Re: [ZION] Imagine that!

2002-11-01 Thread Steven Montgomery
They must be stepping up their attack of these scam letters. I usually receive one or two of these a year, but, for some odd reason, just in the last few weeks I've received several. -- Steven Montgomery At 08:25 PM 10/31/2002, you wrote: I know there's a lot of hilarity in this thread, but in

[ZION] Guns, Germs and Steel

2002-11-01 Thread John W. Redelfs
Has anyone on the list read GUNS, GERMS AND STEEL by Jared Diamond? It won the Pulitzer Prize for general nonfiction in 1998. I am about half way through it, and I'm getting bogged down. This guy is a scientist and a historian, but he keeps explaining how domesticated plants were developed

Re: [ZION] Guns, Germs and Steel

2002-11-01 Thread Paul Osborne
Maybe the scriptures really are just an ancient collection of Hebrew folk talks. Is that possible? Well, I've put all my eggs in one basket in the which the scriptures are true. However, it seems that symbolism plays a major part in the stories told of the Bible which could make what we think

[ZION] Colonialism

2002-11-01 Thread Marc A. Schindler
Chris Grant, a participant on a sister list of Zion-L's, posted a question he asked of Christopher Hichens who is what I think you might call in the US a good liberal if that isn't oxymoronic. I've long been a fan of his, and I think Christ liked Hichens' latest book, Why Orwell Matters. But it

Re: [ZION] Guns, Germs and Steel

2002-11-01 Thread Zion
John: Has anyone on the list read GUNS, GERMS AND STEEL by Jared Diamond? It won the Pulitzer Prize for general nonfiction in 1998. I am about half way through it, and I'm getting bogged down. This guy is a scientist and a historian, but he keeps explaining how domesticated plants were

[ZION] Charter issue? RE: [LDSD] You just don't get it

2002-11-01 Thread Sandy and Melinda Rabinowitz
Bro. Ross-- I know you mean well, and I do not speak as the listowner or anyone having authority, but I am not sure it is appropriate to post the telephone numbers of stake presidents, bishops, or other church leaders on a public or semi-public forum such as LDS-Doctrine or ZION, especially if

Re: [ZION] Weapons of Mass Destruction

2002-11-01 Thread Marc A. Schindler
In the 1P statement on the MX missile, Pres. Kimball says something to the effect that there was never a time that weapons were made, that they weren't used. John W. Redelfs wrote: In every age of mankind's sojourn upon this earth, he has supposed that his technology is superior to all those

Re: [ZION] Charter issue? RE: [LDSD] You just don't get it

2002-11-01 Thread Sandy and Melinda Rabinowitz
Darn it, I hate it when I keep posting to the wrong list! Oh well, I won't repeat myself. I was blowing off steam, anyway. /Sandy/ Sandy and Melinda Rabinowitz [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Bro. Ross-- I know you mean well, [snip]

Re: [ZION] Guns, Germs and Steel

2002-11-01 Thread Marc A. Schindler
I have. John W. Redelfs wrote: Has anyone on the list read GUNS, GERMS AND STEEL by Jared Diamond? It won the Pulitzer Prize for general nonfiction in 1998. I am about half way through it, and I'm getting bogged down. This guy is a scientist and a historian, but he keeps explaining how

Re: [ZION] Guns, Germs and Steel

2002-11-01 Thread Dan R Allen
John: It seems to me that an honest scholar would just stick to writing things he can authenticate using the documentary record, or at least the archaeological record. In the absence of such records the author isn't just engaging in unfounded supposition, he is engaged in irresponsible

Re: [ZION] Guns, Germs and Steel

2002-11-01 Thread John W. Redelfs
At 01:56 PM, Friday, 11/1/02, Marc A. Schindler wrote: You're asking a question Diamond doesn't attempt to answer, and there's no easy way to answer this. I don't believe I suggested that Diamond was supposed to answer my question. I asked my question of the members of this list. If Diamond

Re: [ZION] Guns, Germs and Steel

2002-11-01 Thread Marc A. Schindler
Of course they're true. But what do you mean by true? Scientists use a different definition, and this is where the apparent contradictions arise. Science is forever tentative and can only deal with the physical data it has at hand. It's been very useful and I wouldn't want to do without it, but

Re: [ZION] Iraq: letters in Meridian

2002-11-01 Thread Marc A. Schindler
Stephen Beecroft wrote: -Marc- when it can dip *below* -40oC (which is also, as you probably know, -40oF). This is unnecessarily cruel. There was no need to preempt my favorite smart-alek comment. Meanie. You mean how F really means Foreignheat? Stephen Automobiles don't kill

Re: [ZION] Guns, Germs and Steel

2002-11-01 Thread Marc A. Schindler
Scientists go from the assumption that the Bible isn't secular history, and in that they are right. Apples and oranges. Zion wrote: John: Has anyone on the list read GUNS, GERMS AND STEEL by Jared Diamond? It won the Pulitzer Prize for general nonfiction in 1998. I am about half way

Re: [ZION] Guns, Germs and Steel

2002-11-01 Thread John W. Redelfs
At 04:13 PM, Friday, 11/1/02, Dan R Allen wrote: Something else to consider on the sheep issue John is that we seem to be the only group that understands that Adam lived here - I think that most people assume that Eden was somewhere in what is now the mid-east, if they think about it at all.

Re: [ZION] Guns, Germs and Steel

2002-11-01 Thread John W. Redelfs
At 04:42 PM, Friday, 11/1/02, Marc A. Schindler wrote: Of course they're true. But what do you mean by true? Scientists use a different definition, and this is where the apparent contradictions arise. Science is forever tentative and can only deal with the physical data it has at hand. It's been

Re: [ZION] Iraq: letters in Meridian

2002-11-01 Thread Grampa Bill
Marc A. Schindler wrote: Our foreign affairs people are advising Canadian citizens who were born in the Middle East not to travel via the US. = Grampa Bill comments: Well, that's about the best news I've heard lately! Don't waste the atonement. Sue Woodbury,

Re: [ZION] Iraq: letters in Meridian

2002-11-01 Thread Marc A. Schindler
I'm sorry to hear that. It can be very disruptive and discouraging, and I wish you all the best in finding something you enjoy as soon as possible. And seriously, if you're a high-tech worker or a professional in various other departments, as a citizen of a NAFTA country you can get a job anywhere

Re: [ZION] Guns, Germs and Steel

2002-11-01 Thread Marc A. Schindler
Jim, care to back *any* of this up with any actual facts, rather than just a rant? Jim Cobabe wrote: John, Scientists are free to indulge their fancy. Obviously there's little historic evidence to substantiate supposedly prehistoric events. For many science devotees, one basic premise is

Re: [ZION] Guns, Germs and Steel

2002-11-01 Thread Marc A. Schindler
Well put, Dan. Science has a methodology which is based upon certain assumptions. Many scientists make the mistake of assuming that that's all there is. But many non-scientists likewise make the mistake of pooh-poohing a scientific discovery out of ignorance of how science works, or because on the

Re: [ZION] Iraq: letters in Meridian

2002-11-01 Thread Paul Osborne
Ok, I was just asking. Yet, it was not entirely a throw away remark, as after four years at a job that was perfect for myself and family at the time, I now find myself among the ranks of the unemployed. O dear! I'm so sorry to hear that. I hope you get... Paul O [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: [ZION] Iraq: letters in Meridian

2002-11-01 Thread Marc A. Schindler
Now, if we can just stop the flow of terrorists from the US into our country that'll be even better. Grampa Bill wrote: Marc A. Schindler wrote: Our foreign affairs people are advising Canadian citizens who were born in the Middle East not to travel via the US.

Re: [ZION] Guns, Germs and Steel

2002-11-01 Thread Marc A. Schindler
This issue comes up in apologetics all the time, especially with respect to the evident lack of horses in the New World between the end of the ice age and the time of Columbus (the Vikings don't count because it's known they didn't bring horses with them). And the answer, or more properly, I

Re: [ZION] Iraq: letters in Meridian

2002-11-01 Thread Marc A. Schindler
Double bummer. Well, look after your own emotional health, too. I've learned the hard way that physical illness can have all kinds of psychological effects which in turn exacerbate the physical illness. I wish I had known that before I decided to get sick. :-/ You'll be in our prayers. Steven

[ZION] Symbolic distractions

2002-11-01 Thread Jim Cobabe
This message is symbolic, therefore it cannot be construed to contain any particular meaning. Take a stab in the dark, interpret it however you like. One guess is as good as another. --- Mij Ebaboc / /// ZION LIST