Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-23 Thread escape
I was about to post bugreport at VirtualBox bugtracker, but decided to double-check the issue first. On my system floppy images change are correctly recognized. VirtualBox 4.1.4-3.2.3 OSE OpenSUSE 12.1. On 16.05.12 19:33, Wolfgang Schechinger wrote: Dear experts, I have some floppy images I

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-23 Thread Jack
I was about to post bugreport at VirtualBox bugtracker, but decided to double-check the issue first. On my system floppy images change are correctly recognized. VirtualBox 4.1.4-3.2.3 OSE OpenSUSE 12.1. The issue is that VirtualBox is not posting diskette media-change status in the BIOS data

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-23 Thread Eric Auer
Hi Tom, thanks for checking the int 13 details on VirtualBox! I was about to post bugreport at VirtualBox bugtracker, but decided to double-check the issue first. On my system floppy images change are correctly recognized. VirtualBox 4.1.4-3.2.3 OSE OpenSUSE 12.1. The issue is that

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-23 Thread Jack
Tom: The issue is that VirtualBox is not posting diskette media-change status in the BIOS data table. the 'issue' is that VirtualBox clearly states 'floppy without change-line support' int13/15 returns '01h floppy without change-line support int13/16 returns '06h change line active or

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-23 Thread Eric Auer
Jack, the 'issue' is that VirtualBox clearly states 'floppy without change-line support' int13/15 returns '01h floppy without change-line support int13/16 returns '06h change line active or not supported but UIDE ignores this, and relies on change line support anyway. You are WRONG,

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-23 Thread Tom Ehlert
Jack, The issue is that VirtualBox is not posting diskette media-change status in the BIOS data table. the 'issue' is that VirtualBox clearly states 'floppy without change-line support' int13/15 returns '01h floppy without change-line support int13/16 returns '06h change line active or

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-23 Thread BretJ
Jack-181 wrote: I will NOT cache a drive which cannot tell me when its media has changed, and I REFUSE to add all of the logic in UIDE that Eric notes the DOS kernel contains, to find out if a media-change has occurred using other methods! It's not impossible to cache floppies, Jack. You

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-23 Thread Ralf A. Quint
At 09:22 AM 5/23/2012, Jack wrote: You are WRONG, Tom!! Sorry, Jack, but he is not Honestly Jack, please don't explode each time someone is making a critical statement. There simply is no reason to get all personal about this... UIDE has NEVER ignored if a diskette has change-line

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-23 Thread Jack
UIDE has NEVER ignored if a diskette has change-line support! It does in fact check the BIOS data table at 0:448h for bit 0 (change line for diskette A:) or bit 4 (change line for diskette B:). If those bits are off, diskette A: or diskette B: will not be cached. if UIDE would check

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-23 Thread Jack
UIDE has NEVER ignored if a diskette has change-line support! It does in fact check the BIOS data table at 0:48Fh for bit 0 (change line for diskette A:) or bit 4 (change line for diskette B:). If those bits are off, diskette A: or diskette B: will not be cached. That is an interesting

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-23 Thread Jack
It's not impossible to cache floppies, Jack. You just need to do it differently than you're doing now ... Back in 1980, I told an old friend of mine about a 750K video-driver package which I had seen (written in C, of course!), and he noted, They've got GUTS, calling that a DRIVER! If I had

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-23 Thread Jack
Jack, PLEASE, don't pull yourself up on the VirtualBox issue, it is rather a more general problem. You simply rely on the contents of the memory region rather than than properly query system via INT13. And that isn't adding much to the logic and overall size of your drivers compared to the

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-23 Thread Jack
Eric, Apologies, I misread my own source file (early!) this morning. UIDE and UIDE2 check 0:48Fh (not 448h) for the bits that indicate if drive A: or B: suipport a media-change line. Note the BIOS data lists at: http://www.bioscentral.com/misc/bda.htm This document states that bit 0

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-23 Thread Tom Ehlert
Given how UIDE/UIDE2's diskette I-O has never been a problem BUT for VirtualBox, I will keep UIDE/UIDE2 as-is. this is going nowhere. Jack is right and everybody else is a bloody idiot. AMEN Tom -- Live Security

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-23 Thread Ralf A. Quint
At 12:31 PM 5/23/2012, Jack wrote: As I just got through noting, in another post, why would the BIOS data include diskette change-line flags if they were NOT intended to be USED?? Until someone can positively REFUTE the data offered by the BIOS Central data-table list, my opinion is that neither

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-23 Thread Jack
As I just got through noting, in another post, why would the BIOS data include diskette change-line flags if they were NOT intended to be USED?? Until someone can positively REFUTE the data offered by the BIOS Central data-table list, my opinion is that neither you nor any- one else can say

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-23 Thread TJ Edmister
On Wed, 23 May 2012 14:33:00 -0400, Jack gykazequ...@earthlink.net wrote: Back in 1980, I told an old friend of mine about a 750K video-driver package which I had seen (written in C, of course!), and he noted, They've got GUTS, calling that a DRIVER! Wow, that sounds familiar. Was your

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-20 Thread Wolfgang Schechinger
Dear STF, I have tried both. No difference. Wo How did you change the floppy? I mean, did you just choose one image file after another? Or did you *remove* the current floppy image *and then* choose the next one? -- Empfehlen Sie GMX DSL Ihren Freunden und Bekannten und wir

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-19 Thread Jack
Eric, et al: thanks for the hint! I have commented out the line in autoexec.bat which loads the UIDE.SYS cdrom driver. Now there is no problem accessing the floppy images. So maybe there is a problem with floppy change signalling versus caches - would be interesting to know whether it is

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-19 Thread Wolfgang Schechinger
to (temporally) disable the UIDE driver in order to get my stuff done. Wo Original-Nachricht Datum: Sat, 19 May 2012 14:46:56 -0700 Von: Jack gykazequ...@earthlink.net An: freedos-user@lists.sourceforge.net Betreff: Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-19 Thread Ulrich Hansen
thanks for the hint! I have commented out the line in autoexec.bat which loads the UIDE.SYS cdrom driver. Now there is no problem accessing the floppy images. So maybe there is a problem with floppy change signalling versus caches - would be interesting to know whether it is sufficient

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-19 Thread Jack
Wolfgang, I am so happy that there is something like FreeDos available, even for free, that I can play around with. As I usually pretty soon run into very strange challenges for (any) software - some people say, that every computer that sees me for the first time, simply crashes,

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-19 Thread Wolfgang Schechinger
Jack, I don't think that this is possible. In my case, the installation prgrams is asking for the disks one by one, so there is no way to issue a commandline command inbetween. Wolfgang -- NEU: FreePhone 3-fach-Flat mit kostenlosem Smartphone! Jetzt

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-19 Thread Wolfgang Schechinger
Jack, when your harddrive as well as your floppies are virtual: does it make sense to cache them at all? The host operating system probably is already caching the relevant data. Wolfgang -- Empfehlen Sie GMX DSL Ihren Freunden und Bekannten und wir belohnen Sie mit bis zu 50,- Euro!

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-19 Thread Jack
Wolfgang, when your harddrive as well as your floppies are virtual: does it make sense to cache them at all? The host operating system probably is already caching the relevant data. One cannot be sure the host system is caching data! You should test this, by running with UIDE (caching)

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-16 Thread Marco Achury
El 16/05/2012 12:03 p.m., Wolfgang Schechinger escribió: Dear experts, I have some floppy images I want to use with FreeDos that is running in a VM (VirtualBox). The images work fine with e.g. Windows in such an environment. However with the virtual FreeDos, disk changes are not

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-16 Thread Wolfgang Schechinger
-Nachricht Datum: Wed, 16 May 2012 13:27:59 -0430 Von: Marco Achury marcoach...@gmail.com An: freedos-user@lists.sourceforge.net Betreff: Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox El 16/05/2012 12:03 p.m., Wolfgang Schechinger escribió: Dear experts, I have

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-16 Thread Ulrich Hansen
Hi Wolfgang, I just tested this with FreeDOS 1.1 as guest and VirtualBox 4.1.14 under OS X as host and it works for me. I start FreeDOS with option 1 in the start menu. I did not load UIDE.SYS in AUTOEXEC.BAT, as I normally don't work with CDs in FreeDOS anyway and VirtualBox conflicts with

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-16 Thread Wolfgang Schechinger
Hi Ulrich, thanks for the hint! I have commented out the line in autoexec.bat which loads the UIDE.SYS cdrom driver. Now there is no problem accessing the floppy images. Best regards, Wo -- Empfehlen Sie GMX DSL Ihren Freunden und Bekannten und wir belohnen Sie mit bis zu 50,- Euro!

Re: [Freedos-user] Virtual floppy change problem with VirtualBox

2012-05-16 Thread Jack
Wolfgang and Ulrich, Hi Ulrich, thanks for the hint! I have commented out the line in autoexec.bat which loads the UIDE.SYS cdrom driver. Now there is no problem accessing the floppy images. This sounds to me as if VirtualBox is NOT posting the media change bits for a floppy-disk in