On 7/6/2012 7:26 PM, David Nyman wrote:
On 6 July 2012 22:55, Stephen P. King <stephe...@charter.net <mailto:stephe...@charter.net>> wrote:

    We have to be very careful about this "assumed from the onset"
    stuff! Yes, it is necessary to assume things even for the sake of
    discussion of ideas, but to assume that they are de facto
    primitive and/or a priori is often a fatal mistake.

Let me assure you, Stephen, that I make no assumptions or assertions as to primitivity or a priori truth for these notions.

 Hi David,

I did not mean to claim that you where making assumptions or assertions. I was speaking in generalities, thus the use of the word "we".

As I have said, I find them useful and illuminating (as presumably did Hoyle) in connection with certain conceptual problems of consciousness, particularly those relating to personal identity and history.

I agree. Hoyle was on to an important idea, IMHO. I really appreciate that you have pointed this out.

It is also the case that, in discussing these particular ideas with others, I've found that their particular explicitness with respect to factors that are often tacit or even entirely unrecognised has often been helpful in drawing out veiled aspects of competing viewpoints.

Yes. I recall vividly how much David Bohm discussed tacit assumptions in his writings. It is more often the case than not that it is what we jsut assume to be true without question that is the problem that prevents progress in our thinking.

I tend to agree that a comparison can be drawn with Leibnizian PEH, which I suppose is rather unavoidable given the way the notion is formulated. With respect to the substrate or "real system" with which Hoyle's pigeon holes are assumed to be associated "/h//ypotheses non fingo"; /the heuristic is more or less neutral on this issue, which can be construed both as a weakness or a strength, depending on one's purposes.

Would it be too bold to claim that we now have enough evidence to propose a hypothesis?



"Nature, to be commanded, must be obeyed."
~ Francis Bacon

You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"Everything List" group.
To post to this group, send email to everything-list@googlegroups.com.
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
For more options, visit this group at 

Reply via email to