rb "to realize" work or f'unction to
"talk about actual things and real relations"?
Ben Novak
*Ben Novak*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Maria, FL 34142
Telephone: (814) 808-5702
*"All art is mortal, **not merely the individual artifacts, but the arts
themselves.* *One day th
, from the
perspective of helping others by showing how Peirce's thought could clarify
or extend what they are dealing with.
Ben Novak
*Ben Novak*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Maria, FL 34142
Telephone: (814) 808-5702
*"All art is mortal, **not merely the individual artifacts, but the arts
Dear Jon, Stephen, List:
Whoops! I forgot the attachment.
(Book review starts at bottom of first page)
*Ben Novak*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Maria, FL 34142
Telephone: (814) 808-5702
*"All art is mortal, **not merely the individual artifacts, but the arts
themselves.* *One day the last por
scholars unable to descend from their
ivory towers of abstraction to deal with real world examples, this is a
classic.
Respectfully submitted,
Ben Novak
*Ben Novak*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Maria, FL 34142
Telephone: (814) 808-5702
*"All art is mortal, **not merely the individual artifact
e, if the thought of the Founder of Pragmatism--er,
Pragmaticism--can be said by his disciples to have no practical
application, what have we come to?
Respectfully submitted,
Ben Novak
*Ben Novak*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Maria, FL 34142
Telephone: (814) 808-5702
*"All art is mortal,
studies the principles that relate signs to each other and to the
world, then I simply think that Peter Skagestad and his sister are owed
more than has been offered.
Respectfully submitted,
Ben Novak
*Ben Novak*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Maria, FL 34142
Telephone: (814) 808-5702
*"All art is mor
with that criticism.
Regarding this, it seems something is missing--agree? disagree?
Kindly advise:
Ben Novak
*Ben Novak*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Maria, FL 34142
Telephone: (814) 808-5702
*"All art is mortal, **not merely the individual artifacts, but the arts
themselves.* *One day the last po
their views and arguments.
*Ben Novak*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Maria, FL 34142
Telephone: (814) 808-5702
Mobile: (814) 424-8501
*"All art is mortal, **not merely the individual artifacts, but the arts
themselves.* *One day the last portrait of Rembrandt* *and the last bar of
Mozart will have ce
a long time to come, the entire
work of human reason, in philosophy of every school and kind, in
mathematics, in psychology, in physical science, in history, in sociology,
and in whatever other departments may be, shall appear as the filling up of
its details."
http://paulhague.net/kindred-spir
es:
https://www.firstthings.com/article/1993/12/003-discovering-the-american-aristotle
*Ben Novak*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Maria, FL 34142
Telephone: (814) 808-5702
Mobile: (814) 424-8501
*"All art is mortal, **not merely the individual artifacts, but the arts
themselves.* *One day the last portrait of
be different from the universe of brute actuality).
I am not sure I am expressing this well, but my point is concerned with
adding being (and beings) into the mix as necessary to understand existence
and reality.
Ben Novak
*Ben Novak <http://bennovak.net>*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave
.."It is a real which only exists by virtue
of an act of thought knowing it,"
Ben Novak
*Ben Novak <http://bennovak.net>*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Maria, FL 34142
Telephone: (814) 808-5702
*"All art is mortal, **not merely the individual artifacts, but the arts
themselves.
le
into problems discussed elsewhere?
It would seem that this is particularly relevant to Peirce's theory of
thinking--or at least to our quest to discover it.
Ben N.
*Ben Novak <http://bennovak.net>*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Maria, FL 34142
Telephone: (814) 808-5702
*"All art is mortal, *
s not followed through. Here is my question (which I hope
"nests" all three of Jon's questions):
What would Anselm's ontological argument look like if it were restated in
Peirce's terms? In other words, could Anselm have discovered the same
argument as Peirce? Would this giv
o exist. Whosoever therefore
understandeth in this way that God exists, cannot conceive that he does not
exist. Thanks be to Thee, O good Lord, thanks be to Thee! because that
which heretofore I believed by Thy grace, I now by Thine illumination thus
understand, so that, even though I should not wish
at when the sound or shock wave hit me, I become aware of
them, and my body involuntarily and without conscious thinking reacts. And
by thirdness, I first wonder what made the sound or shock waves. Can I
achieve this by deleting "--I feel them," and is the example then sound?
Tha
to follow this
course with any degree of success, we would undoubtedly have to engage with
other disciplines and lines of thought, and could possibly even make some
contribution to the thought of other thinkers, philosophers, and
disciplines. Heaven forfend!
I hope you all enjoy the humor in that
Clark, Jon, Jerry, Edwina, List:
Perhaps this essay can help in finding what Peirce meant by speaking of
this "theory of thinking" in the Neglected Argument:
http://www.iupui.edu/~arisbe/menu/library/aboutcsp/chiasson/revisit.htm
Ben N.
*Ben Novak <http://bennovak.net>*
5
of
abductive reasoning (Musement)--where new possibilities first present
themselves for consideration--we can begin to build a clearer idea of what
Peirce actually intended for abduction--and his theory of pragmaticism to
mean. *
JerryR, I hope this answers your question.
Jon, I hope this furni
telex access to Peirce's works. That
is why I am asking for your help in finding the passage referred to above.
Thanks,
Ben N.
*Ben Novak <http://bennovak.net>*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Maria, FL 34142
Telephone: (814) 808-5702
*"All art is mortal, **not merely the individual ar
efully you will all be going strong on this subject for a while longer.
In my view, a heck of a lot of progress has been made, and I especially
thank Jon for starting it off.
Many thanks again to Ben U. and to all the participants in this discussion.
Ben N.
Ben
*Ben Novak <http://bennov
ty of Marburg, "What is
Metaphysics?"
http://www.naturalthinker.net/trl/texts/Heidegger,Martin/Heidegger.Martin..What%20Is%20Metaphysics.htm
Ben
*Ben Novak <http://bennovak.net>*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Maria, FL 34142
Telephone: (814) 808-5702
*"All art is mortal, **not merely the
Dear All:
Is the book reviewed here relevant to this discussion?
*A History of Balance, 1250–1375: The Emergence of a New Model of
Equilibrium and Its Impact on Thought* by Joel Kaye
http://www.nybooks.com/articles/2016/05/26/great-ignored-transformation/
Ben N.
*Ben Novak <h
Dear Stephen:
I read your piece on Neural Plasticity, at
https://www.academia.edu/3236559/Pragmatism_Neural_Plasticity_and_Mind-Body_Unity
and it makes a lot of sense to me. I suspect Tom's questions will dissolve
upon reading it, too.
Ben N.
*Ben Novak*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Mari
t these subjects are ubiquitous, and that if we were more
conscious of daily life and experiences, we would find much more fodder for
our work. Part of what I think important in this is a lot more awareness of
culture and history.
Ben Novak
*Ben Novak <http://bennovak.net>*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave
er understanding.
I hope this illuminates my first paragraph above, and explains why I
believe a new paradigm is required to proceed. I have learned a few things
about brain research by watching TED Talks at TED.com <http://ted.com/>.
Regards,
Tom Wyrick
*Ben Novak <http://bennov
tter of
course," and then deduced from A that one should find not only C, but also
D and F, then when one checked and found that D or F were not found in the
circumstances in which one found C, would then one have an attenuative
deduction situation? Or would one only have the falsification of hy
cause the last eye and the last ear
accessible to their message **will have gone."*
Cheers,
Ben Novak
*Ben Novak <http://bennovak.net>*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Maria, FL 34142
Telephones:
Magic Jack: (717) 826-5224 *Best to call and leave messages.*
Landline: 239-455-4200 *My brother&#
hite and those beans
come from that sack, it’s natural that the beans on the table are white.”
[iii] <https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?tab=wm#_ednref3> This is the
thesis of Umberto Eco and Thomas A. Sebeok in The Sign of Three.
[iv] <https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?tab=wm#_ednref4> Josep
know why the last paragraph copied in a different font size than
the ones before..., but you can find the whole essay in a singular font
online at:
http://www.cse.dmu.ac.uk/~mward/gkc/books/orthodoxy/ch4.html
Best,
Ben Novak
*Ben Novak <http://bennovak.net>*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Maria, FL 34
the shapes,
etc., of objects are really there."
http://www.commens.org/dictionary/term/quasi-mind
*Ben Novak <http://bennovak.net>*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Maria, FL 34142
Telephone: (814) 808-5702
*"All art is mortal, **not merely the individual artifacts, but the arts
themselves.
it together this way:
Yet, there is unique opportunity in this example for education and treating
attitudes because the phi ratio is *divine.* The spiral enters through the
senses as an esthetic image of a natural material, nature promises definite [I
would amend this to *infinite*--BenN)
t one does not have to do that over
anyone else's dead body.
Sincerely,
*Ben Novak*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Maria, FL 34142
Telephone: (814) 808-5702
Mobile: (814) 424-8501
*"All art is mortal, **not merely the individual artifacts, but the arts
themselves.* *One day the last portrait of Rem
I wonder whether the following article by Jaime Nubiola may offer some
guidance in the current discussion of Peirce's metaphysics:
https://www.academia.edu/19624309/What_a_Scientific_Metaphysics_Really_Is_According_to_C._S._Peirce
*Ben Novak*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Maria, FL 34142
Tele
ess the same meanings, even for a blind person who cannot see
the colors. If a blind woman received red roses from a gentleman, she would
know their meaning by simply being told their color.
So, my question is to JAS: Do the examples given above. can colors qualify
as signs?
*Ben Novak*
5129 Taylor
Books, Volume 5: The Trinity.
Ben Novak
On Sun, Jun 28, 2015 at 5:18 PM, Helmut Raulien wrote:
>
>
>
>
> Dear Edwina, I meant, that time is reversed virtually, not really, and
> with "virtually" I meant as represented by the mind. But now I suspect,
> that the te
er is astounding. And yet, as Ben
Novak demonstrates, historians still have not fully explained how this
ill-educated and irrational provincial Austrian actually rose to power in
Germany. This work uses the concept of abductive logic both as a means of
investigating the mystery of Hitler's rise to
glad to send a review copy to anyone who will commit to
writing a publishable review of the book for *Transactions* or some other
publication.
Thanks for your interest.
Ben Novak
*Ben Novak <http://bennovak.net>*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Maria, FL 34142
Telephones:
Magic Jack: (717) 826-5224
can see the discussion?
Ben
*Ben Novak <http://bennovak.net>*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Maria, FL 34142
Telephones:
Magic Jack: (717) 826-5224 *Best to call and leave messages.*
Landline: 239-455-4200 *My brother's main phone line.*
Mobile (202) 509-2655* I use this only on trips--and i
ication of
Peirce's logic, everything essential is present in the dissertation
available at the above site in pdf.
Ben
*Ben Novak <http://bennovak.net>*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Maria, FL 34142
Telephones:
Magic Jack: (717) 826-5224 *Best to call and leave messages.*
Landline: 239-455
Reply to Benjamin Udell test email
*Ben Novak <http://bennovak.net>*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Maria, FL 34142
Telephones:
Magic Jack: (717) 826-5224 *Best to call and leave messages.*
Landline: 239-455-4200 *My brother's main phone line.*
Mobile (202) 509-2655* I use this only on trips-
t I
present in this work may be of broader interest, and that if I am judged
successful in solving the problems I set out, that such a book will quicken
greater interest in Charles Sanders Peirce and the logic of abduction.
Thanks to all who have responded so far.
Ben
*Ben Novak <http://ben
oose not to read it, that
is a fair choice.
Thanks for responding,
Ben
*Ben Novak <http://bennovak.net>*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Maria, FL 34142
Telephones:
Magic Jack: (717) 826-5224 *Best to call and leave messages.*
Landline: 239-455-4200 *My brother's main phone line.*
/Hitler_Studies_A_Field_of_Amateurs
The Problem with Hitler: The Man Nobody Knows (2006)
https://www.academia.edu/8772277/The_Problem_with_Hitler_The_Man_Nobody_Knows
The Status of Hitler Today (2006)
https://www.academia.edu/8772100/The_Status_of_Hitler_Today
Best,
Ben N.
*Ben Novak <http://bennovak.net>*
5129
ing it. One can certainly say that Ben Novak has
made a serious effort, deserving of more attention than what some rather
pin-the-tail-on-the-donkey stuff has received occasionally on peirce-l.
Ben N. is on to something.
There's no requirement, only an invitation, for peirce-listers to read
Dear Stephen:
Take a look at p. 374 of *The Essential Peirce*, Vol II.
Ben Novak
*Ben Novak <http://bennovak.net>*
5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Maria, FL 34142
Telephones:
Magic Jack: (717) 826-5224 *Best to call and leave messages.*
Landline: 239-455-4200 *My brother's main phone line.*
46 matches
Mail list logo
