Besides what I have said about using "argument from authority" as a way to win a debate, can you please give us a link to your CV a.ashfield? Can you back up your claims to have such expertise? Thanks, Giovanni
On Sun, Aug 14, 2016 at 4:10 PM, Giovanni Santostasi <gsantost...@gmail.com> wrote: > A.ashfield: > > "Ad hominem" attacks. To quote a famous immortal scene from the "Princess > Bride": "You keep using that word. I don't think it means what you think it > means". > > I didn't attack anybody at hominem. I didn't put down Penon not to have a > PhD. > I simply stated that Rossi saying he has a Doctorate is not true and that > is at least sloppy and probably misleading. > > It doesn't reflect negatively on me at all. > > So let me reflect this back at you given you don't understand what ad > hominem attack is and instead you are using your supposed experience to > make an argument (and trying to disqualify my arguments too as a > consequence) and therefore committing another known fallacy , i. e. > "argument from authority". > > Giovanni > > > > > > On Sun, Aug 14, 2016 at 3:52 PM, a.ashfield <a.ashfi...@verizon.net> > wrote: > >> Giovanni, >> Your string of ad hominem attacks do nothing to clarify the issues and >> reflect badly on you. >> >> I find Dr. Levi's 18 hour test of an E-Cat in 2011, without steam, >> finding a COP 15 -20kW peaking at 130 kW is good proof that the E-Cat >> produces considerable excess heat. As I've said, the performance of the 1 >> MW plant has yet to be proven. >> >> Having headed engineering for large corporations and later consulting >> around the world, doing due diligence for organizations like GRI, EPRI, >> OECD and the World Bank, I have considerable experience in judging people >> and new technologies. >> What experience do you have? >> >> >
