Re: Airing of Grievances

2021-12-28 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
I was just the low life plan reviewer. Forbidden to comment. It was just obvious to me sometimes that primary design intent of plan submittal was for plans to be rejected, with goal of renegotiating price. All I could do was write a review letter and put it on hold. Then six weeks later they

Re: NFPA #30 Containment

2021-12-14 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
If project is referencing the IFC I would recommend Chapter 57, which references back to Chapter 50. If you end up at 5004.2.2.3 you come up with 20 minutes. nb room or design area text. If you were calling me as a plan reviewer working with an architect there would be a code analysis agreed

Re: Gridded dry system

2021-10-27 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
Is the dry system water delivery software capable of modeling this configuration, using a given water supply? Best. Bruce Verhei > On 10/27/2021 9:50 AM Kevin Hall via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > > If the pipe marked in red is removed and capped off, it eliminates any > split

RE: Supervised Air Manual Dry Standpipe

2021-10-21 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
I’m not familiar with NYC’s requirement. I do know FF’s hate waiting for air to discharge and they get a constant stream of water. Even flat, ostensibly dry hose has a lot of air in it. I mean the lines between the engine and the FDC. Then there’s all the air in the standpipe. Pressurize the

Re: theft of FDC inlets

2021-10-14 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
Ed, They’re not using a wrench. They’re breaking out the caps, sticking in a piece of 1-1/2” pipe, and rotating unit off. We went to the Knox product which stopped the problem. Some owners added Locktite Red, which adds its own problem if replacement is necessary. Knox passes out the key to

Re: FA not sprinkler question

2021-09-18 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
/the-mechanics-of-smartsync/1163/3 > > Hope that helps, > > John Drucker > AHJ Fire and Electrical > New Jersey USA > > John Drucker > > From: Sprinklerforum on > behalf of BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum > > Sent: Fri

Re: FA not sprinkler question

2021-09-17 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
Gas detection? To me that implies some special former tenant. Or normal CO detection? Are there natural gas fired appliances in the space? Sync. There are more than one options, somewhat dependent on age of system. By servicing, do you mean space is vacant? Unless the jurisdiction is huge

RE: Fire Pumps and fire apparatus

2021-09-15 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
ex, high flow rate sprinkler systems. > > Craig Prahl | Jacobs | Group Lead/SME – Fire Protection | > craig.pr...@jacobs.com | > https://urldefense.com/v3/__http://www.jacobs.com__;!!FaxH778!LVZMq8TRZNX9Cb6cJQT-tmZ_BW8AJajv_ms3V9-cuinINGaVZMxzwF4vfMg4K19k$ > > 1041 East Bu

RE: Back Up Fire Pump

2021-09-14 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
Apologies. I meant to note that theses were originally my comments. bv > On 09/14/2021 2:27 PM BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > > This is cut and past of partial comments from discussion on another forum, > originating from an NFSA post. > > What is m

RE: Back Up Fire Pump

2021-09-14 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
This is cut and past of partial comments from discussion on another forum, originating from an NFSA post. What is missing from this excerpt is pressure rating of the hose. At acceptance and annually FD’s test hose at 250 psi. You are quickly going to lose persuasion ability with your fire plan

Re: Transfer Switches

2021-08-27 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
Good Afternoon. I don’t know if you are doing wider fire protection or just putting wet stuff on the red stuff. Are you doing the alarm as well? We always asked for, and rec’d an ‘Of course’, to providing power to the alarm system off the EPPS. It’s a tiny draw. I would expect especially the

RE: [EXTERNAL] RE: Closets and Clearance from Deflector to Storage

2021-07-01 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
From an old fire guys perspective I’d be more concerned with accidental head breakage than water dispersal. Best. > On 07/01/2021 3:01 PM Larrimer, Peter A (HEFP\19HEF) via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > > Thanks for that clarification. I missed that. > > Pete > > -Original

RE: 36" Drop

2021-06-24 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
rable to that found in the 2016 NFPA 13? > > Thanks, > > SJ > > > -Original Message- > From: Sprinklerforum On > Behalf Of BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum > Sent: Thursday, June 24, 2021 11:12 AM > To: sprinklerforum@lists.firesprinkler.org > Cc:

RE: 36" Drop

2021-06-24 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
t; Just curious, > Did that system with "Quite a few other breaks", have bracing and other > seismic features installed, comparable to that found in the 2016 NFPA 13? > > Thanks, > > SJ > > > -Original Message- > From: Sprinklerforum On > Behalf

Re: 36" Drop

2021-06-24 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
We had lots of 15’ drops in tilt-ups to office build outs at 9-10th AFF. After Nisqually earthquake I don’t think I saw any failures. A few broken suspended ceiling tiles. Yes, a couple goosenecks did roll, but that was on ESFR, near roof level, and is another story. Quite a few other breaks.

RE: Hydrant barrel loss

2021-04-27 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
In Puget Sound area it’s rare to find a dry hydrant with individually gated ports that isn’t as old as me. I’m curious to hear why it is necessary to calculate friction loss through the hydrant. Best. Bruce V. > On 04/26/2021 6:00 PM Steve Leyton via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > > Wet

RE: [EXTERNAL] Re: Fire Pump Sprk & Fire Flow Demand

2021-04-24 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
My largest water purveyor had long had an antagonism towards fire. One day I asked why. They said it was our use of hard suctions, with resulting drawing down below design pressure at large fires. Everything in water design and maintenance is predicted on that 20 psi minimum. After denials that

RE: Standpipe Testing

2021-04-16 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
In this day and age of digital everything it’s surprising that someone doesn’t sell a hydro pump set up with any auto shut off, with a standard 205 psig and select, with relief at 210 psig. Best. Bruce V. > On 04/16/2021 4:12 PM Tom Duross via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > > Thanks Matt. >

Re: Old sprinklers

2021-04-08 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
It wouldn’t be unlikely that this was offered as an alternative to some code requirement. One-hour corridor construction, including separation? At later date it’s a done deal, unless you want to propose a new building plan review for fire and life safety. I doubt your customer wants to hire an

RE: Best Pressure Loss RPDA

2021-04-02 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
I’ve been going though in my head a small unit with low pressure loss at low flow and a large unit in parallel that’s efficient at high flow. I just can’t see a reasonable total cost. Best. Bruce Verhei > On 04/02/2021 10:57 AM Dane Long via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > > You might try

New coil actuators - New standard

2021-03-26 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
Please reference https://youtu.be/e7Vkdb9z2qc Mike H. Et al: Is this standards change typical, i.e., not intended to apply retroactively? I assume other manufacturers are putting out similar listed or marked products. Best. Bruce Verhei ___

RE: [EXTERNAL] High rise protection question

2021-03-24 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
A campus solution is not uncommon. If the requirement is the one out of the IBC/IFC, and the piping run is distal to the buildings I might ask for more in depth consideration of assurance u/g system will not damaged by the very seismic event for which it is providing back up to the municipal

Re: 4 1/2" FDC

2021-03-18 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
Before you spend your cash I’d make sure you have the correct thread standard. Best. Bruce. > On 03/18/2021 2:55 PM Skyler Bilbo via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > > Sorry, the one I sent was NST on the 4" side. This should be the correct > one. > >

Re: NFPA 13 2016 25.2.1.4.2

2021-03-18 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
I wish we used two terms. I used to call the 13-D test a ‘leak test’, instead of hydrostatic test. That’s what we really mean here. We want to see the pipe charged, and see if it leaks. A hydrostatic and a leak test aren’t really the same thing. Best. Bruce Verhei > On 03/18/2021 8:21 PM

RE: Different Levels of protection open to each other in the same hazard

2021-03-18 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
I’d ask why. Is the fire sprinkler system acting as detection system for a smoke exhaust system? Best. Bruce Verhei > On 03/18/2021 8:05 PM Travis Mack via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > > We've had cases where the 2 story volume area is required to be protected > from the 1st floor

Re: CPVC Drops in Seismic Areas

2021-03-02 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
I’d always been skeptical of the adequacy of two seismic allowances in 13/13-R/13-D. After following up lots of spk system breaks post-Nisqually Earthquake I changed my mind. 1. Those long one or two head drops from roof level in a tilt-up to office build outs, including hard ceilings in

Re: MORE ACTIVITY WEIGHING IN

2021-02-16 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
We used to require the 2.5 pounds/sf as part of the building permit application, if sprinkler permit application was a deferred permit. We also required the structural engineer to state restrictions on point loads. Before ESFR the common sprinkler designs were 0.39 gpm/sf over 5,600 sf or

Re: When is a Remote FDC required

2021-02-11 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
Talk with the fire plans reviewer. > On 02/11/2021 7:41 PM Jerry Van Kolken via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > > I'm doing a project for Cal State, and I'm trying find the code that would > dictate when an FDC needs to be remotely located away from the building. I > seem to remember a

RE: Tissue Paper Wrapped in Plastic

2021-02-06 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
Roll paper is not toilet paper. Roll paper is one of three forms. Jumbos. These are the width of the paper machine (drying unit). Temporary, to be cut again at the pulp or paper mill. 13-25 tons. I may be out of date here. On an expensive steel spindle. Paper that is finished material, often

Re: Area Increases

2021-01-26 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
Kevin, Do FM data sheets now reflect results of these tests? Best. Bruce Verhei > On 01/26/2021 2:02 PM Kevin Hall via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > > There is an active FPRF project that addresses storage occupancies and > sloped ceilings. It is currently in its third phase, and there has

Re: Diesel Fuel Tank - Leak Protection

2020-11-24 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
. > On 11/20/2020 7:50 PM Kenneth Berman via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > > steel fuel lines are good. Use super dope, no tape. NFPA used to require a > check valve in the fuel return, I still put it in the line. Old habits. > > On Fri, Nov 20, 2020 at 5:07 PM BRUCE V

Re: Diesel Fuel Tank - Leak Protection

2020-11-20 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
I’m mostly impressed you have an owner who cares. Best. Bruce Verhei > On 11/20/2020 4:19 PM Kyle.Montgomery via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > > Our standard for diesel fire pumps is to provide a double-wall fuel tank with > leak detection, steel supply and return fuel lines, and of course

Re: Domestic Demands 13R

2020-11-12 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
This is why I hate calling one point on a flow test curve Static. It’s really Background or Normal Usage or something similar. The domestic flow only really matters when have a joint water supply connection for the domestic and spk system. Out at the main someone else is doing fire flow

RE: Class IA Flammable Liquids

2020-11-09 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
1. Previous talk about 1-A being uncommon. If I received an HMIS that showed enough quantity to drive control measures I’d apply some skeptical focus. Is it really 1-A? Often not. While characterization of characterization of combustible or flammable liquids is the easiest of any hazard class,

Re: Fire pump suction diffusers

2020-10-22 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
FF’s have used them for years in the fol-da-tank series. Do the same people make one for fixed tank? Best. Bruce Verhei > On 10/22/2020 3:11 PM Prahl, Craig/GVL via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > > 2019 edition of NFPA 20 has references to the acceptable use of suction > diffusers on fire

RE: Self-storage Lockers

2020-10-15 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
I haven’t seen this. Are people putting a cage on the head? Best. Bruce Verhei > On 10/15/2020 2:02 PM John Irwin via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > > I have done a lot of these in many jurisdictions and never protected the > lockers. I have not been asked about it yet. > > I do protect

RE: [EXTERNAL] Seed Cleaning Plant

2020-10-15 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
To expand on Mark’s comment, I tend to think start at the dust safety first, then sprinklers. I wasn’t bidding jobs, but I certainly saw some expensive solutions going the other way. Best. Bruce Verhei > On 10/15/2020 5:54 PM Mark.Phelps via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > > What Craig said,

Re: pharmacy

2020-10-10 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
Once it’s C of O is issued fire prevention isn’t needed for a new lease. New fixtures don’t need a building permit. Some building officials require a new C of O, some don’t. It might never get an FP inspection. Depending on location would an engine company inspection catch the the clothing

Re: pharmacy

2020-10-10 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
First thing I’d have asked one of my inspectors is racks or shelves. Bruce Verhei > On 10/09/2020 8:23 PM Mark Phillips via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > > Agree > The amount of stored items and the variety > > > Sent from my mobile device > Please excuse spelling, grammar, and auto

Re: Small Hose Stations

2020-09-27 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
All of a sudden I’m worried we’re adding a potential for seismic damage to system, maybe several down a large building. It’s bad enough breaking 1” low point drains. Best. Bruce Verhei > On 09/27/2020 7:50 PM Jeff Normand via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > > Ideally supply hose stations

RE: [EXTERNAL] RE: On/Off Switch in the Electric supply to a Dry Pipe System Air Compressor

2020-09-25 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
umps: charge a whole lot of money for that red paint. > > -Kyle M > > -Original Message----- > From: Sprinklerforum On > Behalf Of BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum > Sent: Friday, September 25, 2020 12:24 PM > To: sprinklerforum@lists.firesprinkler.org > Cc: BRU

RE: On/Off Switch in the Electric supply to a Dry Pipe System Air Compressor

2020-09-25 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
Ah, you folks are all used to UL listing for fire protection. Remember UL listing goes down two paths. One is both safety and efficacy. You want that fire alarm panel to operate to standards, as well as not shock you or start a fire. The other is a table lamp. UL is evaluating it for shock &

RE: Ethanol unloading exposure protection

2020-09-02 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
Is this crossing the line to engineering? My radar would go up on this one. Best. Bruce Verhei > On 09/02/2020 2:25 PM tstone52--- via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > > Ben, > Try FM data Sheets 7-29 & or 7-88 > > Regards, > G. Tim Stone >   > G. Tim Stone Consulting, LLC > NICET Level III

Re: Question

2020-08-26 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
I used these codes in a seismic zone. I’m not familiar with any local amendments. Are you asking about building code importance factor for seimic design to be applied to tank design? Best. Bruce Verhei > On 08/26/2020 12:05 PM Gipson, Russell via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > > I work

RE: [EXTERNAL] Re: Window Sprinklers

2020-08-25 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
Further proof that you can obtain a license to practice architecture without understanding what listing a product means. Wishfulness does not overcome proven knowledge. Best. > On 08/25/2020 10:40 AM Prahl, Craig/GVL via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > > I wouldn't install a non-conforming

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: Testing of existing systems

2020-08-19 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
Ron’s proposal is appropriate if AHJ driving hydro is other than a fire marshal’s office. If you’ve bought a 1970 building, there are no current tenants with property to damage, assuring current condition might be a good idea. Unless single new taps are supplying the code minimum number of

Re: Missing hydraulic data plates

2020-08-06 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
You might find the local fire marshal’s office has copy of test cert, and original plans. Best. Bruce Verhei > On 08/06/2020 8:07 PM Mark Phillips via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > > Hello forum friends > I would like to get some other professionals methods on how they handle > missing

RE: Pump Suction Pressure (NPSH)

2020-08-06 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
I’d always used 20 psi as minimum pump in;et pressure, unless taking supply from a tank. Everywhere you go in AWWA you run into 20 psi as minimum pressure in the water system. Best. Bruce Verhei > On 08/06/2020 2:54 PM Kyle.Montgomery via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > > These two options

Re: Definition of Non-Combustible for hydraulic fluid

2020-07-12 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
The code change that allowed elimination of heads is a couple decades old. We were confused about meaning. I’d like to say I can remember who I talked with or have notes. I don’t. I know the re-emphasis by FM concerning both heated and unheated combustible liquids being aerosolized by high

RE: [EXTERNAL] RE: Floor area less than required

2020-06-18 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
For the record some of us like engineers. Best. Bruce > On 06/17/2020 8:34 AM Dennis Wilson via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > > > Don’t you just love them engineers!!! > > > > > > > > From: Sprinklerforum On > Behalf Of Bob Knight via Sprinklerforum >

Re: Structural Load

2020-06-04 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
Skyler We used to see WSRB or FM jobs with 0.39 gpm/sf over 5,600 sf as standard warehouse design. Based on previous engineers comments we normally said structural plans had to reserve 2.5 lbs/sf for sprinklers where they were deferred permit, which was always. 2.5 was conservative.

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: mattress storage

2020-06-04 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
I’ve seen what about 50 of these stored, on side in a non-sprinklered building can do, after fire. Furniture store, just opened up for day. Units behind a partial height storeroom wall. Old CMU, timber truss auto sales bldg from 1920’s. About 120’ x 100’. At first whiff of smoke the evacuated.

Re: Water Supply Test

2020-06-03 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
I’m a little cautious without seeing a sketch to make sure I’m seeing the situation correctly, but yes, I’ve used alternate connection locations for the gauge. i know my water department has made a pair of matching taps on matching dead ends so we could make a series of test prior to major

RE: Covered Parking in 13R

2020-05-30 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
The host organization of this forum has in the past, and sprinkler industry as a whole, advocated for fire codes that allow trade offs for sprinklers. They got ‘me. The deal is now each trade-off is a choice that owner-architect needs to explicitly make. This might be surprising to most of

Re: Covered Parking in 13R

2020-05-30 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
Yes. This is part of the building plan review. If I was the fire plan reviewer answer to this question would be on the first sheet of the approved building plans, with code cites. Yes, I’ve had a bunch of spk designers displeased with me over such issues. The Building and Fire reviewer can

Re: [External] Re: I-B construction - ABS plumbing piping

2020-05-21 Thread BRUCE VERHEI via Sprinklerforum
I can’t comment on the situation above the ceiling. Is this project, ‘bidder design’, shorthand for ‘building and systems design is by committee that never meets? Best. Bruce Verhei > On May 21, 2020 at 3:04 PM Ron Greenman via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > I'm going to do a stupid thing

Re: Insulation on Valve Risers

2020-04-14 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
I also had some luck convincing facilities installing non-code required generators to include valve room heat in circuits powered. Air compressor. FACU as well of course. Tiny draw. Best. > On Apr 14, 2020, at 13:13, Reed A. Roisum, SET via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > Check out FMDS 8-29

Re: Insulation on Valve Risers

2020-04-14 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
I was always more concerned that the valve room was insulated, to slow cooling during power outage. Are you attempting to keep the pipe interior cold? This would seem to be result of insulating it in the heated room, at least downstream of valves. Best. Bruce Verhei > On Apr 14, 2020, at

Re: CFC / NFPA Changes

2020-04-10 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
I know that when this section came along there was a certain skepticism to six heads only. Especially given the near witchcraft process of how this change for quick response reduction in light hazard was created. It’s right there with how 30’ x 30’ was she as standard spot smoke detector

Re: COVID-19

2020-04-09 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
In theory shut down in WA State unless response oriented construction. I’ve seen one pickup at 4 over 2 project across from my pharmacy. Security? One lone superintendent keeping it rain resistant? Elsewhere around town? I don’t know. One trip each of last two weeks. Did take a fifteen mile

Re: Curbs for Containment

2020-04-09 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
If it’s containers more than de minimus curbs are poor practice. Going up an over a 20” dike with forklift is in the real world a classic cause of spills. Sumps or a tank are much better. Added benefit is for spills generation of flammable vapors is related to surface area, not volume. Cover a

Re: Curbs for Containment

2020-04-09 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
Spill control is single largest vessel. Secondary containment is spill control plus 20 minutes sprinkler flow. ...plus the design flow volume of fire protection water calculated to discharge from the fire-extinguishing system over the minimum required system design area or area of the room or

Re: IBC 1406.3

2020-04-08 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
When 13-R came along fire spread up balconies, into each unit, through the bird blocking and into the attic was a still fire scenario. Operating one or two dozen heads became a real thing. That said I don’t have an answer for your question. Best. > On Apr 8, 2020, at 16:39, Matt Grise via

Re: NFPA 13D

2020-03-28 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
Do hang the HVAC from the CPVC. Not just taking it off. Ever wonder how codes get thicker and thicker. One way is more pre-approved design options. The other. Needing to write this kind of into code. Simple question. Will HVAC firm post photo on their homepage as example work their proud

Re: Minimum Lead-in Sizing

2020-03-19 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
CPVC has been used for U/G for quite a while now. Has either the NFPA or manufacturer’s guidelines been updated to include measures for line locating? We used City engineering standards for any underground in easement along public streets to get it until local industry more or less made it

Re: [EXTERNAL] MPP Floor Panels

2020-03-19 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
Is there a 1 1/2” to 2” aerated concrete layer on top of the flooring? Best Sent from my iPhone > On Mar 19, 2020, at 11:35, Prahl, Craig/GVL via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > Sounds like the flooring wouldn’t be a determining factor for sprinklers but, > what is being routed through the

Re: Minimum Lead-in Sizing

2020-03-18 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
I always hated seeing 4”, reduced to 2” or 1 1/2”. 4” DDCVA, 4” PIV. Absurd for a four head design. Best. > On Mar 18, 2020, at 10:37, Travis Mack, SET, CFPS, CWBSP, RME-G via > Sprinklerforum wrote: > > When shared fire / domestic, you have to add the domestic at the split when > supply is

Re: low flow residential head replacement

2020-03-11 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
Have you asked the local fire prevention office if they have plans? If you thought they’d be helpful I’d also ask about calc’s. Especially if they’d been digitized they’d likely be retained as separate documents. I wouldn’t assume counter person answering question would understand inherent

Re: How are you guys handling calcs for 13R balconies?

2020-03-06 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
https://www-dailyherald-com.cdn.ampproject.org/c/s/www.dailyherald.com/amp-article/20200221/news/200229736/ Balcony fire, spk head. > On Mar 6, 2020, at 13:11, Pete Schwab via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > We only calculate the single balcony in question. > > > Peter Schwab > VP of

Re: How are you guys handling calcs for 13R balconies?

2020-03-06 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
Another balcony head operation. https://www.linkedin.com/posts/national-fire-sprinkler-association_virginia-beach-fire-crews-tackle-balcony-activity-6640255799157415938-wDnl It takes a moment to fully open. If you go to the second photo, then scroll over to 7th photo you get best shot of

Re: Dedicated space in Electrical Rooms per NEC Article 110

2020-03-06 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
Good afternoon. We’ve heard this discussed for years. The #13 committee has over the years issued Formal Interpretations. Does the #70 committee do the same? Is there one or two in record? Best. Bruce > On Mar 6, 2020, at 11:08, Steve Leyton via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > Awesome

Top Loading Storage Arrays

2020-03-03 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
SFPE article. Best. Bruce https://tinyurl.com/toploadrobots ___ Sprinklerforum mailing list Sprinklerforum@lists.firesprinkler.org http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org

Re: Quick FM question

2020-03-03 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
To my knowledge the reduction in area was not based on a fire test series as would be typical FM practice. My memory is it was done in part to encourage use of QR sprinklers. At time they were still a buck or two more expensive/hd. Best. Bruce > On Mar 3, 2020, at 07:55, BILL MENSTER via

Re: Combustible dust collector

2020-02-24 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
Flamex has been around for several decades, I believe under a couple different corporate ownerships. It is not a new technology. I’m more used to seeing as part of an overall dust explosion control system. Usually I’ve worked with a mechanical engineer whose specialty is dust explosion

Re: Combustible dust collector

2020-02-24 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
> On Feb 24, 2020, at 08:03, Skyler Bilbo via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > I have a little experience with this. I have seen a system brand called > "Flamex" on the dust collection ducts. This system uses flame sensors and > solenoids to extinguish a fire in the duct, which is a better

Re: Occupancy class each room?

2020-02-06 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
I didn’t. The only time it’d be an issue was if building permit plans hadn’t been approved, and there is some ongoing controversy with owner or architect over occupancy classification, especially H or not H. It may be that I worked in an office with a particularly close relationship with our

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: Shell Spaces and Bushed Outlets

2020-02-05 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
K-17. That’s a little different than I expect. I always thought more like parts of a strip mall building that might end up OH-2. Best. > On Feb 5, 2020, at 07:58, Kyle.Montgomery via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > That’s the crux of my question. A literal interpretation could say that the >

Re: [EXTERNAL] IBC "throughout"

2020-02-01 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
To add to Ch Blackwell’s comments, at start of fire plan review one task is fire flow calc’s. This is to determine in part minimum water required from the municipal water system, at 20 psi, number and spacing of hydrants, based on type of construction, size of building and so on. The sprinkler

Re: Valves in dry systems

2020-01-31 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
The AHJ would ask sign noting system supplies both bldg’s and also note at riser showing location of second shut off, at valve if not obvious, with NORMALLY OPEN text. Best. Bruce > On Jan 31, 2020, at 07:35, Tim Stone via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > Todd, > There are couple of existing

Revised UL Smoke Alarm standard

2020-01-29 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
All: I know this isn’t spk’s, but family and friends expect us to be current in such fire safety basics. Discussion of new standards for smoke alarms in the U.S. They almost get to point of saying smoke alarm has several sensors, and uses algorithm to compare signatures to cooking smoke and

Re: Overhead / Friction Loss

2020-01-28 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
Maybe this is obvious to you designers vs just a plans reviewer. Wouldn’t you estimate x psi vs y % psi? Are you supporting use of a smaller underground? Best. > On Jan 28, 2020, at 11:15, Richard Carr via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > 15% is good for a tree, 8-10% if it is a grid. > >

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: NFPA 13, 23.1.3 (37)

2020-01-15 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
NAL] Re: NFPA 13, 23.1.3 (37) >>> >>> >>> >>> Are you familiar with the term ‘C.O.J.’? >>> >>> >>> >>> Heheheh… >>> >>> >>> >>> Just in case you aren’t, it’s not dirty or an

Re: NFPA 13, 23.1.3 (37)

2020-01-13 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
I’ve never drawn up a fab order. I always assumed you’d need this information. Do I get it wrong. Best. Bruce Verhei > On Jan 13, 2020, at 06:15, Prahl, Craig/GVL via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > I’m curious why there is any confusion over this? > > Example: If you have sprinklers on

Re: [EXTERNAL] Campus type water supply

2019-12-23 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
I was involved with master plan for multi-building complex. Adjacent parcel, by same owner, contained 3mg above ground municipal water tank. 12” in/out. Lots of water at the minimum design water pressure for fire flow, i.e. 20 psi. Nowhere near enough pressure for three story building or some

Re: Sprinkler in garage closet understairs.

2019-12-05 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
I assume stairs have the typical rated GWB protection on under side. No spk required. Best. Bruce Verhei Sent from my iPhone > On Dec 5, 2019, at 14:07, Steve Leyton via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > I don’t disagree with JD’s disagreement on a purely statutory basis (i.e. the > letter of

Re: [EXTERNAL] RE: Trouble getting Architects to give Revit files

2019-12-04 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
Ken You left off the provided flow curve is for job in another town. Bruce > On Dec 4, 2019, at 19:20, John Drucker via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > Partial Releases only add to the problem. If architects were required to > submit only complete packages for permitting, ie sprinklers,

Re: UPDATE! Water purveyor requiring fire flow test for 13D calcs

2019-11-27 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
> > -Original Message- > From: firstin--- via Sprinklerforum > To: sprinklerforum > Cc: firstin ; Bruce Verhei > Sent: Tue, Nov 19, 2019 2:38 pm > Subject: Re: [EXTERNAL] Not required, requirement > > Ha! I was wondering. > > Sent from my iPhone > &

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: Cane Detection

2019-11-22 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
David Thanks. When I advocated italicization of defined terms to ICC, as some other standards were already being done, they jumped at it. At the time I think they wanted all code language and style comments to come from outside their staff. From the reaction I think staff had already wanted

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: Cane Detection

2019-11-22 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
I’d hope nothing is done that prevents use as even a non-designated area of refuge. > On Nov 22, 2019, at 12:30, Nick Maneen via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > I hope then when you combine what Ed Kramer and David Blackwell provided > someone sees reason. > > Nick Maneen, SET > c

Re: [EXTERNAL] Not required, requirement

2019-11-19 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
he power > yet very little knowledge and training) who is just passing through on the > promotional track. Very frustrating. > > Sent from my iPhone > >> On Nov 18, 2019, at 11:28 PM, Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum >> wrote: >> >> I don’t get it. It’s

Re: [EXTERNAL] Not required, requirement

2019-11-18 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
I don’t get it. It’s not off a home well. > On Nov 18, 2019, at 20:24, firstin--- via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > The water purveyor does the test at a cost of $600 plus the delay waiting for > it to get done. > > We all know how things can evolve over time as people in different positions

NFPA 30-B, Plastic Cans, FMGlobal Full Scale test.

2019-11-12 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
FMGlobal tests of container type novel to me. Best. Bruce Verhei https://www.fmglobal.com/research-and-resources/standards-and-certification/~/media/4A15FE3BE13A4110BAA7F8231884A7ED.ashx ___ Sprinklerforum mailing list

Re: Aerosol determinations

2019-11-08 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
regattion where an owner is wanting to shelve aerosols > on a racking area of appx. 17,720 square feet on one end of his warehouse. > > > -Original Message----- > From: Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum > To: sprinklerforum > Cc: Bruce Verhei > Sent: Fri, Nov

Re: Aerosol determinations

2019-11-08 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
; On Nov 8, 2019, at 12:42, Shawn Chapman via Sprinklerforum >> wrote: >> >> Bruce, Am I understanding correctly that unlabeled would mean level 1? >> Softest form of sprinkler coverage? >> >> >> >> -Original Message- >> From: Bruce

Re: Aerosol determinations

2019-11-08 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
nderstanding correctly that unlabeled would mean level 1? > Softest form of sprinkler coverage? > > > > -Original Message----- > From: Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum > To: sprinklerforum > Cc: Bruce Verhei > Sent: Fri, Nov 8, 2019 3:28 pm > Subject: Re: Aerosol de

Re: Aerosol determinations

2019-11-08 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
MSDS are not designed or intended to provide information needed for building or fire code compliance. ... Part of the IFC requires each carton to be labeled by the manufacturer. If it’s not labeled, it is protected to Class III. This is explicit in the code. I worked at town with lots of

Re: 13D GPM to use?

2019-11-01 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
Good afternoon. Is AHJ confused with 13-R? Did someone one the owner’s side say they wanted a four head design for their 12,000 sf, three generation home? My water dept’s would not have let a meter with that Q of water through the domestic meter. A large enough meter would undercount hundred

Re: [EXTERNAL] Trying to determine hydrant locations per IFC, wondering how sprinkler coverage omissions will affect distances.

2019-10-24 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
I’d agree with Ed. It is likely quite a bit of conversation has already occurred. The reviewer is already trying to get to minimum needed. Best. Bruce Verhei > On Oct 24, 2019, at 21:44, Ed Vining via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > A talk with the AHJ would be better than headache later > .

Re: Fire Alarm plan checklist

2019-10-23 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
I had a wide range of what I expected for fire alarm. There is so much more variety that with spk’s. There’s a reason I got Architect of Record to sign a system design criteria sheet before building permit approval. Then the G.C. had a document with architect and fire plan review’s signature to

Re: Hotel washroom & closets

2019-10-15 Thread Bruce Verhei via Sprinklerforum
We had an Extended Stay America that had commonly had units rented long term. It was a hotel for our purposes. People may have been gone on weekends, but some stuff was in the room. Best. Bruce Verhei > On Oct 15, 2019, at 17:15, Fpdcdesign via Sprinklerforum > wrote: > > I don’t recall

  1   2   >