Much closer, though the size of the rendered view still differs which affects performance quite a bit. If I scrunch the window until they are same size, there is very little difference on my machine:
- Away3D give 33 fps - Flare3D gives 30-31 fps I know you say in the text you fixed the viewport sizes to be same, but they're just not in my IE view of the demos. Cheers, BW On Tue, Jan 11, 2011 at 12:54 PM, Michael Iv <[email protected]> wrote: > Updated test for Away3D and Flare3D > > > http://blog.alladvanced.net/2011/01/11/speed-test-comparison-between-away3d-and-flare3d-reloaded/ > > Feel free to criticize guys (but just give me a favor ,forget the grammar > stuff ) > > > On Tue, Jan 11, 2011 at 5:01 PM, Michael Iv <[email protected]> wrote: > >> No problem Pete .I like critic as it helps to improve. However I am going >> to rewrite the article especially the flash examples to give a better >> benchmark.(Should stop coding at nights ... :) >> >> >> On Tue, Jan 11, 2011 at 4:15 PM, Peter Kapelyan <[email protected]>wrote: >> >>> Hey Bob and abowman, thanks for that, it really made my day :) >>> >>> Michael you are right, and I apologize, I didn't mean to be so harsh and >>> critical (it's my nature). I got jealous+defensive, sort of like my >>> girlfriend :) And, in America you'll find THE worst slaughter of the English >>> language you can find. Because you are a pro, and the subject matter is >>> technical, I don't think it would have mattered if it was written in Hebrew >>> or any other language. Take a look at http://blog.r3c7.net/ for >>> instance, probably the best blog about flash 3d that exists, even if I can't >>> read a single word. >>> >>> And finally, thank you for sharing the info! Not many people at all on >>> this earth could have done a better job. >>> >>> -Pete >>> >>> >>> On Tue, Jan 11, 2011 at 6:08 AM, Michael Iv <[email protected]>wrote: >>> >>>> I absolutely agree with you Greg ,but it has nothing to do with the >>>> language and a grammar issue.Also I still believe that Away3D is the best >>>> not only among open source engines. AwayLite was not tested as I personally >>>> believe it would be unfair as it is light weight engine with lots of >>>> features striped out from it. Flare3D is pretty stuffed just like Away3D >>>> (although in terms of the toolbox versatility Away still wins) therefore >>>> the test was against the regular Away 3.6.1 Also I suppose you can guess >>>> without testing that AwayLite will take over because the performance gain >>>> of >>>> FLARE in comparison to Away3D is not that significant so far . >>>> >>>> Best regards, >>>> Michael >>>> >>>> >>>> On Tue, Jan 11, 2011 at 12:57 PM, Greg209 <[email protected]>wrote: >>>> >>>>> The two views definitely render differently so cannot be representative >>>>> are a true benchmark. Both need to render exactly the same. I wouldn't >>>>> say a >>>>> fixed view is ideal but would prefer the camera to travel around the scene >>>>> on a fixed path to show performance with high poly counts and low. >>>>> >>>>> A longer term graph of FPS may also be more useful as a comparison >>>>> rather than a fluctuating counter + average fps. >>>>> >>>>> I certainly think benchmarks are very useful in the decision of which >>>>> engine to choose but there are so many other factors including the open >>>>> source aspect and the support give from the team behind the product. I >>>>> can't >>>>> speak for Flare3D but Away3D certainly has that team and support. >>>>> >>>>> As you can see from the reaction of people so far, providing a >>>>> benchmarking example is going to be open to a lot of criticism as people >>>>> try >>>>> to defend their favored product - which is only natural, but also try to >>>>> highlight problems/inconsistency, etc to prove/disprove the validity of >>>>> the >>>>> benchmark. >>>>> >>>>> You may also want (if you plan to evolve this) do a feature comparison >>>>> - Away3Dlite or other engines, could then be included in the comparison. >>>>> >>>>> To sum it up, I think a benchmark is useful tool to have, but in this >>>>> case it doesn't - yet - hit the mark and still requires work. >>>>> >>>>> Greg >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> -- >>>> Michael Ivanov ,Programmer >>>> Neurotech Solutions Ltd. >>>> Flex|Air |3D|Unity| >>>> www.neurotechresearch.com >>>> http://blog.alladvanced.net >>>> Tel:054-4962254 >>>> [email protected] >>>> [email protected] >>>> >>>> >>> >>> >>> -- >>> ___________________ >>> >>> Actionscript 3.0 Flash 3D Graphics Engine >>> >>> HTTP://AWAY3D.COM <http://away3d.com/> >>> >> >> >> >> -- >> Michael Ivanov ,Programmer >> Neurotech Solutions Ltd. >> Flex|Air |3D|Unity| >> www.neurotechresearch.com >> http://blog.alladvanced.net >> Tel:054-4962254 >> [email protected] >> [email protected] >> >> > > > -- > Michael Ivanov ,Programmer > Neurotech Solutions Ltd. > Flex|Air |3D|Unity| > www.neurotechresearch.com > http://blog.alladvanced.net > Tel:054-4962254 > [email protected] > [email protected] > >
