE this

2012-01-22 Thread Eff Wivakeef
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-89SiqG3pI0 

Re: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

2012-01-22 Thread John Milstone
Just because you keep repeating that doesn't make it so. If the water was at 5 to 10 bars, it could easily be heated to 150 - 180 C. in the preheating process. At that point, being wrapped up in that massive insulation blanket, it would stay over 100 C for hours.  It could even be boiling the

Re: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

2012-01-22 Thread Eff Wivakeef
Blindingly obvious but the Rossi cultists will never believe it. They have FAITH. There's your problem. Oh dear, your Messiah has been a VERY naughty boy. CLAIMED TO HAVE THE FORMULA TO TURN WASTE INTO BLACK GOLD, ONLY MANAGED TO CAUSE AN ENVIRONMENTAL DISASTER Sentenced to eight years'

Re: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread Dusty Bradshaw
Some of us doubters would rather unsubscribe but since this is like Hotel California, welp.. Also, didn't know this was a religion here, worshipping at the altar of fringe science? Is this a cult or science, and where can I get off this train? Heavens Gate much?? Have a nice day.

Re: [Vo]:Another lie from Rossi: 1MW plant was at bologna in the first day of november

2012-01-22 Thread Jed Rothwell
Robert Leguillon robert.leguil...@hotmail.com wrote: We don't know what person communications transpired between them, but I think his impression of BBB customer delivery consisted of more than a single affirmative on Rossi's blog. He was getting some info from the horse's mouth. His reaction

RE: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread Peter B
Tom Im all for cutting and running (somedays) but this mentality is like terrorism , if we were to run away they win and they would probably follow . ..A bit of an extreeme story but ..A lady got her legs blown off in those train bombing in London in 2004 . Two years latter there she

Re: [Vo]:Another lie from Rossi: 1MW plant was at bologna in the first day of november

2012-01-22 Thread Eff Wivakeef
Awww! Poor Aussie Guy (cough splutter choke gasp) From: Jed Rothwell jedrothw...@gmail.com To: vortex-l@eskimo.com Sent: Sunday, 22 January 2012 9:50 PM Subject: Re: [Vo]:Another lie from Rossi: 1MW plant was at bologna in the first day of november

Re: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread Yamali Yamali
David Robertson wrote: It is apparent to me that he has a very difficult problem trying to maintain stability of the power output and I have been doing some interesting simulation that tends to support this claim. Would you share that simulation? I can't help feeling that stability is an

[Vo]:This might work

2012-01-22 Thread Eff Wivakeef
Ted Patrick, one of the pioneers of deprogramming, used a confrontational method: When you deprogram people, you force them to think...But I keep them off balance and this forces them to begin questioning, to open their minds. When the mind gets to a certain point, they can see through all the

Re: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread Mary Yugo
On Sun, Jan 22, 2012 at 12:15 PM, Jed Rothwell jedrothw...@gmail.comwrote: I see you are using several other time-tested techniques. You have carefully described a test that would be difficult or impossible to meet. Joule heating or electrolysis power is necessary for most experiments. In

Re: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

2012-01-22 Thread Jed Rothwell
John Milstone john_sw_orla...@yahoo.com wrote: If the water was at 5 to 10 bars, it could easily be heated to 150 - 180 C. in the preheating process. At that point, being wrapped up in that massive insulation blanket, it would stay over 100 C for hours. There was a TC in the reactor. It

Re: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread Jed Rothwell
Robert Lynn robert.gulliver.l...@gmail.com wrote: I am pretty sure Rossi's stability and control problem stems from relying on heat transfer through a large temperature differential (low Watts per degree) to cool a reaction that has a positive temperature coefficient (ie gets more powerful

[Vo]:Stable Fusion??

2012-01-22 Thread Dusty Bradshaw
I have been having some success heating my house with a device that consists of unpressurized proteins, sugars, starches, and waters that undergo heating via an electric resistance. Here are the salient facts: Flour Eggs Water Sucrose Vaniila I mix these together in a reactor vessel

RE: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread Craig Brown
This is not what we are discussing. We are talking about the forum and how it was overtaken by abusive posters. Steorn's claim is not relevant to this discussion. Quoting Wikipedia is of no value when it comes to exotic energy claims simply because of their establishment bias and the bias of the

Re: [Vo]:Ni-64 enrichment

2012-01-22 Thread Harry Veeder
ahh thanks for that reminder! So in a sense I added to the lie. Sorry folks. Harry (Damn that talking dog!) harry On Sun, Jan 22, 2012 at 4:28 PM, Terry Blanton hohlr...@gmail.com wrote: On Sun, Jan 22, 2012 at 3:54 PM, Harry Veeder hveeder...@gmail.com wrote: There was never any hard

Re: [Vo]:Stable Fusion??

2012-01-22 Thread James Bowery
In the immortal words of Hunter S. Thompson: WHO SENT YOU? On Sun, Jan 22, 2012 at 4:23 PM, Dusty Bradshaw d_bra...@bellsouth.netwrote: I have been having some success heating my house with a device that consists of unpressurized proteins, sugars, starches, and waters that undergo heating

Re: [Vo]:The 1MW container is not from old footage.

2012-01-22 Thread Shaun Taylor
On 23/01/2012 1:38 AM, John Milstone wrote: So... Rossi had the old container in his warehouse on 10/28, for the dog pony show. Meanwhile, he had a second box hidden somewhere else (or he build a second one between 10/28 and 10/30, when he claimed it was gone). The secret customer tested the

Re: [Vo]:Stable Fusion??

2012-01-22 Thread Terry Blanton
On Sun, Jan 22, 2012 at 5:23 PM, Dusty Bradshaw d_bra...@bellsouth.net wrote: I'm considering the manufacture of these as the by product alone may feed an army. Any thoughts?? As Jean-Jacques Rousseau said: Qu'ils mangent de la brioche! :-) T

Re: [Vo]:The 1MW container is not from old footage.

2012-01-22 Thread Shaun Taylor
On 23/01/2012 1:47 AM, John Milstone wrote: Not to mention that on 10/30 Rossi answered Yes to the question Have you started building another 1MW in another container? He said nothing about having finished a second box, nor of having shipped it. It's clear from his answers that the first box is

Re: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread David Roberson
I believe that the danger in operating the device in maximum feedback is that the nickel will melt and that will end the power generation permanently. It most likely will require an operation temperature that is controlled and set to the proper level for the desired heat output power. Dave

Re: [Vo]:The 1MW container is not from old footage.

2012-01-22 Thread Shaun Taylor
On 23/01/2012 1:52 AM, John Milstone wrote: If you're being sarcastic, I congratulate you on your subtlety. If you're being serious, I would ask you to provide any evidence at all to support your statement. It directly contradicts everything that Rossi has said. On October 30 (just two days

Re: [Vo]: Stabilization of the reactor (was: Opponents should please go away and form your own group)

2012-01-22 Thread Alain Sepeda
yes, good explanation. however if the reaction curve ( P//T) is more than linear, you should avoid getting higher than a given temp, otherwise the reaction positive feedback will overcome the cooling negative feedback and start a runaway. this is what happens probably as you says with old

Re: [Vo]:The 1MW container is not from old footage.

2012-01-22 Thread Shaun Taylor
On 23/01/2012 2:06 AM, Daniel Rocha wrote: Rossi installed the other box at the customer's site, he even supervise it. Probably he also tested the other box there. Daniel there is no 2nd BBB. It is just another lie in a long line of Rossi lies. Shaun

Re: [Vo]:The 1MW container is not from old footage.

2012-01-22 Thread Shaun Taylor
On 23/01/2012 3:38 AM, Mary Yugo wrote: On Sun, Jan 22, 2012 at 6:14 AM, John Milstone john_sw_orla...@yahoo.com mailto:john_sw_orla...@yahoo.com wrote: As for Focardi and Levi, I notice that they never corrected any of the various lies about the University of Bologna actually

Re: [Vo]: Stabilization of the reactor (was: Opponents should please go away and form your own group)

2012-01-22 Thread Alain Sepeda
by the way, this discussion raise a possibility, and doubt of doubt... the design of defkalion, and problems of rossi seems rational and linked to real problems, that if not straight, are to be expected. this give credibility to the fact that : - defkalion have worked on a real case, fighting

RE: [Vo]:The 1MW container is not from old footage.

2012-01-22 Thread Mark Iverson-ZeroPoint
Shaun states as fact: He [Rossi] has been caught working with licensees to take green family investor money despite saying he would never do this. I think I have read all the postings so far, and Shaun was specifically asked, I think twice, by others if there was any evidence that *Rossi* himself

Re: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread David Roberson
You have shown an excellent example of the problem and Defkalion's solution. The model that I am working on suggests that it is the slope of the Power Output versus Temperature curve of the core device multiplied by the thermal resistance that defines stability. I have modeled many different

Re: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread Shaun Taylor
On 23/01/2012 4:46 AM, Jed Rothwell wrote: These people include Mary Yugo, Axil Axil, John Milstone, Eff Wivakeef and others. You know who you are. If you will not stop this childish nonsense, I ask you to shut up and go away. I ask Bill Beaty to ban you. I have been adding you to my personal

Re: [Vo]:Another lie from Rossi: 1MW plant was at bologna in the first day of november

2012-01-22 Thread Shaun Taylor
On 23/01/2012 5:01 AM, Mattia Rizzi wrote: Here is the video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tqhXotcu5hsfeature=player_embedded http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tqhXotcu5hsfeature=player_embedded You can see the 1MW plant. I've contacted the author: the video footage was taken in the first day of

Re: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

2012-01-22 Thread Eff Wivakeef
You are not very bright are you Jed. From: Jed Rothwell jedrothw...@gmail.com To: John Milstone vortex-l@eskimo.com Sent: Sunday, 22 January 2012 10:09 PM Subject: Re: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog John Milstone

Re: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

2012-01-22 Thread Wolf Fischer
This is were you clearly crossed the line. Get some air and do something else besides insulting people and repeating yourself! Wolf You are not very bright are you Jed. *From:* Jed Rothwell jedrothw...@gmail.com *To:*

Re: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

2012-01-22 Thread Andre Blum
+1 On 01/22/2012 07:45 PM, Wolf Fischer wrote: This is were you clearly crossed the line. Get some air and do something else besides insulting people and repeating yourself! Wolf You are not very bright are you Jed.

Re: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

2012-01-22 Thread John Milstone
Who supplied and positioned the thermocouple.  If it was Rossi (as Mats Lewan claims was true for every test), then I don't believe it.  Rossi has way too much to gain, and way too much history of lying and cheating for me to place any faith in anything he supplied to test his gadget.   You

Re: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

2012-01-22 Thread Иванов Михаил
test passed

Re: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

2012-01-22 Thread David Roberson
I think that the device would explode long before it reached 10 bars. Dave -Original Message- From: Jed Rothwell jedrothw...@gmail.com To: John Milstone vortex-l@eskimo.com Sent: Sun, Jan 22, 2012 5:09 pm Subject: Re: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

Re: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

2012-01-22 Thread Eff Wivakeef
Oh I am sorry. I forgot that Rossi is such an honest man that he would of course have put the temperature probe inside the pressure cooker  Duh! From: Andre Blum andre_vor...@blums.nl To: vortex-l@eskimo.com Sent: Sunday, 22 January 2012 11:48 PM Subject: Re:

Re: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

2012-01-22 Thread Shaun Taylor
On 23/01/2012 6:08 AM, Stephen A. Lawrence wrote: On 12-01-22 04:24 AM, Shaun Taylor wrote: The goop is where the bead of the thermocouple was placed. There is no other reason for anything like that material to be there other than to provide a good heat exchange between the brass fitting and

RE: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

2012-01-22 Thread Mark Iverson-ZeroPoint
Agreed, wholeheartedly.. There was a thermocouple in the E-Cat and the highest I remember it ever getting was ~108degC. Anyone who claims that it was anywhere near 150 needs to provide the proof. I don't think even Yugo would try to float that asinine suggestion. or would you Mary?

Re: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

2012-01-22 Thread Eff Wivakeef
Did they stick the probe up the Ecat's bum? From: Mark Iverson-ZeroPoint zeropo...@charter.net To: vortex-l@eskimo.com Sent: Sunday, 22 January 2012 11:56 PM Subject: RE: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog Agreed,

Re: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

2012-01-22 Thread John Milstone
That may be.  I reviewed the picture with the cover off, and the cover doesn't appear as substantial as I remembered.  But there sure are a lot of bolts to hold it down.  Far more than would be needed if it were only pressurized to slightly more than normal (as Rossi claims. And, I suspect any

Re: [Vo]:Another lie from Rossi: 1MW plant was at bologna in the first day of november

2012-01-22 Thread Shaun Taylor
On 23/01/2012 6:28 AM, Jed Rothwell wrote: It is either minor confusion or a minor lie. Minor Lie? WTF? Rossi lied to the world about shipping the words first operational 500 kW LENR reactor to a secret customer and later lied about going there to do the install. Jed what does it take to

Re: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread Shaun Taylor
On 23/01/2012 6:31 AM, Mary Yugo wrote: On Sun, Jan 22, 2012 at 11:55 AM, David Roberson dlrober...@aol.com mailto:dlrober...@aol.com wrote: Mary, there are serious problems with Rossi's demonstrations that we are all aware of. It is apparent to me that he has a very difficult

Re: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

2012-01-22 Thread Wolf Fischer
You (and people like you) really dont get it. This mailing list is about people discussing topics of different kinds, among them, e.g., LENR as well as Rossi. As long as there is doubt (on either side of the coin, i.e., either pro or contra) there have to be discussions, i.e., people allow

Re: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

2012-01-22 Thread Shaun Taylor
On 23/01/2012 6:38 AM, John Milstone wrote: At the risk of confusing the issue, is it possible that Rossi is trying to *reduce* the apparent temperature of the system? After seeing the video of the September test, and reading Eff Wiavkeef's comments here:

RE: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread Craig Brown
I think you are misreading the situation. The problem here is the accusatory and pathalogical scepticism displayed by posters such as yourself which is based on attacking the character of anyone and everyone who is keeping an open mind regarding Rossi's claims. Original Message

RE: [Vo]:The 1MW container is not from old footage.

2012-01-22 Thread Mark Iverson-ZeroPoint
So here was Shaun's acknowledging the FACT that he doesn't know, or have evidence that Rossi is even aware of the Australian licensee (Millin): === *While I have no proof*, I would expect a few of those going to the meeting would have emailed Rossi to check on the validity of

RE: [Vo]:Another lie from Rossi: 1MW plant was at bologna in the first day of november

2012-01-22 Thread Craig Brown
Hehe...you really are a bit of a drama queen Shaun. Put down the aspartame drink slowly and step away from the keyboard.. Original Message Subject: Re: [Vo]:Another lie from Rossi: 1MW plant was at bologna in the first day of november From: Shaun Taylor shauntaylor...@gmail.com

Re: [Vo]:The 1MW container is not from old footage.

2012-01-22 Thread Wolf Fischer
Yup. The way they argue I think Shaun Taylor and Eff Wivakeef are actually the same persons... I think I might also start creating a kill list like Jed although perhaps there is a time when one of both might actually have something worthwhile to contribute to a discussion (although this seems

[Vo]:I'm added Eff in my SPAM filter

2012-01-22 Thread OrionWorks - Steven Vincent Johnson
Shish! I leave for a weekend, and when I return and check my email I find myself barraged with a pissing contest. Eff, you install yourself in the Vort Collective and attempt to hijack it with a personal agenda consumed by revenge that you have been carefully nursing along for years. You don't

RE: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

2012-01-22 Thread Robert Leguillon
During the September test (with the large steam release in question) the temperature exceeded 133C... You can see it in the video. During the October 6th test, the temperature reaches 123.8C at the onset of self-sustaining mode, and it drops to 103C by the end of the test.

RE: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread Dusty
A lot more transparancy would negate the need for 'open' minds. Sadly, Rossi = Fail. Any University would be happy to test his device under an NDA and blackbox.. How you gonna change the world without coming out into the light? He could have protected his IP and changed the world, but alas

Re: [Vo]:Another lie from Rossi: 1MW plant was at bologna in the first day of november

2012-01-22 Thread Shaun Taylor
On 23/01/2012 6:46 AM, Robert Leguillon wrote: /snip/ It is either minor confusion or a minor lie. Minor compared to the usual level of chaos that Rossi sows when he opens his mouth. This incident sent AussiGuy into a tizzy. I told him I do not understand why, because anyone who has dealt with

Re: [Vo]:Chan Method Update

2012-01-22 Thread ecat builder
Chan, a mystery Ni-H replicator claims to be working on plans for a 10MW Metal Hydride Nickel Fusion unit. He claims to have patents and will update people on the following web site: http://chanfusionpower.chan.host-ed.me/ It says the following currently: Chan Fusion Power 10 MW Fusion Power

RE: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread Craig Brown
I'm all for transparency and god knows Rossi needs to sort out his translations for the avoidance of doubt. But transparency works BOTH ways. You can't have transparency on ONE side only! Pathological sceptics are rarely transparent and usually have their own agenda. So sitting there demanding

RE: [Vo]:The 1MW container is not from old footage.

2012-01-22 Thread Craig Brown
I would not be surprised if Eff Wivakeef and Shaun Taylor are fake pseudonyms and that they are posters from the moletrap forum. MaryYugo regularly tells everyone over on Moletrap how stupid and gullible "she" thinks everyone on Vortex is, then she comes over here to have a go.The fact Yugo and

Re: [Vo]:The 1MW container is not from old footage.

2012-01-22 Thread Shaun Taylor
On 23/01/2012 9:55 AM, Mark Iverson-ZeroPoint wrote: Shaun states as fact: He [Rossi] has been caught working with licensees to take green family investor money despite saying he would never do this. I think I have read all the postings so far, and Shaun was specifically asked, I think twice,

Re: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread Shaun Taylor
On 23/01/2012 10:46 AM, Craig Brown wrote: I think you are misreading the situation. The problem here is the accusatory and pathalogical scepticism displayed by posters such as yourself which is based on attacking the character of anyone and everyone who is keeping an open mind regarding Rossi's

[Vo]:OT: BBB, BRB, BGB, BYB...

2012-01-22 Thread Harry Veeder
Rossi's BBB will fit right in... http://youtu.be/FHyqj_OdjNo Harry

Re: [Vo]:The 1MW container is not from old footage.

2012-01-22 Thread Shaun Taylor
On 23/01/2012 10:47 AM, Mark Iverson-ZeroPoint wrote: So here was Shaun's acknowledging the FACT that he doesn't know, or have evidence that Rossi is even aware of the Australian licensee (Millin): Mark, since then I saw the slide show and other data about that event on Millin's site. He

RE: [Vo]:Chan Method Update

2012-01-22 Thread Peter B
Thanks Brad I appreciate the update Pete Date: Sun, 22 Jan 2012 16:37:47 -0800 Subject: Re: [Vo]:Chan Method Update From: ecatbuil...@gmail.com To: vortex-l@eskimo.com Chan, a mystery Ni-H replicator claims to be working on plans for a 10MW Metal Hydride Nickel Fusion unit. He claims to

RE: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

2012-01-22 Thread Mark Iverson-ZeroPoint
Thx Robert, I stand corrected. From: Robert Leguillon [mailto:robert.leguil...@hotmail.com] Sent: Sunday, January 22, 2012 4:25 PM To: vortex-l@eskimo.com Subject: RE: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog During the September test (with the large steam release

RE: [Vo]:The 1MW container is not from old footage.

2012-01-22 Thread Mark Iverson-ZeroPoint
Shaun, Picking data apart is one thing, but when you choose to state, AS A FACT, that Rossi is knowingly working with Millin, you damn well better have direct evidence (e.g., a contract with Rossi's sig, or video of Rossi interacting with Millin). It is perfectly clear that that is NOT the case

Re: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread Mary Yugo
On Sun, Jan 22, 2012 at 2:29 PM, Craig Brown cr...@overunity.co wrote: This is not what we are discussing. We are talking about the forum and how it was overtaken by abusive posters. Steorn's claim is not relevant to this discussion. Quoting Wikipedia is of no value when it comes to exotic

[Vo]:Commercial heat pump with COP of 8

2012-01-22 Thread Shaun Taylor
Who needs Rossi and his fake Ecat when a commercially available Hitachi heat pump, the Eco Cute, achieved a COP of up to 8 way back in 2008. http://www.mayekawausa.com/brochures/pdf/wEcoCute_brochure.pdf Shaun

Re: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread Mary Yugo
On Sun, Jan 22, 2012 at 4:16 PM, Craig Brown cr...@overunity.co wrote: I think you are misreading the situation. The problem here is the accusatory and pathalogical scepticism displayed by posters such as yourself which is based on attacking the character of anyone and everyone who is

[Vo]:A hypothesis about the Rossi reactor and Rossi

2012-01-22 Thread Abd ul-Rahman Lomax
As many Vorticians know, I've followed the Rossi affair since early 2011. I found, fairly quickly, reasons to think that the demonstrations were not conclusive, that they may have shown anything from no excess heat, mild excess heat, to strong excess heat. From certain evidence (asserted most

Re: [Vo]:Commercial heat pump with COP of 8

2012-01-22 Thread Chemical Engineer
Shaun, I use a heat pump with COP of 6 in Georgia to heat my pool. It still needs a heat source such as relatively warm air or geothermal as a primary heat source. On Sun, Jan 22, 2012 at 8:51 PM, Shaun Taylor shauntaylor...@gmail.comwrote: Who needs Rossi and his fake Ecat when a

Re: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

2012-01-22 Thread Jed Rothwell
John Milstone john_sw_orla...@yahoo.com wrote: You have repeatedly used Lewan's statement that it *was* very hot to justify your claims of nuclear reactions. Please note: I said the surface temperature did not *vary much*. That means the internal temperature could not have been ~180 deg C

Re: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread Abd ul-Rahman Lomax
At 02:46 PM 1/22/2012, Eff Wivakeef wrote: Look at all the attention and acclaim given to Rossi and for what? To keep the scam going and ripoff more victims. Simple really. Why would anyone choose to believe the word of Rossi the convicted fraudster? Weird or what? I don't believe Rossi, but

Re: [Vo]:Right Sizing Nickel Particles

2012-01-22 Thread fznidarsic
That is another good question. Why do we need protons in a proton conductor? The proton spacing is still measured in atomic distances not nuclear distances. The answer is The Dissolved Protons are not bound. The frequency is not determined by K sq root of K/M where K is measured to the next

Re: [Vo]:The 1MW container is not from old footage.

2012-01-22 Thread Mary Yugo
On Sun, Jan 22, 2012 at 4:35 PM, Craig Brown cr...@overunity.co wrote: I would not be surprised if Eff Wivakeef and Shaun Taylor are fake pseudonyms and that they are posters from the moletrap forum. MaryYugo regularly tells everyone over on Moletrap how stupid and gullible she thinks

Re: [Vo]:The 1MW container is not from old footage.

2012-01-22 Thread Shaun Taylor
On 23/01/2012 11:58 AM, Mark Iverson-ZeroPoint wrote: Shaun, Picking data apart is one thing, but when you choose to state, AS A FACT, that Rossi is knowingly working with Millin, you damn well better have direct evidence (e.g., a contract with Rossi's sig, or video of Rossi interacting with

Re: [Vo]:The 1MW container is not from old footage.

2012-01-22 Thread Mary Yugo
On Sun, Jan 22, 2012 at 5:28 PM, Mark Iverson-ZeroPoint zeropo...@charter.net wrote: Shaun, Picking data apart is one thing, but when you choose to state, AS A FACT, that Rossi is knowingly working with Millin, you damn well better have direct evidence (e.g., a contract with Rossi's sig, or

Re: [Vo]:A hypothesis about the Rossi reactor and Rossi

2012-01-22 Thread Mary Yugo
On Sun, Jan 22, 2012 at 5:55 PM, Abd ul-Rahman Lomax a...@lomaxdesign.comwrote: A LENR device that produces power for a few hours or a few days isn't practical. It might indeed be of interest, and someone, someday, might figure out how to make something like this reliable, but Rossi might

Re: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread Jed Rothwell
Shaun Taylor shauntaylor...@gmail.com wrote: Of course we welcome your contributions to the technical discussion here. - Jed Oh so now Vortex is only a PRO Rossi discussion group? No, it is pro-science. Please re-read what I said: we welcome your contributions to the technical discussion

Re: [Vo]:A hypothesis about the Rossi reactor and Rossi

2012-01-22 Thread Rich Murray
Yes, that fits in with the relaxed innocence with which he waved the black hose against Focardi's black sweater to reveal the wisps of visible water mist -- since then he's been more and more panicked, like the warlord in Kurosawa's version of Macbeth, being pinned against the castle wall by

Re: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread Mary Yugo
On Sun, Jan 22, 2012 at 6:02 PM, Abd ul-Rahman Lomax a...@lomaxdesign.comwrote: I don't believe Rossi, but I do believe that Eff Vivakeef is acting beyond the pale for Vortex. Convicted fraudster is libel. I don't think that's libel. It may not be the whole story but you can find in

Re: [Vo]:Opponents should please go away and form your own group

2012-01-22 Thread Mary Yugo
On Sun, Jan 22, 2012 at 6:17 PM, Jed Rothwell jedrothw...@gmail.com wrote: Shaun Taylor shauntaylor...@gmail.com wrote: Of course we welcome your contributions to the technical discussion here. - Jed Oh so now Vortex is only a PRO Rossi discussion group? No, it is pro-science. Your

Re: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog

2012-01-22 Thread Shaun Taylor
On 23/01/2012 12:27 PM, Jed Rothwell wrote: As I noted, the temperature was measured by Lewan. Who is now known to have covered up multiple Rossi lies and to have accepted the BS Tout bead placement in the 6 Oct test. So please explain why Lewans has credibility in your eyes? Are you

<    1   2   3   >