"Will anyone acting like a lawyer please stand up, so the rest of us can stop
saying we're not one?"

kevin kenan wrote:

> If a spell, monster, name, etc does not appear in a section designated as
> OGC, then it is closed.

*OR* if it apperas in the section marked PI, and the works says "all parts not
marked PI are open."

> If a spell, monster, name, etc. appears in a section designated as OGC, but
> also appears in the list of PI, then it is closed.

Wrong.  OGC cannot be PI--it's a violation of the OGL.

> If an item appears in the list of PI and appears in a section designated as
> OGC, but doesn't meet the criteria of PI given in the OGL, then you have a
> breach of the license.

If it appears in PI and doesn't meet the list, it's a violation.

DM, who must be going.

-------------
For more information, please link to www.opengamingfoundation.org

Reply via email to