XAuth is is the right choice for an end-user client app and satisfactorily resolves the UX issues in client applications that OAuth creates. Unfortunately, many web-app developers simply don't know enough about end-user client app development to understand these UX issues, or why end-user client application trust is neither an issue that needs addressing nor one that OAuth can (nor even attempts to) address.
It shouldn't take more than a week or two to get your authorization from Twitter to use XAuth if you're applying for a client app. On May 30, 1:40 pm, Bernd Stramm <[email protected]> wrote: > On Sun, 30 May 2010 11:14:54 -0700 > > > > > > Abraham Williams <[email protected]> wrote: > > On Sun, May 30, 2010 at 11:01, Bernd Stramm <[email protected]> > > wrote: > > > > The user does trust the app, otherwise they would not be using it. > > > The problem with the scheme of using the app *and* a browser is > > > that the user has to trust *both* of them. > > > > And if they don't trust the app, why are they using it to post their > > > tweets? > > > Trust is not a boolean value. There are levels of it. I trust my > > mobile browser to not take over my Twitter account but I only trust > > random new Twitter client to not post spam. If the Twitter client > > breaks my trust it is easy to revoke access to it. > > Is it easy for most users? The authentication token doesn't expire, so > an application (any application, not just desktop/mobile client) can do > what it wants for quite a while. > > You should be careful with trusting browsers, mobile or otherwise. They > are very leaky. > > And my point remains, when using a browser *and* a standalone client, > the user trusts both of them. From the point of view of the honest > application developer, I do not want to assume that another application > (the browser) which is completely unknown to me, is trustworthy. Hence > I prefer the solution with the small integrated webview in my > application. > > But also, what do people to with their twitter account that needs > protecting, other than posting messages and media content? And of > course giving away great data to the data miners. > > A lot of this authentication business misses the easiest intrusion > vector anyway. People will steal your phone, and have access to > everything you store on it. Including any authentication for serious > business. Nevermind trusting the standalone app or the browser, the > entire system is easily compromised if its stolen. > > -- > Bernd Stramm > <[email protected]>
