On 2018-03-21 11:55, Raimon Esteve wrote: > 2018-03-21 11:37 GMT+01:00 Sergi Almacellas Abellana <se...@koolpi.com>: > > El 21/03/18 a les 11:18, Raimon Esteve ha escrit: > >>> Raimon: Could you explain what do you mean about deducible and which > >>> functionalities are implemented? > >> First design account_es module: > >> > >> https://bitbucket.org/trytonspain/trytond-account_es/src/ > > > > That's the base we picked for the first version of the account_es > > module. We did some cleaning and as already explained on this thread we > > should do more cleaning. > >> > >> Third modules to add more functions in account_es core module (from > >> tryton.org): > >> > >> https://bitbucket.org/trytonspain/trytond-account_es_es/src/ > > > > Let's comment the functionality added by this module. > > > > - It adds and efective kind on account. Where is the efective kind used? > > If any module requires a new kind it should be added on the module and > > not on a chart of accounts (Like we do in account_deposit). Indeed there > > is an issue to allow to define the kind depending on the activated > > modules: https://bugs.tryton.org/issue7126 > > https://bitbucket.org/trytonspain/trytond-account_es/commits/ad96bde5798318763e303caa6becd4470e33c4a3
I do not understand what you mean by pointing a link to commit. Please elaborate a sentence to explain. Please try to be understood by others. > > - It adds the code on fiscalyear and period. This was removed by > > https://bugs.tryton.org/issue4241 Could you explain why is required to > > have the code on the spanish localization. I don't see any reason here. > > Code field was removed from account module last versions. We use in > aeat modules, etc. What is the usage? Why not use the name? > > - It removes the xml check from the template modules. Why is this > > required? IIRC this is a workarround to solve another problem and should > > not be part of the chart of accounts. > > to allow update account.template etc I think this shows that current Spanish account template are wrong if they need to be updated. And it is probably because there are too much. > > - It adds a report description on the taxes. This is already implemented > > with https://bugs.tryton.org/issue2329 > > Is not same legal notice that report description tax. Please explain. What is the purpose? where is it used? > > - It adds a deducible boolean on the taxes. I see all have the value of > > True. So could you explain why this flag is needed and which taxes will > > have a False value? > > https://bitbucket.org/trytonspain/tryton-account_es_csv2xml/commits/a85b54392424eeb8be4b404e46aeaacbfb27ae7b Again what do you want to express by pointing a commit of thousand of lines? Please try to have a conversation with arguments and explanation. > > - It adds a recargo equivalencia flag to the taxes. This flag is not set > > for any taxes (but we have the recargo the equivalencia base module). So > > I do not think this is a used feature and it can be removed. > > https://bitbucket.org/trytonspain/tryton-account_es_csv2xml/commits/492a29cbc17b1590c10763d9629a07d65f0d01b0 Again the same thousands of lines without any explanation. > note: > @sergi, you was working on trytonspain modules some years ago. I think > you know/remember very well all features and desings, and why do > it,.... ;) And for the others? How can we have explanation and design choices? > I have two new quesions to know future about account_es module: > > - Who know account chart account? spanish account users or foreign users? I think keeping it secret only for you is not how to build a community. Most of the challenge of accounting are not limited to a country as we showed in many cases (cash basis, tax rule substitutions, invoice sequences etc.). So yes "foreign developers" will probably improve the Spanish chart of account (indeed https://bugs.tryton.org/issue7150 already prove it). > - I read about the idea to do a basic module with a simple data and > remove extra data that need medium/big companies. Correct? This is the usual Tryton way. General usage is standard and specific module for extended usage. -- Cédric Krier - B2CK SPRL Email/Jabber: cedric.kr...@b2ck.com Tel: +32 472 54 46 59 Website: http://www.b2ck.com/ -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "tryton" group. To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/tryton/20180321113704.GG3935%40kei.
