Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-22 Thread Dionisis Karampinis
Totally agree with you! Letting users know about the security flaws of IE6+7 is much more effective than the usual passive messages (especially on e-shops)!! Providing the content styled or not is a tough question, but i believe it all comes to the site's audience and purpose..for instance for a

RE: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-22 Thread Erickson, Kevin (DOE)
: Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet - Original Message - From: "Erickson, Kevin (DOE)" To: Sent: Tuesday, December 21, 2010 7:51 AM Subject: RE: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet Yes. Thank you Felix! "best viewed" works much bett

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-21 Thread David Hucklesby
On 12/20/10 6:14 PM, Chad Kelly wrote: - Original Message - From: "Erickson, Kevin (DOE)" To: Sent: Tuesday, December 21, 2010 7:51 AM Subject: RE: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet Yes. Thank you Felix! "best viewed" works much better. [...] Thi

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-21 Thread stuart
On Mon, 20 Dec 2010 13:10:03 -0800, tee wrote: One of my clients did an implementation on his site, year ago the usage of IE6 was over 15%; he had me put up an IE6 no more banner, 6 months later, the usage only dropped some 3%. Then I read news about Google got hacked and that Microsoft asked

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-20 Thread Joseph Taylor
- Sites by Joe, LLC /"Clean, Simple and Elegant Web Design"/ Phone: (609) 335-3076 Web: http://sitesbyjoe.com Email: j...@sitesbyjoe.com On 12/20/10 9:14 PM, Chad Kelly wrote: - Original Message - From: "Erickson, Kevin (DOE)" To: Sent: Tue

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-20 Thread Chad Kelly
- Original Message - From: "Erickson, Kevin (DOE)" To: Sent: Tuesday, December 21, 2010 7:51 AM Subject: RE: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet Yes. Thank you Felix! "best viewed" works much better. And then throw in the fact that IE 6 was first rel

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-20 Thread G.Sørtun
On 20.12.2010 21:00, David McKinnon wrote: Sorry Georg, I should have read your article before (re)using that joke! I still not sure I'd spend extra effort to effectively penalise IE6 users. IE6 is not Netscape 4, its CSS support is not that bad. ... I just realised I'm sticking up for IE6! Mu

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-20 Thread tee
On Dec 20, 2010, at 12:26 PM, Felix Miata wrote: > On 2010/12/20 13:13 (GMT-0500) Erickson, Kevin (DOE) composed: > >> I like the "let it fail gracefully" method. And, using something like >> , display a message for IE 6 only, "You are using IE 6. >> Please upgrade your browser to view this sit

RE: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-20 Thread Erickson, Kevin (DOE)
nal Message- From: li...@webstandardsgroup.org [mailto:li...@webstandardsgroup.org] On Behalf Of Felix Miata Sent: Monday, December 20, 2010 3:26 PM To: wsg@webstandardsgroup.org Subject: Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet On 2010/12/20 13:13 (GMT-0500) Erickson, Kevin (DOE) compos

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-20 Thread Felix Miata
On 2010/12/20 13:13 (GMT-0500) Erickson, Kevin (DOE) composed: I like the "let it fail gracefully" method. And, using something like , display a message for IE 6 only, "You are using IE 6. Please upgrade your browser to view this site correctly." "Correctly"? Do all compliant browsers do corre

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-20 Thread David McKinnon
Sorry Georg, I should have read your article before (re)using that joke! I still not sure I'd spend extra effort to effectively penalise IE6 users. IE6 is not Netscape 4, its CSS support is not that bad. ... I just realised I'm sticking up for IE6! Must be the payback for all the nasty things I'

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-20 Thread Joseph Taylor
IE6 would not load the stylesheet if set up the line of HTML like this: Joseph R. B. Taylor /Web Designer / Developer/ -- Sites by Joe, LLC /"Clean, Simple and Elegant Web Design"/ Phone: (609) 335-3076 Web: http://sitesbyjoe.com Email: j...@sitesbyjoe.co

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-20 Thread Ty Hatch
http://forabeautifulweb.com/blog/about/universal_internet_explorer_6_css/ On Sat, Dec 18, 2010 at 4:20 AM, tee wrote: > I am finally to begin to stop supporting IE6 starts from 2011 as the usage > has fallen below 5%. I don't want the IE6 users to see a broken page due to > no special treatment

RE: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-20 Thread Erickson, Kevin (DOE)
I like the "let it fail gracefully" method. And, using something like , display a message for IE 6 only, "You are using IE 6. Please upgrade your browser to view this site correctly." Kevin -Original Message- From: li...@webstandardsgroup.org [mailto:li...@webstandardsgroup.org] On Behalf

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-20 Thread tee
Paul, thank you very much! Very neat! Had a deja vu moment when I saw the title, I might had stumbled on that article before. If I were to find the article in 2009 it probably wasn't worth the consideration due to IE6 usage at that time, but it's prime time to start using this technique now

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-19 Thread Paul Irish
tee, you want this: http://forabeautifulweb.com/blog/about/universal_internet_explorer_6_css/ it greatly simplifies the layout for IE6.. to just be the straight-up content.. no layout tricks. plus decent typography. :) On Sun, Dec 19, 2010 at 3:59 PM, "G.Sørtun" wrote: > On 19.12.2010 22:13,

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-19 Thread G.Sørtun
On 19.12.2010 22:13, David McKinnon wrote: Sounds like you're going to a lot of effort to make the IE6 experince worse than it needs to be. Is this *dis*graceful degradation? ;) David As it says in my article: "I've restricted disgraceful degradation to IE6 and older." And, the effort is min

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-19 Thread David McKinnon
Sounds like you're going to a lot of effort to make the IE6 experince worse than it needs to be. Is this *dis*graceful degradation? ;) David On 20/12/2010, at 1:18 AM, tee wrote: > Thanks. I need to look into it and run a few tests. > > I think it may not be a safest approach as I vaguely rem

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-19 Thread tee
Thanks. I need to look into it and run a few tests. I think it may not be a safest approach as I vaguely remember I experienced a few issue using @import with CSS compression and CSS file merging script. Script that brings CSS3 selectors for IE such as selectivizr also cannot handle @import pro

RE: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-18 Thread Thierry Koblentz
> >> The reason for this is twofold though: firstly, you want to coax > people off of IE6. > > > I don't think that's our job... > > Who better? Wouldn't you rather IE6/7 disappear sooner than later? You > enjoy > the extra effort the too many years of its massive non-conformity > causes? Most

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-18 Thread Ben Buchanan
On 18 December 2010 22:20, tee wrote: > I am finally to begin to stop supporting IE6 starts from 2011 as the usage > has fallen below 5%. I don't want the IE6 users to see a broken page due to > no special treatment made for the browser, rather, I would like them to see > an un-styled page as if

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-18 Thread Eric Taylor
Agreed. Our job is to provide the best web experience the user can have. To do this, the user will optimally have the most up-to-date browser, as to experience the latest web technology available. Eric Taylor < Elements Aside /> http://www.elementsaside.com On Dec 18, 2010, at 11:49 PM, Felix M

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-18 Thread Felix Miata
On 2010/12/18 20:33 (GMT-0800) Thierry Koblentz composed: The reason for this is twofold though: firstly, you want to coax people off of IE6. I don't think that's our job... Who better? Wouldn't you rather IE6/7 disappear sooner than later? You enjoy the extra effort the too many years o

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-18 Thread Eric Taylor
Also, I forgot to mention - If you are looking to get people to move to a newer browser, simple implement a small banner, maybe static header or footer, that recommends some newer browsers. This can be added into your override CSS file for the outdated browser(s). Eric Taylor < Elements Aside /

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-18 Thread Eric Taylor
Good points James. When I think about cross-browser compatibility, I try to keep the following points in mind: 1 - Websites don't have to look the same in each browser. This doesn't mean that you can ignore how pages render in browsers you don't care about; it means that if Chrome displays roun

RE: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-18 Thread Thierry Koblentz
> The reason for this is twofold though: firstly, you want to coax people off > of IE6. I don't think that's our job... -- Regards, Thierry www.tjkdesign.com | www.ez-css.org | @thierrykoblentz *** List Guidelines: http:/

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-18 Thread Andrew Stewart
Is there a js file somewhere that would allow me to just insert the following into my pages: http://cdn.domain.com/ie6.js";> It would then pop up a warning to the user (but only once per session) that their browser was out of date, and give them links to more modern browsers - like what

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-18 Thread James Ducker
> > > Imho, we should take care of any layout issue, but not try to get fancy > effects via extra markup, images, filters, and other hacks. In short, IE6 > should get layout fixes and miss on properties like "border-radius", > "opacity", etc. > So no need for a specific styles sheet imo. > > The re

RE: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-18 Thread Thierry Koblentz
> Personally I think it is reasonable to take this approach, given the > age > of IE6 and its declining market share. However I would be interested in > the attitude of other developers. Imho, we should take care of any layout issue, but not try to get fancy effects via extra markup, images, filte

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-18 Thread Grant Bailey
Big companies such as Google and Youtube have had to deal with the IE6 problem on a large scale. Their pages display a warning message to advise IE6 users that the page may not display correctly, and suggest upgrading to a more recent browser. Personally I think it is reasonable to take this a

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-18 Thread Anthony Gr.
Sorry :) ... of course. Best, Anton. 2010/12/18 Anthony Gr. : > Hi. I think, this example will help you: > > > > > > > Best, > Anton > > > 2010/12/18 tee : >> I am finally to begin to stop supporting IE6 starts from 2011 as the usage >> has fallen below 5%. I don't want the IE6 users to see

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-18 Thread Anthony Gr.
Hi. I think, this example will help you: Best, Anton 2010/12/18 tee : > I am finally to begin to stop supporting IE6 starts from 2011 as the usage > has fallen below 5%. I don't want the IE6 users to see a broken page due to > no special treatment made for the browser, rather, I would lik

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-18 Thread G.Sørtun
I am finally to begin to stop supporting IE6 starts from 2011 as the usage has fallen below 5%. I don't want the IE6 users to see a broken page due to no special treatment made for the browser, rather, I would like them to see an un-styled page as if the style sheet has switch off. Can this

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-18 Thread Benjamin Hawkes-Lewis
On Sat, Dec 18, 2010 at 11:20 AM, tee wrote: > I am finally to begin to stop supporting IE6 starts from 2011 as the usage > has fallen below 5%. I don't want the IE6 users to see a broken page due to > no special treatment made for the browser, rather, I would like them to see > an un-styled pa

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-18 Thread tee
Don't have any base, I just think psychologically an un-styled page is better received than a broken page, and it makes the page loads faster too without nice transparent background images. I wouldn't called these two pages failed gracefully. They are semi-broken and PNG transparent images a

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-18 Thread David Laakso
On 12/18/10 6:20 AM, tee wrote: I am finally to begin to stop supporting IE6 starts from 2011 as the usage has fallen below 5%. I don't want the IE6 users to see a broken page due to no special treatment made for the browser, rather, I would like them to see an un-styled page as if the style s

Re: [WSG] disallow IE6 to load the main style sheet

2010-12-18 Thread Russ Weakley
Why go that far? Why not let this browser see the CSS and fail gracefully - or semi-gracefully as needed (as long as the content and navigation are accessible so that the site can be navigated and read). On 18/12/2010, at 10:20 PM, tee wrote: > I am finally to begin to stop supporting IE6 star