Am 16.09.2016 um 20:46 schrieb Thad Guidry:
> Daniel,
> 
> I wasn't trying to help solve the issues - I'll be quite now :)
> 
> ​I was helping to expose one of your test cases :)​

Ha, sorry for sounding harsh, and thanks for pointing me to "product"! It's a
good test case indeed.

> 'product' is a lexeme - a headword - a basic unit of meaning that has a 'set 
> of
> forms' and those have 'a set of definitions'

In the current model, a Lexeme has forms and senses. Forms don't have senses
directly, the meanings should apply to all forms. This means lexemes have to be
split with higher granularity:

* product (English noun) would be one lexeme, with "products" being the plural
form, and "product's" the genitive, and "products'" the plural genitive. Sense
include the ones you mentioned.
* (to) produce (English verb) would be another lexeme, with forms like
"produces", "produced", "producing", etc, and senses meaning "to create", "to
show", "to make available", etc
* production (English noun) would be another lexeme, with other forms and 
senses.
* produce (English noun) would be another
* producer (English noun) would be another
* produced (English adjective) another
etc...

These lexemes can be linked using some kind of "derived from" statements.

> ​But a thought just occured to me...
> A. In order to model this perhaps would be to have those headwords stored in
> Wikidata.  Those headwords ideally would not actually be a Q or a P ... but 
> what
> about instead ... L​  ?  Wrapping the graph structure itself ?  Pros / Cons ?

That's the plan, yes: Have lexemes (L...) on wikidata, which wrap the structure
of forms and senses, and has statements for the lexeme, as well as for each form
and each sense.

We don't currently plan a "super-structure" for wrapping derived/related lexemse
(product, produce, production, etc). They would just be inter-linked by 
statements.

> B.  or do we go with Daniel's suggestion of linking out to headwords and not
> actually storing them in Wikidata ?  Pros / Cons ?

The link I suggest is between items (Q...) and lexemes (L...), both on Wikidata.

-- 
Daniel Kinzler
Senior Software Developer

Wikimedia Deutschland
Gesellschaft zur Förderung Freien Wissens e.V.

_______________________________________________
Wikidata mailing list
Wikidata@lists.wikimedia.org
https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikidata

Reply via email to