Jeff, list,

JBD: What is clear is that patterns of thought unuttered today may, at some
point in the future, be uttered. As such, the analysis of those unuttered
thoughts should account for the future possible forms in which they might be
expressed verbally, in writing or in some other form of action.

GF: I would say that a thought-sign which may be uttered at some point in
the future is, by definition, a type. What I have in mind is a thought-sign
which is not only subvocal but sublinguistic, perhaps subconscious as well,
but is presently existing as brain activity that is actually happening right
now, and thus is by definition a token. The general type of which it is an
individual token (an embodiment) is presumably a habit of that bodymind
which may also inhabit other bodyminds, especially when they are "prompted"
by spoken or written tokens. But those uttered tokens are individuals, and
so is the brain activity I'm referring to. When "two minds share a single
thought," even when they share a language and other cultural dispositions,
they do not share the same brain activity. One thought, two brains, two
tokens. They may be synchronized in the case of a "live" conversation, but
they are still ontologically separate.

To me, the idea of an internal utterance is oxymoronic. The verb "utter" is
obviously based on the root word "out," and the OED's first definition is
"To issue or send forth; to publish." You utter a thought by uttering a
spoken or written token of it, by issuing some token that is perceivable by
others. That's how I see it, anyway. 

Gary f.

 

 

}  {

 <https://gnusystems.ca/wp/> https://gnusystems.ca/wp/ }{ living the time

 

From: Jeffrey Brian Downard <[email protected]> 
Sent: 6-Nov-21 15:20
To: 'Peirce-L' <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Subject: Re: [PEIRCE-L] Signs, Types, and Tokens

 

Gary F, Jon AS, Gary R, Phyllis, et al.

 

Sometimes, such as when I'm done thinking about a philosophical question, I
look at the time and wonder where it went. I didn't write anything down, and
I didn't talk to anyone about it. Gary F's question takes the following
form:  are my unuttered thoughts during this period internal sign tokens?

 

Consider a set of similar cases:

 

A.  I'm lost in thought, but occasionally muttering to myself. There is no
one around to hear it, and I'm not even noticing that I'm quietly muttering.

 

B. I'm lost in thought and sketching a diagram. The diagram is something of
a mess, and my thoughts are rather confused. I consider several changes that
I might make, perhaps adding lines here, erasing some there, but I don't
make the all of the changes considered. After an hour of doodling, I take
the sheet of paper and throw it away. I don't come back to it later, nor
does anyone else read it.

 

Whatever answer we give to your question about internal signs, I think the
explanations should flow naturally to cover cases A and B. Similarly, the
explanations should fit variations on A and B where someone else comes along
and says, "you're muttering" what are you saying and I say "oh it's nothing"
or, conversely, I reflect and offer an explanation of my thoughts. So, too,
for the case of the diagram on the piece of paper when someone pulls it out
of the trash and asks what I was thinking about when making the figure, and
I give similar responses.

 

What is clear is that patterns of thought unuttered today may, at some point
in the future, be uttered. As such, the analysis of those unuttered thoughts
should account for the future possible forms in which they might be
expressed verbally, in writing or in some other form of action.

--Jeff

 

 

Jeffrey Downard
Associate Professor
Department of Philosophy
Northern Arizona University
(o) 928 523-8354 

 

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
► PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON 
PEIRCE-L to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to [email protected] . 
► To UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message NOT to PEIRCE-L but to [email protected] 
with UNSUBSCRIBE PEIRCE-L in the SUBJECT LINE of the message and nothing in the 
body.  More at https://list.iupui.edu/sympa/help/user-signoff.html .
► PEIRCE-L is owned by THE PEIRCE GROUP;  moderated by Gary Richmond;  and 
co-managed by him and Ben Udell.

Reply via email to