Thanks for the additional context Rich. I might have derailed a bit since I was looking to improve the onboarding of new contributors (without ASF ID) into the apache ecosystem, which IMO has some intersection with the badging system, but it's definitely not the same thing.
I'll sleep on this, do some homework and get back to this later. Stay tuned! :) In the meantime anyone else feel free to take up the original questions posed by Rich in the beginning of the thread so we get back on topic. On Wed, Mar 20, 2024 at 3:25 PM Rich Bowen <rbo...@rcbowen.com> wrote: > > > On Mar 20, 2024, at 11:59 AM, Paulo Motta <pa...@apache.org> wrote: > > > > Rich: > > > > I need some time to better elaborate this. I will prepare sometime in the > > next week or so a short doc explaining what am I proposing, what problem > it > > solves and how it intersects with the badging tool object of this working > > group. > > > > I suspect we might be thinking about similar things but in different > terms, > > right now I’m just doing unstructured brainstorming. > > > > On the meantime, can you briefly describe what problem are you trying to > > solve with this badging system, and what do you expect from it to ensure > > we’re talking about the same things? If this is already described > somewhere > > please let me know and I will use it to check if this intersects with the > > proposal I have in mind. > > The purpose of badging is discussed here: > https://github.com/apache/comdev-working-groups/tree/main/wg-badging > > In brief, it’s to celebrate and gamify moments in individuals’ community > journey. It’s a way for people to brag/celebrate/display their > accomplishments, since this is something that has been shown to motivate > not only participation, but for people to expand outside of their usual > habitual sphere of participation and try other things. > > Tying it to Apache IDs is reasonable because this is for us. It’s for our > community. It’s to make others want to be part of our community, sure, but > primarily it’s for our community. Having a (very very small, I might note) > barrier to entry is totally reasonable. And creating a new, separate ID > system actively defeats the link with the community, not to mention > introducing new complications. > > Celebrating achievements in community is a building block for tighter > community relationships. I encourage everyone on the ComDev project to read > The Art of Community by Charles Vogl, because there’s a TON of science > around how to build community that we, in open source, tend to be largely > unaware of, going back decades, and we miss out on a LOT of simple > low-hanging opportunities to draw people in, and strengthen what we have. > This is one of them. > > >
