On Mon, Jul 4, 2011 at 2:15 PM, Constantine Pseudonymous
<bsor...@gmail.com> wrote:
> Rex, I think your onto something here.... let me add a little
> critique:
> "1.  Explanation is subordinate to description.
>  2.  Description is subordinate to observation.
>  3.  Observation is subordinate to experience.
>  4.  And now we want to close the circle by explaining experience."
> you distinguish between observation and experience? nonsense.

I’m using “observation” as the term for particular instances or
aspects of experience.

So, no, I don’t actually distinguish between observation and
experience in any significant way.

> "However, our explanation of experience can only be justified by
> appeal  to experience - plus reason."
> Before jumping to explanation of experience you might want to hang out
> at the problem of description of experience.... which is an element of
> experience itself, or in so far as it is possible, a tautology.  Does
> any such description of experience exist?

I can describe my experience to you in terms of fundamental concepts
which I possess - but unless you have access to those same concepts,
then my description won’t make any sense to you.

> you assume there is in existence any such explanation of experience or
> existence.
> show me one explanation of experience. even if it existed it would be
> a mere feature of experience.

I don’t assume that there is any sort of "ultimate" explanation for
experience.  In fact, I assume that there is not.

> Do you believe in a objective world or totality? Do you believe in an
> objective experience of experience-description? Do you believe in a
> objective reality, universal and totalizing, that can represent itself
> as such?

I believe that conscious experience exists, fundamentally and uncaused.

> "And there’s just the general question of what “reason” means in a
>  deterministic world, or a probabilistic world, or a purely contingent
> world."
> Or how about a world which is a vague approximation of all three and
> more.

And more?  What is this “more” to which you refer?


You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"Everything List" group.
To post to this group, send email to everything-list@googlegroups.com.
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
For more options, visit this group at 

Reply via email to