"Still Learnin'" <ssski...@gmail.com> wrote in message 
> Tony Marston wrote:
>>> You've been told more than twice, it isn't an arbitrary rule. It isn't
>>> a petty rule. It isn't about perfection.
>> It is arbitrary. It is petty. It is about someone's idea of perfection.
> One of us clearly manifests a reality gap. How many people do you
> have siding with your position, on this list?
>>> It's about clarity. So that the threaded archives are intelligible
>>> instead of jumbled. So that the post-by-post emails properly read from
>>> top to bottom.
>> That's why other newsgroups allow top posting because the response in 
>> each post is at the top, where the newsreader starts, so you don't have 
>> to scroll over the text of the previous post to get to the important 
>> stuff.
> This is not a newsgroup. It is an email list that archives emails
> on the php.net web site, and has a newsgroup subscribed.

It *is* a newsgroup because I can access it through my newsreader. I can 
recieve copies of posts in my email client, but I can only post using my 

>> If a thread contained 30 posts would you really want the text of all 30 
>> contained in the same message? How difficult would it be to separate one 
>> message from another?
> What broken program (or script) puts the text of 30 posts into the
> same post? You seem to be grasping at straws.

When you hit "reply" in your newsreader what happens? It creates a new post 
with the original message quoted in its entirety. Some newsreadrs then 
posiition the cursor at the  top ready for your reply, while others position 
it at the bottom. If this happens 30 times then the last post contains 
copies of the all the previous 29 messages.

>>> It's also about courtesy, not dropping dingleberries dozens or scores
>>> of lines long (and some of you others could stand to snip the extraneous
>>> even though you do properly bottom-post).
>> So what are the rules about snipping then?
> You're the 30-year professional, figure them out. I'm Still Learnin'

Why should I have to figure it out? Surely some little Hitler has created a 
rule so that the rest of us sheep don't have to think for ourselves?

Tony Marston

PHP General Mailing List (http://www.php.net/)
To unsubscribe, visit: http://www.php.net/unsub.php

Reply via email to