Hi Silvia, Re harmful effects of co-sleeping -there are some comprehensive articles in my links page -I have a heading Co sleeping links. ( www.pinky-mychild.com ) One of these is an entire issue of Mothering Magazine devoted to research on cosleeping by various experts (including James MCKenna) . The studies of long term benefits are interesting and positive (male college students who co-slept when babies had better sex lives!!).
This may have been a fairly typical but innocent comment from a 9 year old who actually saw what was happening with his parents. Our kids were not in our bed at that age except if they wandered in to cuddle the baby or have a morning cuddle and chat at weekends, and I dont know of anyone having this experience (perhaps because they would be tooo embarrassed to say so??) - most kids simply think parents are cuddling so as littlies often do ask can they cuddle too. Once when our youngest was just 5 , he was looking through story books beside our bed and came across a pair of knickers among the rubble. He exclaimed - Girls knickers!! Some one has been having sex in this bed! I thought ,oh my goodness, my baby has lost his innocence -(hes the bonus baby and we had teenagers then too) but as I casually said -"Sex - what's that?" he said "Oh, mum , you know - when you cuddle for a very long time with your clothes off." Maybe we should clarify what kids really mean - perhaps their intentions really are quite innocent and we are the ones reading deviance into what they say and consequently making them feel abnormal / "dirty" by our reactions - if they were truly deviant do you think they would actually say these things out loud? I must say, I have found families with various levels of comfort about older children sharing sleep etc with them, nudity etc. My own kids went happily off to their own beds between 3 and 5 (all different needs and personalities) and all developed a natural need for privacy as they approached adolescence - all at different ages again (Sarah, my photographer daugheter has a beautiful photo of Larissa my other daughter) nude on a beach at 5 am in winter in Melbourne - Sarah had apparently thought it would be great to do in the afternoon on a sunny day, but Larissa was more comfortable with a deserted beach even tho it was freezing!) . A woman I knew quite well had a big house with a double shower and her boys used to shower with her -I remembering being quite shocked that her 13 year old would shower with her -mine certainly wouldnt have and I wouldnt have felt comfortable with this. I am not sure whether this is a bit odd or whether my boundaries are much stronger. My 12 year old certainly shuts his bedroom and the bathroom door these days. Pinky Pinky ----- Original Message ----- From: "Sylvia Boutsalis" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Saturday, March 20, 2004 10:58 AM Subject: RE: [ozmidwifery] husbands on co-sleeping > I read some very interesting thoughts, and thankyou for sharing them > with me. I may just do an activity about co-sleeping and take some > comments from your messages if you give me permission. > I also came from home with no nudity and anything sexual was taboo. We > as parents though are totally different too. We bathe all our children > together (1 girl, 2 boys) and everytime I come out of the shower there > is always a couple of little hands wanting to pull my nipples! My > husband is very involved with the upbringing of our children. Sometimes > I feel he loves them more than I do (that's the exhaustion speaking!) > It is as you say, back then all children slept with their parents and > then slowly society has changed it to each child has a room and > therefore co-sleeping has become taboo along with breastfeeding past 1 > year and tandem breastfeeding. > > I still have concerns because my young cousin (9 at the time) was asking > his mother if he could 'stick his thing in her like daddy does' while > co-sleeping because my uncle thought he was asleep while they were > having sex. This child is now seeing a therapist. But after reading > all these responses of well adjusted adults who co-slept, is this > instance with my cousin rare? > > > Sylvia > > > -----Original Message----- > From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Nicole > Christensen > Sent: Friday, 19 March 2004 11:57 PM > To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > Subject: [ozmidwifery] husbands on co-sleeping > > > Hi Sylvia -as you were curious about the effects of co-sleeping on > husbands....thought I might tell you of mine... My husband was brought > up in a very traditional household - no nudity, no going near parent's > bed etc etc. yet he has fathered the complete anti-of his father (thank > goodness!!!) We shower and bath with our children, all doors are left > open (including toilet)... and he lavishes our boys with lots of kisses, > love and his time. We are self-confessed dags - our little family - we > do absolutely EVERYTHING together... grocery shopping, collecting our > eldest son from school, watching him play sport, training, walks etc > etc We also have no real family support - so my husband and I never > have time alone - and whenever we go out - it is always with our boys. I > breastfeed my children until they are ready to self-wean (still going > strong tandem feeding my 2 1/2 yr old and 7 mth old)...with FULL support > of my husband ... so, co- sleeping has been pretty much an unsaid > natural extension of our parenting.... (ie doing everything together). > My husband has NEVER complained about sharing our bed with our children > (or even having to sleep in another room and bed when he gets booted > out... which is OFTEN) . We have a single bed pushed up to our queen > bed. Most nights our nearly 12 yr old sleeps in the single bed (the > other nights my husband gets a turn...) and I sleep in the middle of the > queen bed with my baby on one side and our 2 yr old on the other. I love > having my children sleep with me. having all 3 boys with me, safe and > cosy and snuggly all night long. Then there's the giggles and fun when > they all awake together - particularly with my 12 yr old and 2 yr old > who are extremely close. When my husband is in there too - he loves this > also! My husband and I are very in-love and very close... yet we don't > have the intimacy that we once had before I was completely exhausted and > chronically sleep deprived. My husband sees how exhausted I am... and he > is tired too... as our very demanding and non-sleeping 2 1/2 yr old > finally drops at 11 pm each night - and this is when we are doing the > dishes, washing nappies etc etc. Our sex life is a dire contrast to > pre-children... I was the sex goddess... and now I am a PLANT!!! I know > he would like to have sex every now and then (and we don't do it in the > bedroom, either!) - and will sometimes be not so subtle in hinting... > but at the same time -he sees how exhausted I am, and feels sorry for me > - so would never push it with me. he also misses cuddling me in bed - > but knows that this time of our children being so young, needy and > dependant is too short-lived - so accepts that this is how it is NOW but > will not always be this way..... I think the only thing that makes my > husband frustrated - is the fact that our toddler goes to bed so late - > and then we do some housework... which by then, it is around midnight. > He would LOVE to have some "me time" for himself to wind down... and > some time shared with me. This isn't possible with a wakeful night-owl 2 > 1/ yr old!!! Your comment "that is not what's supposed to happen" -ie > giving your children yourself over your husband during the night - is > interesting. I agree that it is important to give time to your husband > and your marriage... but it is not always realistic. If our children > want me/us in the night - it is and has never been an issue... or even > discussed for that matter.. as it has always been an unspoken natural > thing foir us to do... and we enjoy being with them in bed at night as > much as the children love being with us too... kind regards, Nicole > > > > ----- Original Message ----- > From: "Sylvia Boutsalis" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > To: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > Sent: Friday, March 19, 2004 10:10 AM > Subject: RE: [ozmidwifery] sleep stuff > > > > I don't mean to be judgmental in relation to co-sleeping but I am > > curious about what happens to the couples relationship? I am not a > > selfish person but I do regard my bed time to be something shared with > > > my husband alone. For me having a child in bed turns my attention > > away from my partner and intimacy and focuses on my child. That is > > not what is supposed to happen. Children take up so much time that > > it's important to be able to find time to nurture our own relationship > > > with our partner, and most of that time is usually at night when the > > children go to bed and when we go to bed. Children are an extension > > of us, not a replacement of our affections. > > > > I would be interested to know how the men in your lives are coping > > with this arrangement. Are they really into it or have they just > > accepted it? > > > > Sylvia > > Mum to Ellie 10, Chris 6 and Evan 4 (who all breastfed, but never > > co-slept) > > > > > > -----Original Message----- > > From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Wayne and > > Cas > > Sent: Friday, 19 March 2004 8:48 AM > > To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > Subject: [ozmidwifery] sleep stuff > > > > > > Well, we tried the side car thing last night and he went down without > > any hassles at 8.30, then woke up at 10pm so I fed him and gently > > rolled him over to the cot and he didn't stir until 5am this morning. > > So far so good. It was the best night's sleep I've had in weeks. > > Thanks for all of your suggestions. > > > > I wanted to add though that sleeping with children and babies is not > > right for everyone. I don't actually know too many adults or children > > that seem affected by the fact their parents made them sleep in a cot > > when they were babies. There is a lot more to parenting than whether > > you co-sleep or not. Ie. If you don't love your kids unconditionally, > > no amount of co-sleeping is going to give the added security a child > > needs. I think we are all individuals and so are our children and we > > just need to work out what best suits them. When Liam was the same age > > > as Daniel he was very hands off, didn't want hugs, didn't want the > > breast a lot and it hurt me at the time but it was what he needed. > > Daniel is a totally different baby. > > > > I will let you know if our good fortune last night continues. > > > > Cheers Cas. > > > > Cas, Wayne, Liam and Daniel McCullough > > [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > www.casmccullough.com > > > > > > > > -- > > This mailing list is sponsored by ACE Graphics. > > Visit <http://www.acegraphics.com.au> to subscribe or unsubscribe. > > > > > > -- > > This mailing list is sponsored by ACE Graphics. > > Visit <http://www.acegraphics.com.au> to subscribe or unsubscribe. > > > -- > This mailing list is sponsored by ACE Graphics. > Visit <http://www.acegraphics.com.au> to subscribe or unsubscribe. > > > -- > This mailing list is sponsored by ACE Graphics. > Visit <http://www.acegraphics.com.au> to subscribe or unsubscribe. -- This mailing list is sponsored by ACE Graphics. Visit <http://www.acegraphics.com.au> to subscribe or unsubscribe.
