Re: Passage in ADJ

2003-07-21 Thread Susan Maneck
Dear David, I think the passage is urging us to integrate new believers into our community. I don't think the 'introducing' part was meant to be taken literally. And you are correct that the present focus is on integrating even seekers into our community life as early as is feasible. However I thi

Re: eScribe

2003-07-21 Thread Susan Maneck
Dear Mark, If it is permantly down does this mean all our archives are gone? warmest, Susan -- You are subscribed to Baha'i Studies as: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Baha'i Studies is available through the following: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] http://list.jccc.net/cgi-bin/lyris.pl?enter=ba

Prayer as Remembrance

2003-07-21 Thread Susan Maneck
Dear friends, Continuing on with my review of the articles in *Reason and Revelation* would now like to discuss Christopher White's article "Prayer as Remembrance." warmest, Susan Christopher White's article "Prayer as Remembrance" is perhaps more of an inspirational and reflective piece than an

Re: KELLY SOUGHT SOLACE IN BAHA'I FAITH

2003-07-21 Thread Susan Maneck
> Does anyone know how active David Kelly was in the Faith? I notice > references to him being a pacifist, and attending meetings of a pacifist > group on a regular basis. Did he realize that pacifism is not something > Baha'is believe in? Dear David, David Kelly had only been a Baha'i for a fe

Scripture as literature

2003-07-22 Thread Susan Maneck
Continuing on with my review of Reason and Revelation: Perhaps the richest essay in this collection is Frank Lewis' "Scripture as Literature." Dr. Lewis argues that understanding the background of many of the literary genre found in the Baha'i Writings can contribute immensely to our knowledge of

Fundamentalism and Liberalism

2003-07-23 Thread Susan Maneck
This continues my review of articles from Reason and Revelation. Moojan's article can be found online here: http://www.breacais.demon.co.uk/BSR/Articles/2_Momen_Fundamentalism.htm Moojan Momen's article "Fundamentalism and Liberalism" argues that these two different approaches to religious questio

Quinn and Buck's articles

2003-07-26 Thread Susan Maneck
Dear friends, Continuing on with my review of the book Reason and Revelation, this time I am treating two article's together, Sholeh Quinn's article "The End of History?" and Chistopher Buck's article regarding Native American Manifestations. I think it will be clear why I'm placing those together

Re: Fundamentalism and Liberalism

2003-07-26 Thread Susan Maneck
> The problem I have with this paper and most others on the subject is the > assumption that fundamentalism is a pole with liberalism at the other > end. Dear Don, That's why I proposed Fowlers's Stages of Faith as an alternative paradigm. In that paradigm *both* liberals and fundamentalist would

Re: spiritual winter

2003-07-26 Thread Susan Maneck
> Why then will future Manifestations come? So women can sit on the Universal House of Justice? -- You are subscribed to Baha'i Studies as: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] To unsubscribe send a blank email to mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Baha'i Studies is available through the following: mailto:

Re: Baha'i courtship

2003-07-27 Thread Susan Maneck
Dear David, Since I don't think there is anything in the Writings on this topic, I'm not sure what any of us could say beyond expressing our personal opinion. It sounds like it is more of a topic for Baha'i-Discuss than Baha'i Studies which is focused on issues related to scholarship. warmest, Su

Re: Fundamentalism and Liberalism

2003-07-27 Thread Susan Maneck
> What you seem to be implying is that if fundamentalists would 'grow up', > they would become liberals. I think there is a fair amount of research > that bears on this issue. As people grow up, mature in their experience > and thinking, they tend to become more conservative and relativistic. De

bahai-st@list.jccc.net

2003-07-27 Thread Susan Maneck
Bryan Graham's article "Baha'i Approaches to Economics" surveys some of the secondary Baha'i literature on the Baha'i Faith and economics. It seems strange in this context, that the author ignored those articles which dealt with Marxism and the Baha'i Faith until we realize that the Graham's conce

Re: Baha'i courtship

2003-07-27 Thread Susan Maneck
> Point taken. I guess the problem is that I don't know for sure what is in > the Writings. I may overlook passages that explicitly answer a question. Dear David, Then perhaps the best approach would be to simply ask if there is anything in the Writings specifically on the topic of courtship. W

Re: Baha'i courtship

2003-07-27 Thread Susan Maneck
> Susan, > aren't Baha'i studies essentially about the dialogue between > contemporary society and the Baha'i teachings?. Dear Owen, That is not the purpose of this list. As our guidelines state: "The purpose of this list is to promote scholarship, in particular academic scholarship, on the Baha

Re: Question

2003-07-27 Thread Susan Maneck
While I have no interest in finding out the reason, I > find the action curious, for the reason that the House removed him from the > NSA but did not deprive him of his voting rights. I would have thought that > if a person were removed from an NSA deprivation of voting rights would go > along wi

Re: Declaration of Baha'u'llah

2003-07-28 Thread Susan Maneck
> > I'm just wondering if historians have got any further in penetrating the > obscurity since Shoghi Effendi wrote. Dear David, Ismael Velasco wrote a very nice post on the current stage of scholarship on this topic entitled Reconstructing Ridvan a few years ago. Unfortunately it is on my other

List Guidelines

2003-07-28 Thread Susan Maneck
> Susan, I hadn't seen those guidelines. > Owen It doesn't hurt to post them. Usually they are sent out when someone subscribes: *List Guidelines* 1. Consultation, tolerance, and courtesy are encouraged. All list members have a right to be treated respectfully, regardless of their level of edu

Re: List Guidelines

2003-07-29 Thread Susan Maneck
> It's good of you to repost the list rules, Susan, especially as you > yourself often post in html rich-text. (I'm sure inadvertently.) > Dear Alex, My server is set up to send things out in plain text. However, if the person I am responding to uses Rich-text it will sometimes respond in the sam

Capitalism

2003-07-29 Thread Susan Maneck
Dear friends, I understand there is a letter from the Universal House of Justice which contains a very strong critique against capitalism. It was written sometime after the Promise of World Peace. Does anyone know where this letter can be located? warmest, Susan -- You are subscribed to

Re: Capitalism

2003-07-29 Thread Susan Maneck
> > It could be THE PROSPERITY OF HUMANKIND No, this wasn't one of their major statements, it was a letter written to some Baha'i economists who had questioned the House's critique of capitalism in the Promise of World Peace. warmest, Susan -- You are subscribed to Baha'i Studies as:

Re: Review of Sen's article on theocracy

2003-08-04 Thread Susan Maneck
Dear Steve, I can't seem to make that link work. BTW folks, I've been gone all week so it make take me awhile to catch up on all your email. warmest, Susan -- You are subscribed to Baha'i Studies as: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] To unsubscribe send a blank email to mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: Mary in Rome?

2003-08-05 Thread Susan Maneck
> I'm just wondering where 'Abdu'l-Baha might be getting the idea that Mary > Magdalene went to Rome. Is this in any tradition, or is this a matter of > divine Revelation? Dear David, It is a part of church tradition: "Holy Tradition testifies, that when the Apostles departed from Jerusalem for

Re: Last names

2003-08-05 Thread Susan Maneck
> I'm just wondering if there is anything in the Faith, like perhaps a letter, > bearing on the issue of what name to take when one marries. Not to my knowledge, nor do I think there should be. This is a purely cultural issue. Most women in most cultures keep their surnames after they marry. --

Re: Anything new on the House and women question?

2003-08-05 Thread Susan Maneck
When I spoke to a > Counsellor as to what I could say if asked about the composition of the > House of Justice he said to say that we don't know, but that membership on > the House of Justice is not a spiritual but administrative station. Dear David, But most religions have affirmed women's spi

Re: Anything new on the House and women question?

2003-08-05 Thread Susan Maneck
If you can get a hold of JA and PJ Khan's > Advancement of Women: A Baha'i Perspective, pp.122-134 is the longest > "official" discussion yet published. Dear Steve, I don't think we should regard something written by an individual member of the House has 'official.' When he writes a book of this

Re: Anything new on the House and women question?

2003-08-05 Thread Susan Maneck
> Yes, women do not serve on the Universal House of Justice (they do vote for > it's members), Dear Patti That was true of *all* Baha'i administrative institutions in Iran until 1954. but as 'Abdu'l-Baha writes (more of the quote is included > below)--"There is Divine wisdom in this which will

Re: Pamphlet for Christians i have not seen it

2003-08-06 Thread Susan Maneck
" This "once removed" connection keeps the reader engaged and challenged, without as much risk of offense." Thanks, Khazeh. I didn't mean to imply the comic book was offensive like Chic comic books, only that it used the same kinds of graphics as Jack Chic comics do. Obviously, the content of th

Re: Anything new on the House and women question?

2003-08-06 Thread Susan Maneck
"I suppose it would be poetic justice if males were to be exempted/excluded from service on the Baha'i world's future Executive Body. And there is support in the reported sayings of 'Abdu'l-Baha for the superiority of women in governing. Just a thought." Dear Vaughn, I think it was once suggest

Re: Review of Sen's article on theocracy

2003-08-07 Thread Susan Maneck
> I thought I'd take this opportunity to ask if there is some way one can stop > receving messages while still be subscribed to this list. Yes, if you go to the website you will find a 'no-mail' option. You can then read the mail from the archives and post as you wish, but you won't receive anythi

Re: Help finding a quote

2003-08-08 Thread Susan Maneck
"Then why not two single women or two single men, since single parents are often at a financial disadvantage and have trouble finding adult supervision of their children so they can sometimes get away?" Dear Marlene, I certainly don't have any problem with it, though I think preference should be

Re: Help finding a quote

2003-08-08 Thread Susan Maneck
> As I said, I cannot remember the wording specific enough as to whether > it was "adoption" or "raising" children. The reason this so stuck in my > mind was that it seemed to permit two people of the same sex to raise > children together. Dear Marlene, Mothers and grandmothers do this tog

Re: Source of paragraph

2003-08-09 Thread Susan Maneck
"Thanks. Does that mean it has the same status as a pilgrim note?" Yes. Baha'i Scriptures included Pilgrim's Notes which is why Shoghi Effendi did not wholly approve of the volume. warmest, Susan -- You are subscribed to Baha'i Studies as: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] To unsubscribe send a

Re: Nabi and Rasul

2003-08-10 Thread Susan Maneck
> > Hello, Susan. > O.K. My point, which may have been obvious from my previous post, > is that if Baha'u'llah was neither Nabi nor Rasul, if He was of a different > category, Dear Timothy, Perhaps but I wouldn't conclude that simply because Baha'u'llah didn't apply these terms to Himself. N

Re: Sears and Isaiah 53

2003-08-11 Thread Susan Maneck
Dear David, I think Isaiah 53 applies to most of the Manifestations. But Thief in the Night is a very dated book. There are much better ones such as those by Michael Sours or Gary Matthews for introducing the Faith to Christians. warmest, Susan -- You are subscribed to Baha'i Studies as

Re: Buddhism and prayer

2003-08-11 Thread Susan Maneck
> There was a book called, " The God of Budddha " published in the 1980's. > Never obtained a copy myself but read a copy of a friend and I seem to > remember reference to 'the unborn one', or 'uncreated one'. Dear Owen, The reference is to an unborn, an uncreated. No mention of a 'one.' They d

Re: Rebuilding of Jerusalem

2003-08-11 Thread Susan Maneck
> It might be interesting if anyone knows a source for the interpretations > which started the Seventh Day Adventist Church to await the coming of > christ in 1844. Dear Owen, Stricly speaking the Adventist church grew out of the disappointment of 1844. It was a break-off from the Millerite move

Re: Allah the Christian God

2003-08-11 Thread Susan Maneck
> She points out that al-Lah was the main god > before the time of Muhammad. His holy place > was at the Ka'aba. al-Lah had three daughters > (banat al-Lah) > who each had a holy place as well. Dear Tom, The Arab religion appears to have been derived from Mesopotamia where the High God (the God

Re: Anything new on the House and women question?

2003-08-14 Thread Susan Maneck
> On what in the Baha'i Writings is based the prediction "When the Supreme > Tribunal merges with the House of Justice"? Dear Vaugn, It is based on a letter written on behalf of the Guardian. > > Also, I wonder if there are several possible interpretations of "merge", > assuming this word occurs

Re: Anything new on the House and women question?

2003-08-14 Thread Susan Maneck
Dear Owen, I'm not suggesting that women can't get justice within the Baha'i system because men are at the top. I am suggesting that having men only at the top does have an important symbolic significance that can be disempowering to women in other respects. I don't find the assertion that service

Re: Buddhism and prayer

2003-08-14 Thread Susan Maneck
> > Since most Buddhists don't believe in God, or that Buddha talked about God, > who are they praying to? Or is it just a personal development strategy? Usually a form of the Buddha. -- You are subscribed to Baha'i Studies as: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] To unsubscribe send a blank email

Re: Self-praise

2003-08-14 Thread Susan Maneck
> Self-praise is seen as a bad thing in the Baha'i Faith. We are to praise > others, but not ourselves. Dear David, I think before we can have much of a discussion of this issue we need to look at the Writings involved. What is your assertion above based on? warmest, Susan -- You are

Re: Capitalism

2003-08-14 Thread Susan Maneck
> It is in Century of Light. > Rich > Dear Rich, No, I'm thinking of a letter written by the House in answer to some specific individuals objections to their anti-capitalistic stance. warmest, Susan -- You are subscribed to Baha'i Studies as: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] To unsubscribe

Re: Children of early Baha'is

2003-08-14 Thread Susan Maneck
> I would like to know if any of the American or European Baha'is of > Abdu'l Baha's era had children who were also Baha'is. I'm thinking of > Thornton Chase, Lua Getsinger, Howard MacNutt, Charles Greenleaf, > Arthur Dodge, Isabella Brittingham, Fred Mortensen, John Esslemont, > Robert Turner

Re: Pamphlet for Christians

2003-08-14 Thread Susan Maneck
" It is a Baha'i comic but it really looks (outwardly) like something done by Jehovah's Witnesses.  It has all these apocalyptic images in it and one of the main characters features this huge gold cross around his neck."   Dear Matt,   It reminds me more of those Chic comic books produced by

Re: Mary in Rome?

2003-08-14 Thread Susan Maneck
> From comments you make later evidently you find some of this stuff quite > reliable historically. Dear David, It may or may not be. My point is simply that 'Abdu'l-Baha doesn't pick this kind of thing out of the air. I'm quite well informed regarding documents within > two centuries of Jesus'

Re: Allah the Christian God

2003-08-14 Thread Susan Maneck
> For centuries Arab Christians have been praying in the Basilica of the > Nativity in Bethlehem, and the Basilica of the Annunciation in Nazareth. > My question is, haven't they -- Catholics and other Christian > denominations -- been calling on God with the Arabic word "Allah?" Aren't > they doi

Re: Allah the Christian God

2003-08-14 Thread Susan Maneck
  My understanding is that al-Lah was at one point one of many gods,   Dear Tom, Al is a direct article while lah is a generic term for God. But so is el.   warnest, Susan -- You are subscribed to Baha'i Studies as: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] To uns

Re: Buddhism and prayer

2003-08-14 Thread Susan Maneck
"The traditions established the fact that in all Dispensations the law of prayer hath constituted a fundamental element of the Revelation of all the Prophets of God-- a law the form and the manner of which hath been adapted to the varying requirements of every age." (Baha'u'llah, Kitab-i-Iqan, Wr

Re: Letter and Spirit of Laws Concerning Personal Devotions

2003-08-14 Thread Susan Maneck
> Yes, I know about using fingers to count, and I do have > a beautiful set of prayer beads my wife made for me. > Even with those, counting is sometimes distracting. Dear Timothy, I'm not sure I understand.The whole purpose of prayer beads is so you don't have to count, you just finger the b

Re: Nabi and Rasul

2003-08-14 Thread Susan Maneck
> As I understand it, the Quran refers to minor Prophets as Nabi (warner), > and Prophets who bring a book as Rasul. Isaiah and Daniel are examples of > Nabi, > while Moses, Jesus and Muhammad are Rasul. Dear Timothy, I wouldn't get too hung up with these categories. They refer to functions,

Re: Spiritual disease

2003-08-14 Thread Susan Maneck
> "Of course I cannot ut agree with its proofs and evidences." > > should read > **Of course I cannot but agree with its proofs and evidences.** I was trying to figure out what you were disagreeing with. ;-} -- You are subscribed to Baha'i Studies as: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] To unsubs

Re: Anything new on the House and women question?

2003-08-14 Thread Susan Maneck
"Am I understanding correctly that you are expressing a -greater concern- that women would not be in a position of authority to determine the process of weaving the social fabric of the future human society? Or put another way... participation without representation??" Dear Samdra, Not exactly.

Re: Ownership in http://bahaistudies.net/momentum.html

2003-08-14 Thread Susan Maneck
***A high degree of enthusiasm and a strong sense of ownership are also characteristics of clusters ready to embark on an intensive program of growth. *** More or less I can recognize enthusiasm but what does *ownership* refer to? Dear Khazeh, "Ownership" in this context means that we take person

Re: Anything new on the House and women question?

2003-08-14 Thread Susan Maneck
> Since you are the second person who has called me up on this, evidently I > was unclear. I mean that in light of everything in the Writings the > exclusion of women *should not* be a big deal. It is, though. > Dear David, I think the reason it is two-fold. 1) Since we are talking about the *

Re: Help finding a quote

2003-08-14 Thread Susan Maneck
> I can swear I remember a letter written by Shoghi Effendi or written on > his behalf that said something to the effect that if two people wished > to enter into some kind of an agreement involving the adoption or > raising of children that it was permissible. Or could it have been > 'Abdu'l-Baha

Re: Children of early Baha'is

2003-08-14 Thread Susan Maneck
Both Lua Getsinger and > Ethel Rosenberg remained single Whoops, I was thinking of Juliet Thompson. ;-}I'm pretty sure Lua didn't have any children either. There was a nephew who subsequently became a Knight of Baha'u'llah. warmest, Susan -- You are subscribed to Baha'i Studies as: mail

Re: Question

2003-08-14 Thread Susan Maneck
Dear David, Can I ask you to create subject headings which reflect the specific question you are raising. Simply putting up 'question' isn't much help in tracing threads. warmest, Susan -- You are subscribed to Baha'i Studies as: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] To unsubscribe send a blank emai

Re: Anything new on the House and women question?

2003-08-14 Thread Susan Maneck
That's a > doctrinal issue, and even Shoghi Effendi didn't try to provide an > explanation when asked, so I wouldn't expect the House to do more. Dear David, It is more an issue of Baha'i law than doctrine. But it is primarily 'Abdu'l-Baha who didn't give us much of an explanation to go on. I

Re: Anything new on the House and women question?

2003-08-14 Thread Susan Maneck
> No, I mean 'properly' published in a book, visible to the bahai community if > nothing else,as opposed to unpublished conference presentations, photocopied > notes mailed all over the world or internet musings and such like. That is > precisely why I quoted the word 'official' to avoid your very

Re: men and sex outside of marriage

2003-08-16 Thread Susan Maneck
> Any behavior or action by a woman which she knows is likely to elicit > a sexual response by a man who is not her husband is, in my opinion, > sexual activity outside marriage and therefore prohibited under Baha'i > law. Too many women seem to believe that it is not sexual until a man > makes hi

Re: men and sex outside of marriage

2003-08-16 Thread Susan Maneck
> I didn't say "whatever *might*", I said "knows is likely". There's a > big difference. Dear Don, Such things are culturally determined. In the Islamic world not being fully covered is likely to arouse a man. Yet for women to restrict themselves this way has been clearly detrimental to their d

Re: men and sex outside of marriage

2003-08-16 Thread Susan Maneck
> Isn't there something in the Writings about that? ;-) " And if he met the fairest and most comely of women, he would not feel his heart seduced by the least shadow of desire for her beauty. Such an one, indeed, is the creation of spotless chastity. Thus instructeth you the Pen of the Ancient of

Re: Questions

2003-08-16 Thread Susan Maneck
> > 2. Shoghi Effendi wrote: > > "Masturbation is clearly not a proper use of the sex instinct, as this is > understood in the Faith. Moreover it involves, as you have pointed out, > mental fantasies, while Baha'u'llah, in the Kitab-i-Aqdas, has exhorted us > not to indulge our passions and in on

Re: ABS Executive Commmittee

2003-08-17 Thread Susan Maneck
> > I have only attended a couple of the annual meetings of the ABS in Canada, > but in both cases only members of the Association could vote or be voted > for in the election of the executive. Dear David, My understanding is that the members of the Executive Committee are appointed by the Canadi

Re: Questions: masturbation

2003-08-17 Thread Susan Maneck
> Please don't keep us in suspense. What did the Bab say? Do you have a > quote? Dear Marlene, It's a provisional translation. "God forgiveth you your nocturnal emissions and masturbation. But know ye the value of your seed, for your seed is the cause of the creation of one who worshippet

Re: men and sex outside of marriage

2003-08-17 Thread Susan Maneck
What do we > propose next, banning all PG-14 movies? Most definitely. Can't have PG-14 movies. ;-} -- You are subscribed to Baha'i Studies as: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] To unsubscribe send a blank email to mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Baha'i Studies is available through the following: mailto:

Re: Questions: masturbation

2003-08-18 Thread Susan Maneck
"By "the exquisite place" could the Bab possibly have been referring to a specific part of the female anatomy, in which the "seed" might bear fruit?"   Uh, that's not the place I had in mind.  -- You are subscribed to Baha'i Studies as: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] To unsubscribe send a

Re: ABS Executive Commmittee

2003-08-18 Thread Susan Maneck
> What exactly do they seem to be looking for in making the appointments? And > why is it just the Canadian NSA who makes the appointments? Because they > have less work than the US NSA? Has anyone on this list been on the > Executive Committee before? Dear David, Canada started the ABS and wh

Re: The Studies list losing focus

2003-08-19 Thread Susan Maneck
"I swear by God and I say this most solemnly. you are losing focus by discussing so much on sex and matters related to sex." I have to agree with Khazeh here. We do seem to losing our focus. warmest, Susan -- You are subscribed to Baha'i Studies as: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] To unsubsc

Re: Ruhi book 2

2003-08-20 Thread Susan Maneck
Dear David, If you make your posts a little more succinct, I think you will find they are more likely to be read. Usually you give us more detail than we need. However, in this portion you didn't explain yourself: > After this I found the material fine for some time. Section 4, question 5 > was

Re: Four poisons

2003-08-20 Thread Susan Maneck
> What concerned me was the almost Calvinist tone this discussion was taking on. > Who wears what, and when ? I also don't think this list is an appropriate forum > for this discussion. Dear Rich, That was one problem. I think the other problem is that we were getting blow by blow accounts of

Re: Prayer on paper

2003-08-23 Thread Susan Maneck
> "O Lord, Thou hast ordained the family to be the basic social unit. Dear Larry, Somehow this doesn't sound like 'Abdu'l-Baha to me. warmest, Susan -- You are subscribed to Baha'i Studies as: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] To unsubscribe send a blank email to mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Baha'

Re: Kingship

2003-08-24 Thread Susan Maneck
What I would like to know > is whether, when the world is Baha'i, such titles will still be used for > kings. Dear David, I know of nothing in the Writings that explicitly indicates that there won't be. Surely a title such as "Your Eminence," in capitals no less, would > denote superiority of

Re: Conferred Infallibility of the House of Justice

2003-08-25 Thread Susan Maneck
The Writings endow the Universal House of Justice > with "legislative, executive and judicial powers." (The Universal House of > Justice, "Constitution of the Universal House of Justice," p. 8) Dear Brent, You state the "Writings" bestow the House of Justice with these powers but what you quote

Re: Conferred Infallibility of the House of Justice

2003-08-25 Thread Susan Maneck
> That is, each word of > the Constitution describing a power of the House rests squarely on a verse > in the Writings. Dear Brent, Where does it say that? > I am really not sure what the intent of your post was. Well, as you know I am very persnickety when it comes to things people say are in

Re: Conferred Infallibility of the House of Justice

2003-08-25 Thread Susan Maneck
"Yes, but, in a decentralised 3 level federal system its not hard to imagine that one can have a world level legislative institution whose legal will is principally executed/administered by the national units. Likewise the National legislative institution exe

Re: Conferred Infallibility of the House of Justice

2003-08-25 Thread Susan Maneck
"The believer having the responsibility to obey. As this obedience is not blind, (as the statements of the Administrative Order by Shoghi Effendi recognises), but an obedience that comes from our own personal love of God, from our covenant with God, then a spiritual dynamic is created in which beli

Re: Lamps before the Throne

2003-08-25 Thread Susan Maneck
 ""24 seats" 19 Letters of the LIving, the Bab, Siyyid Kazim, Sheikh Amad, and what two others?"   Vakil ul-Dawlih, was another one, the final one has yet to be identified.   warmest, Susan -- You are subscribed to Baha'i Studies as: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] To unsubscribe send a bla

Re: Conferred Infallibility of the House of Justice

2003-08-27 Thread Susan Maneck
> Blind obedience is when there is no attempt to understand the processes > behind a ruling or a law. Dear Owen, The reason I asked is that you indicated that it wasn't blind obedience because it comes from the love of God. That's not the same as attempting to understand the processes behind a

The Passing of Vinson Jamir

2003-08-27 Thread Susan Maneck
Dear friends, I am saddened to announce the passing of Vinson Jamir who was an active participant on this list a couple of years ago. Please remember him and his family in your prayers. warmest, Susan NORTH AUGUSTA, S.C. -Funeral services for Mr. Vinson Jamir, 52, of Audubon Circle, North August

Re: Conferred Infallibility of the House of Justice

2003-08-30 Thread Susan Maneck
Dear Brent, Oridinarily I would agree with you about the weakness of utilizing a pilgrim's note. But in this case the pilgrim's note in question merely elucidates what the Will and Testament itself said regarding the the fact that the legislative powers of the House of Justice were different from

Fw: Beings and existents

2003-09-02 Thread Susan Maneck
- Original Message - From: "Gary L. Matthews" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "Bridges" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Cc: "Translation" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "Bridges" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "Dr. Khazeh Fananapazir" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "Joyce Maneck" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "Nizam & Joyce Maneck" <[EMAIL PROTECT

Re: Revival and Decline

2003-09-03 Thread Susan Maneck
And in New > Mexico, the violent crime rate is actually still *10 times* what it > was in 1960, tho down about 10% from its peak in the late 90's. > Brent perception of what's going on in his area is correct. Dear Don, But Brent it talking about an increase in the last two or three years. You are

Re: What to do?

2003-09-03 Thread Susan Maneck
> I would like to raise an issue I have been thinking about for some time, > which is whether we can do anything about the major problems that can be > seen in many Baha'i young people (pre-youth and youth) today. Dear David, I think this would be a more appropriate topic for Baha'i Discuss. Th

Re: Revival and Decline

2003-09-04 Thread Susan Maneck
> And these days, TV doesn't pass the smell test. What passes for garments > for teenagers these days don't, either. Evidence? It's all around. Dear Brent, My observation is that neither TV or clothing is all that worse than when you and I were young. The cartoons were certainly more violent t

Re: Revival and Decline

2003-09-04 Thread Susan Maneck
My > former consitutional law professor, Justice Anthony Kennedy now on the US > Supreme Court (then on the 9th Circuit with Dorothy Nelson), a devoted > Catholic, a man highly sensitive to the impact of a statement of a justice > in a formal opinion, has just opened the door to homosexual marriage

Fw: Fw: Quinn and Buck's articles

2003-09-04 Thread Susan Maneck
- Original Message - From: "Dr. Christopher Buck" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "Susan Maneck" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Cc: "William Collins" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "Sholeh A Quinn" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Thursday, September 04, 20

Re: Fw: Quinn and Buck's articles

2003-09-04 Thread Susan Maneck
> "Buck concludes his essay by arguing that while it may not be possible > to add specific names to the list of officially acknowledged prophets > still Baha'i authorities might consider affirming the principle that > Messengers of God have appeared in the Americas. It strikes me that > Chris Buck

Re: Fw: Quinn and Buck's articles

2003-09-04 Thread Susan Maneck
> What does this mean in regard to the next Manifestation, who will have to > present Himself to the House of Justice? Dear David, The only thing I presume about the coming of the next Manifestation is that it won't be as we expect it. > I thought all Manifestations were supposed to come from th

Re: Fw: Quinn and Buck's articles

2003-09-04 Thread Susan Maneck
"I thought there was a passage in Gleanings which states that all of the Prophets have come from the Holy Land. Of course, this may not preclude Messengers." Dear Matt, What's the Holy Land? warmest, Susan -- You are subscribed to Baha'i Studies as: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] To unsubs

Re: Manifestations only from the east?

2003-09-05 Thread Susan Maneck
Title: Message "I think what needs to be identified in questions like this, is what is the underlying cause of both recognising and not recognising the Manaifestation of God. This is an eternal question. East - west and any prophetic aspects are related to the era that has now gone by. But t

Re: Manifestations only from the east?

2003-09-06 Thread Susan Maneck
"Perhaps the next manifestation will come from California" Just so long as She's from Santa Cruz and not LA. ;-} Oh, wait a minute Manifestations are supposed to appear in the worst places, not the best. How about San Bernardino? warmest, Susan -- You are subscribed to Baha'i Studies a

Re: Manifestations only from the east?

2003-09-06 Thread Susan Maneck
I guess, then, that if > female pronouns had been used, such would prove that the next Manifestation > would be female? Dear David, It would certainly be a strong indication. But I've never know the scriptures to make it that easy. ;-} warmest, Susan -- You are subscribed to Baha'i S

Re: Manifestations only from the east?

2003-09-06 Thread Susan Maneck
> I'm fairly sure I have heard that there is no actual term for separate > gender in Persian? Is this true? If so this could have a bearing on the > discussion? Dear Michael,. That's correct. But we have been citing texts that were written in Arabic which insists on gender. warmest, Susan

Re: Fw: Quinn and Buck's articles

2003-09-06 Thread Susan Maneck
> "THE BLESSED state of California bears the utmost similarity to the Holy > Land, that is, the country of Palestine. Dear David, Muhammad wasn't from Palestine. Niether was Zoroaster, Krishna, Buddha, the Bab or Baha'u'llah. warmest, Susan -- You are subscribed to Baha'i Studies as: m

Re: Manifestations only from the east?

2003-09-07 Thread Susan Maneck
Message "But there is a spiritual trap in the academic approach to spiritual matters, is there not?" Dear Owen, It is not a question of a 'trap.' Academic methodologies are tools that exist for specific purposes. When applied to the proper 'job' they do well. But there are certain jobs they aren'

Re: Conferred Infallibility of the House of Justice

2003-09-07 Thread Susan Maneck
> If we were to take this as an accurate statement of a limitation on the > nature and powers of the National and Universal House of Justice, how > would we reconcile this with the Guardian's statement to the US NSA about > "the relations that should be maintained between the central > administrati

Re: Fw: Quinn and Buck's articles

2003-09-07 Thread Susan Maneck
> The following authentic passage might be read to indicate that the > Manifestation has always come from the East, Dear David, Part of the problem here may be that the same word can be used in Arabic to mean Dawning-point or East. warmest, Susan -- You are subscribed to Baha'i Studies

Re: debts

2003-09-08 Thread Susan Maneck
> I remember reading a quotation by Shoghi Effendi or written on his behalf > stating that paying off one's debts comes before contributing to the Fund. > I cannot find it. Does anyone know of it? All the ones I have been able to > find are the following. Thank you, Loni Bramson Dear Loni, I th

Re: Obedience to government

2003-09-08 Thread Susan Maneck
> Further on this issue, I happened to think of how in Iran there is a secret > underground Baha'i university. Aren't the Baha'is in Iran being disobedient > to their government in having this? If they didn't feel they were being > disobedient it wouldn't be kept under wraps. Dear David, There

  1   2   >