On 9/11/2012 1:25 PM, Bruno Marchal wrote:
On 11 Sep 2012, at 13:33, Alberto G. Corona wrote:
The idea of looking for a spatio-temporal location of the mental (or
soul) categories in the brain is wrong IHMO, and it is surprising to
heart this from you Roger. Brain localization of mental functions is
like trying to locate physically the spell checker of a word
processor in the hardware of a personal computer. The spell checker
uses most of the hardware.
But there are low level computer functions that are physically
located, such are the floating point unit, the memory transfer unit
etc. There are a parallelism in the brain: IHMO there is a
confusion between very specialized functions, like sensory
processing, which are localized for reasons of processing efficiency
and wider, higuer level functions like the self, which are not
subject to this restriction. As far as i know, the amygdala is part
of these efficiency-constrained parts of the brain. For this reason
it is almost a separate organ. It is in charge of early processing
of sensory data to trigger rapid responses before they are
You can't locate the first person mind, but you can locate relatively
to you the 3p modules responsible for the relative (to you)
manifestation of that mind.
In fine, that local 3p is only an 1p-plural due to the 1p
indeterminacy on all the arithmetical realization of those
manifestation, so the "exact 3p picture" is more complex, and involves
infinities of computations.
Could the 3p be defined as a closed and open (clopen) set of many
1p's, where each 1p is the intersection (or somethign similar) of an
infinity of computations?
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"Everything List" group.
To post to this group, send email to email@example.com.
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
For more options, visit this group at