Typically I have always thought that Deus Ex Machina was mainly used as
a cheat when the writers wrote themselves into a corner.  From the way
it has been discussed so far it seems like people think the Thrones were
a Deux Ex Machina written in to get the Meisters out of the trap.  In
this situation it could be that the trapping of the Ptolemais Meisters
was the Deus Ex Machina to give the writers an easy cheat to give the
Throne Meisters a dramatic entrance.

 

 

________________________________

From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of
Joseph Riggs
Sent: Thursday, February 07, 2008 2:56 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [RE][gundam] Gundam 00 Episode 17 *spoilers*

 

We're not asking for full explanations.  We're not even asking for
minimal explanations.  We're asking for proper foreshadowing and setting
up.  If you don't do that, then yes, it looks very much as if you're
making it up as you go along.  And that's one of the reasons why people
have concerns about the series.

 

Maybe there will be events in season one that make sense in the context
of being seen in season two.  But so far there haven't been any earlier
events that make sense after viewing episode 17.  Or episide 16, 15,
etc...  And that's quite a while.  But there's been not one thing that I
can think of to date where an action or event in the show helped explain
something that took place earlier.

Instead, we get Deus Ex Machina events, in which things that haven't so
much as even been hinted at suddenly come out of nowhere and save the
day when things look grim for the Gundam Meisters.  The first appearence
of the Thrones was one.  Gundam Nadeelah (sp?) was another.

 

Would it have really been that hard for the writers to drop a vague hint
that Gundam Virtue was more than it appeared?

 

 

A good example from an earlier successful series is Rau la Cruze (I
probably mangled his name) in Gundam SEED.  You get hints early on that
he's up to no good, and that's seemingly born out when he's revealed as
leaking information to Blue Cosmos.  But it's not until the end of the
series that you realize just how far gone he is.

 

 

junior




        ---------[ Received Mail Content ]----------
        Subject : Re: [RE][gundam] Gundam 00 Episode 17 *spoilers*
        Date : Thu, 07 Feb 2008 15:00:18 -0500
        From : Adrian Leo <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
        To : [email protected]
        
        ">From : "Deacon Blues" 
        To : [email protected] 
        
        I don't understand where people think he's pulling this all out
of his 
        ass. I think people seem to forget that season one is a segway
into 
        season two, so not much is SUPPOSE to be explained in this
season. 
        Personally I have no problem with it whatsoever. I guess most
people who 
        are hardened UC seem to be disappointed with this. I guess the
UC 
        elitists just won't die." 

 

Reply via email to