What is the reason for this action of removing the year and refunding it back to the losing registrar? If the year is removed is the losing registrar obligated to refund the amount back?
This doesn't make any sense to me. You pay for a year so you can perform the transfer then get that year taken away from you? Scott Ken Joy wrote: >To be clear: > >We DO add the year (we have to; it's a function of Registry/Registrar >protocol, not a business decision). It's jus that the year that was paid for >at the losing registrar get's refunded to them, and the year get's taken >back from the domain. > >Ken > >>-----Original Message----- >>From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] >>[mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]On Behalf Of Saurabh Agarwal >>Sent: Wednesday, January 16, 2002 1:40 PM >>To: Subscriber; [EMAIL PROTECTED] >>Subject: RE: Domain transfer renewal date dispute >> >> >>Hello >> >>I also have had same type of issue ... while moving a domain from >>dotregistrar to Opensrs. >> >>Opensrs says if an expired domain is just renewed and transferred >>within 45 >>days of renewal they will not add the year ... they further says that >>loosing registrar gets the DRY refunded ... >> >>While loosing registrar says "why we should return the DRY "... >> >>I tired with ICANN too but no response till date ... >> >>Thanks and Best Regards >> >>Saurabh Agarwal >>www.indiaresult.com >>Monsoon Software Consulting P. Ltd. >>51/11 Opp. Technology Park >>Shipra Path, Mansarovar >>Jaipur 302 020 (RAJ) India >>T +91-141-783113, 783114 >> >> >> >>-----Original Message----- >>From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] >>[mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]On Behalf Of Subscriber >>Sent: Wednesday, January 16, 2002 11:00 PM >>To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] >>Subject: Domain transfer renewal date dispute >> >> >>I have a problem between two registrars. I asked for a domain to be >>transferred from Netsol to Tucows in early December. Because the >>domain had one of the old [EMAIL PROTECTED] addresses, it >>expired on 12 Dec before I could confirm the transfer. Then Netsol refused >>to transfer unless I paid them for a further year. I paid on Dec >>31 for the >>period 12 Dec 2001 to 12 Dec 2002, and they transferred on Jan 3 2002. But >>Tucows only renewed it to Dec 2002. >> >>When I queried them, I get two assertions: >> >>1) Netsol : It could not have been transferred unless you renewed it. We >>did renew the date, and can email you an invoice showing a renewal date of >>2002. >> >>2) Opensrs (aka Tucows, via register4less): We always add on time to the >>existing date. If the current renewal date is now Dec 2002, we must have >>received the domain dated Dec 2001. >> >>So I have two stories, each making an assertion on what "must have" >>happened. Is there any electronic record of this transaction that will >>provide documentary proof of what the renewal date of the domain >>was at the >>time of transfer? How would I get that? >> >> >>Thanks, >> >>Patrick O'Beirne >> >> Patrick O'Beirne, Director. >> Systems Modelling Ltd., Ireland. >> http://www.sysmod.com/ >> >> >> >
